How to Conduct Your Own Round Analysis

If you are watching a video from the NSDA Resource Library to practice (I have some already linked for you to the left), follow these steps: 

1. Flow the Round: Grab a piece of paper, split it into Proposition and Opposition columns, and vertically track every argument, cross-ex concession, and response.

2. Pause and Predict: Pause the video right before a rebuttal speech. Give yourself 60 seconds of prep time, outline what you would say to defend or attack the case, and then resume the video to see how the national-level competitor handled it.

3. Evaluate the Ballot: Act as the judge. Before watching who wins or reading the ballot comments, write down your own RFC (Reason for Decision) based strictly on which debater defended their framework more cohesively.

When watching a round, track the timing rigorously. Because EXD is a fast, one-on-one format with unique current events resolutions assigned right before the round, look for how effectively debaters utilize their limited clocks: [

• Proposition Constructive (2 mins): Evaluate if the speaker establishes a clear framework and 2–3 concise contentions backed by high-quality, efficient evidence. 

• Cross-Examination of Proposition (1 min): Observe if the Opposition asks pointed, brief questions rather than giving speeches. 

• Opposition Constructive (2 mins): Check if the speaker successfully splits their time between building their own case and attacking the Proposition's core contentions. 

• Cross-Examination of Opposition (1 min): Analyze how the Prop forces the Opp to defend vulnerabilities exposed in their speech.