The Board of Zoning Appeals, in 2019, heard 22 Development Standards Variance petitions, compared to 20 in 2018. Thirty Six (36%) percent of these development standard variance applications were multi-part, containing several requests. In total, the Board of Zoning appeals heard requests for 29 different petitions. This year the BZA also heard 7 Special Exception requests, which is three times more than in 2018.
The case for 1851 W CR 400 N by Atlantic Sign Company was heard on 2/12/2019 and received an Approval with Conditions form the Board of Zoning Appeals. There was a sign that resided on the site since 2006, but since then, has been structurally compromised and needed removed. This Special Exception Use allowed for a new pole sign within the “Interstate Corridor” as prescribed under UDO 5.58(Q).
A continuation of BZA 2019-01 (also heard on 2/12/2019), this case addressed the approval of a Development Standard Variance from UDO 5.58.Q.3.c. This is a request to erect a sign larger than what is suggested by the UDO. This also recieved an Approval with Conditions by the board.
This case is requesting three Development Standards Variances for a property that was constructed by John Hamilton in 1853 (132 W Washington Street), with the current owner looking at restoration of the home. The variances that were heard on 2/12/2019 for the following:
This property is a vacant lot (Lot 7) in the Lakeside Addition (1851 Culbertson Road). This case requested, and received Approval for, multiple Development Standards Variances to allow for a shorter front yard setback, increased lot coverage, and addition of a second driveway. The variances that were heard on 3/12/2019 for the following:
The Golden Bear Preschool & Administration Office had requested a Special Exception Use for an Electronic Message Center (EMC) during the 3/12/2019 hearing. This EMC exception was examined under UDO 5.58 to accommodate for an approximately 18 square foot sign, and received Approval by the board.
This site (101 Tindall Drive) was previously replatted in PC 2019-05 and was being observed by Greenleaf Foods for development of a plant-based protein manufacturing building. This Special Exception Use petition is looking at the approval to have a “Food and Beverage Production” under the General Industrial (IG) District through its “special exception use” standards. This case received Approval by the Board of Zoning Appeals during the 5/14/2019 hearing.
This case was also heard on 5/14/2019, and is a continuation of BZA 2019-06 with this Development Standard Variance observing UDO 5.32.A.1.b; which similarly received Approval. Greenleaf in this petition was requesting a variance from installing planting on the north side of the site due to the areas future use of trailer storage and expansion of the building.
This site (located at 596 Chestnut Street) contains a mobile home park established form the 1950’s. The current company has purchased the park and removed unrepairable trailers, garbage and debris, and is making site improvements. With these changes, the request for a Development Standards Variance was needed to reduce the minimum living area per dwelling from 900 square feet to 700 square feet. The hearing date was held on 5/14/2019, and this case received an Approval by the BZA.
A submission for a Site Development Plan by Tom Gallagher/Hoosier Energy was examined by the Board of Zoning Appeals during this time to accommodate for a new substation (PC 2019-07). In reference to the five requests for Development Standards Variances, this case is looking at the specific variances needed for that substation (located at 1982 W County Road 300 N). The variances heard on 5/28/2019 were for the following:
A Site Development Plan was submitted to the Plan Commission (PC 2019-12) to allow for a self-storage facility located at 1414 E State Road 44. This BZA case is looking at the variances in which the owner was requesting for the case. There were four Development Standards Variances being observed for changes in façades, roofs/parapets, maximum primary structures, and number of parking spaces. The variances heard on 7/9/2019 were for the following:
This property is a single-family residence in the McCooley Addition. The owner is requesting a Development Standards Variance for UDO 5.55.B.1, the Setback Standards for an accessory structure, to reduce the standard by four feet within the front yard setback. This request was heard on 8/13/2019 and had received Approval by the board.
This case is a request for a Development Standards Variance for the Planned Development Designation of Permanent Open Space (UDO 4.07) located at 150 W Washington Street. The City of Shelbyville asked for a reduction to 5% of permanent open space, which is more comparable to traditional Single-Family Residential neighborhoods. The Board of Zoning Appeals heard the case on 11/12/2019 and gained an Approval.
In PC 2019-20 the petitioner submitted a Site Development Plan for new construction of a convenience store and gas station (3899 N Michigan Road). This BZA submission is in cohesion to that PC case, the request for this case is to allow fuel sales in conjunction with a convenience restaurant/store. This petition made by Giant Eagle Inc. had received Approval during the 11/12/2019 hearing.
The BZA examined a Special Exception Use for a downtown parking garage located at 17 & 23 Public Square. The exception was to allow for a parking garage within the Business Central District. This case, made by Genesis Property Group, was heard and received Approval on 12/10/2019.
The Development Standards Variance for this site coincides with PC 2019-22: construction of a new gas station and convenience store at 1804-1810 N Riley Highway. The variance for this case references UDO 5.15.B, Non-residential Driveway Standards. The petition is to allow an increase in the road standards to allow for forty (40) foot truck entrances instead of the standard thirty-six (36) feet. This case received Approval by the BZA during the 12/10/2019 hearing.
In addition to the previous variances for the site, a Special Exception Use petition was applied to accommodate for a sign pole in the Business Highway District. This also received Approval by the board.
In addition to the prior Special Exception Use, the petitioner also requested a development standard variance to increase the square footage of the sign size to 550 square feet. This again received Approval.
The First Presbyterian Church requested a Special Exception Use to construct a electronic message center at their 124 West Broadway facility. Electronic Message Centers are only allowed via special exception by the Shelbyville Board of Zoning Appeals. The board gave Approval during the 1/14/2020 hearing.