Testimonials: 2020–2021

English 12 Students Reflect on the Makerspace

Collected and shared in June of 2021. See more testimonials by clicking here: sisyphean-high/testimonials.

The Myth of the "Non-Academic"

Ken Robinson’s “Changing Education Paradigms” is one of the first things students are shown when they enter Room 210. A copy of the RSA Animate version of it even hands on the wall in the classroom. It is inspirational, especially toward the end.

We have to think differently about human capacity. We have to get over this old conception of academic, non-academic, abstract, theoretical, vocational, and see it for what it is — a myth. Second, you have to recognize that most great learning happens in groups, that collaboration is the stuff of growth. If you atomize people and separate them and judge them separately, we form a kind of disjunction between them and their natural learning environment. And thirdly, it’s crucially about the culture of our institutions, the habits of institution and the habitats that they occupy.

At its heart, Robinson’s purpose is to encourage a change in the culture and habits of schools. He argues that this requires a more individualized, responsive view of student potential; a focus on group learning and collaboration; and a reconnection between students and their learning environments.

He also calls out a myth: that some students are "academic," while others are "non-academic." Early in his talk, he highlights the way education has split students this way — see the image to the right.

This makerspace levels the ground. The testimonials are the same. When it was eight of the top ten students, they spoke of the importance of eliminating traditional grades and shifting instruction and feedback. On this page, the students traditionally labeled "non-academic" agree.

Senior Testimonials: June, 2021

These are gleaned from student responses to a final essay prompt and a formative questionnaire. The latter led to as much insight as the essay prompt, so the responses were broken down into categories.

The questions are printed at the top of each column of responses. Student names are included with their permission. Each spreadsheet has commentary and notes on what students have written.

'21 Testimonials: Makerspace Pillars

Makerspace Pillars

These are the major shifts of the Humanities makerspace. You can read all about them at the course website.

Universal Skills and Traits

The elimination of traditional grades is responsible for most of the other major shifts in the space. Under the "Makerspace Pillars" category, you'll see students discussing the impact of grade abatement. In this section, they talk about the specific skills and traits evaluated through the system.

'21 Testimonials: Skills and Traits
'21 Reflections — MF

Final Reflections

Drive Folderhttps://tinyurl.com/21-testimonials-04

These are copies of senior essays — 14 essays that offer a cross section of the class. They have been given feedback that elaborates on the makerspace itself.

Embedded to the left is a final reflection from a student who was in Room 210 as a sophomore and again as a senior. 

Senior Talks

Below are reflections on the Senior Talk, which was the final project of the year. It reflects the makerspace ideals of skill-based, iterative work, and the final product can be showcased: https://sites.google.com/brewsterschools.org/senior-talks-2021.

The reflective writing has also been annotated to connect it to the innovations of the makerspace.

'21 Testimonials: Senior Talks

What If: Grade Abatement

Finally, a testimonial by way of hypothetical exercise:

This document details what would happen if the last month of high school was graded traditionally. The pandemic forced us all to change our stance on traditional grades — and that is an invitation to look at the efficacy of a space that already changed its stance.

The testimonials here (and elsewhere on this site) make more sense when you are familiar with the terms and conditions of this classroom, which has been on this particular path for the better part of a decade. The progress is made transparent.

Reading just this page, however, will still yield a wealth of information about improved feedback, greater investment in reading, more self-efficacy in writing, and better mental health.

For these students, the innovations of this makerspace offered opportunities they would not have otherwise had.

GAP Feedback: What If?