1981
Eileen Reilly
1991
Cindy Beltran
1992
Cindy Beltran
1993
Jodi Wiebolt
1994
Lyndsey Caverly
Janene Leinweber
1995
Lyndsey Caverly
Janene Leinweber
Jen Yanchosky
1996
Lyndsey Caverly
1997
Kristina D’Antonio
Crystal Petraccoro
1998
Kristina D’Antonio
Crystal Petraccoro
1999
Kristina D’Antonio
Crystal Petraccoro
Kelly Brady
Shannon Plunkett
2000
Kelly Brady
Shannon Plunkett
2001
Tierney Brady
2002
Tierney Brady
2003
Jessica Fuccello
2004
Jessica Fuccello
Shana Brady
2005
Jessica Fuccello
Caitlin Toomey
Mallory Baker
2006
Jourdan Thompson
Christina Cuffari
2007
Jourdan Thompson
Christina Cuffari
2008
Caitlin Conway
Jordan Downs
2009
Jordan Downs
2010
Jordan Downs
Ricky Suhl
2021
Izzy Hernandez
2023
Chloe Gellici
Giselle Lizardi
2024
Brooke DeAlemida