Class community norms (co-generated and revised as necessary)
These agreements became important guidelines for working through some difficult moments when we had to negotiate different uses and interpretations of language and terms.
Remind ourselves of the community norms regularly
When there’s a difficult conversation -- there might be differences in opinions -- how to say I respectfully disagree--say “ouch” as a way to indicate disagreement, take a pause to check in, we can come back to something as well
Create a space where people feel heard and we can challenge people
If you don’t understand something, ask “can you elaborate, provide more clarification?”
Meet people where they are, acknowledge that we all come from different backgrounds, we’re all learning together
Don’t freeze others or yourself in time
Put personal experiences within broader group level patterns and context
We might need to differentiate on an ongoing basis what is a personal/individual narrative and what are broader patterns
Keep personal stories confidential and share lessons
Paying attention to sharing space
Accountability is key but we want to keep thinking about how to do it
What are our collective expectations about how we want to hold each other accountable and who will hold each other accountable?
What are we holding ourselves accountable to?
Community norms
Listening to understand, not to respond
We went to visit a high school in Minneapolis--one of the teachers is a fellow organizer of EdLibMN--and she arranged for her students to take our students on a tour of their school. This happened during the week when we were focusing on carcerality and the built environment. Students reflected on their visit connecting the visit to their own schooling experiences and course readings and themes (posts are lightly edited for clarity):
“I really appreciated visiting [XX] High School, and I found a lot of similarities between it and my old high school. As someone who also went to a school designed by a prison architect, I was comfortable in this building, and I related to the gripes that students had about their school building (no windows!!!). Although I felt like it was normal, I had to step back and remember that this architecture is not natural; it reeks of carceral logic. When the students took us on tours, they needed a signed hall pass to explain their presence in the halls, and the only entrance was heavily surveilled. The building was technically open, but there were a lot of restrictions on who could leave, thereby restricting the freedom of younger students and of students with GPAs under 2.0. It seemed like accessing the liberty that they ostensibly had was often difficult. Also, I may be drawing too much meaning out of this, but the students who were giving me a tour never took me to the third floor. We stayed in the parts of the building where they were more familiar, which was the area with more restrictions. In this space for predominantly BIPOC youth, I saw the school-to-prison nexus at play in many of the ways that Bettina Love and Damien Sojoyner outline.”
“I think that as the instructors, y'all chose for us to see this school because of the assumptions that are made about the school both by ourselves prior to visiting the school or by the larger community about the culture and students within the school. From the outside looking in, it could've been very easy to write the school off and make assumptions about the nature of the school and the students who are within the school without ever having stepped foot into the school. As someone who comes from a community and neighborhood very similar to the one that was surrounding [XX] High School, I knew that the school wouldn't be anything like the negative reports or connotations that are out there about the school. However, because of my identity and background, I am also very aware that because of the demographics of the community, the location of the school, as well as the build of the school, it is very easy to make assumptions about how the school might be without ever going in. A prime example was when we were talking to the students, and they began talking about the news reports that were recently coming out about their school. That the students do drugs there, they were criminals (steal cars and other criminal reports), that they aren't intelligent and so forth. When that wasn't the case at all.”
Anita & students at field trip site
Legislation and discipline policies in schools, March 27, 2024 (contact us if you want more of our lesson plans)
Storytelling for justice framework by Lee Anne Bell
We reviewed this framework with the students to understand different kinds of stories told about ourselves, our communities, and our societies: stock, concealed, resistance, and emerging/transformative stories. In one of our classes, students analyzed stories being told in Minnesota about Ethnic Studies through this framework.
Ethnic Studies Stock Stories
Ethnic Studies Concealed Stories
Ethnic Studies Resistance Stories
Ethnic Studies Emerging/Transformative Stories
Sample posters from the Student Data Gallery Walk activity
Student data gallery walk
Marika brought to campus (in the rain!) part of the gallery walk about data and digital surveillance in schools that TCIA adapted from the work of Parent Toolkit for Student Privacy. Our students read through the posters and reflected on these questions:
What did you notice that was new information?
What was old information that you now see in a different way?
How does seeing this information from kindergarten to graduation make you feel?
What questions does it raise for you?
Do you know what kinds of information have been collected about you by your schools (including Carleton)?
Do you know what Carleton’s data privacy policy is? Or your K-12 schools?
Will you change any of your behaviors in the future based on this information?
Zine page
In one of the classes, we all read this zine about the school to prison pipeline by Rachel Marie-Crane Willams. In class, we asked the students to add a page to the zine about their understanding of the school to prison nexus.
Zine pages created by students