By Isaiah Donaldson, Daniel Cavalleros, and Kathryn Caudill
The North Atlantic Treaty, also called the Washington Treaty, founded the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) on April 4th, 1949 under the principle of collective security. NATO fostered greater military integration between the United States (US) and Western Europe, providing Western Europe the resources to deter growing influence from the Soviet Union (USSR) and its allies. Notably, Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty affirmed that an attack against one Member State in NATO would result in multilateral retaliation from each member. The cooperative security principle allowed NATO to fulfill its objectives of deterring Soviet influence, mitigating nationalist militarism, and integrating Europe as a political entity. Initially, NATO comprised 12 Member States, but has expanded to 32 Member States as of 2025.
The three principal committees of NATO include the North Atlantic Council (NAC), Nuclear Planning Group (NPG), and Military Committee (MC). Chaired by the NATO Secretary-General and composed of a delegation from each Member State, the NAC is NATO’s central political decision-making body. Discussions and decisions made within the NAC cover the full extent of the organization’s activities and stem from recommendations made by NATO committees. NAC decisions express the collective will of NATO’s Member States, as these decisions require unanimity. Furthermore, the Nuclear Planning Group (NPG) is a committee of NATO tasked with issuing policy relating to nuclear forces. Beyond the NAC and NPG, the Military Committee (MC) is NATO’s senior military authority. The MC provides consensus-based military policy and strategy advice to the other two principal committees, the NAC and NPG. This crucial link between the organization's political and military bodies allows for the conversion of political decisions and guidance into military direction. In addition to the central bodies, various specialized subordinate committees meet under the NAC to address subjects on the organization’s agenda.
Relations between NATO and the United Nations (UN) are well-established and reinforced by their joint commitment to the maintenance of international peace and security. In 2008, NATO and the UN signed a framework for expanded consultation and cooperation between the two bodies. This has allowed for extended collaboration and development toward practical relations relative to each organization’s specific mandates, areas of expertise, procedures, and capabilities. The UN and NATO work closely in policy areas including crisis management, arms control, and civil-military cooperation. This is evidenced by NATO and the UN’s collaboration in international operations like those seen in the UN Security Council (UNSC). UNSC resolutions have provided mandates for NATO operations, including S/RES/678 for Iraq in 1990, and S/RES/1386 for Afghanistan in 2001.
NATO has two primary budgets—civil and military—which is decided by its Budget Committee. NATO’s civil budget includes capital and programme expenditures, as well as the personnel and operating costs of its international staff at NATO headquarters, located in Brussels. NATO’s military budget includes money allocated towards the alliance’s integrated command structure and missions. NATO derives its funding from its members via direct and indirect contributions. Direct funding provides resources for NATO’s budget, programs and capabilities supporting its mandate, and activities including missions and alliance-wide command and control systems. These funds are taken from each member according to a cost share formula considering their Gross National Income (GNI) under the principle of “burden-sharing.” In 2025, NATO’s total direct funding amounts to USD 5.2 billion—of which, the US, Germany, United Kingdom, and France provide the most funds. Indirect funding includes troops or equipment donated to the organization on a voluntary basis by NATO’s members.
Throughout the Cold War—a period of tense stalemate between the US and USSR in the latter half of the 20th century—deterring Soviet influence remained the principal objective of NATO. However, the collapse of the USSR in the early 1990s forced NATO to adapt its mandate to a new geopolitical climate. In 1991, NATO issued the “Rome Declaration on Peace and Cooperation,” a declaration affirming NATO’s commitment to lasting security across Europe, beyond the borders of its Member States. To meet this objective, NATO established cooperation initiatives including the North Atlantic Cooperation Council (NACC) and the Partnership for Peace (PfP) program in the 1990s. After the attacks on the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, NATO invoked Article 5 for the first and only time. As a result, NATO members committed forces in Afghanistan as the military alliance oriented its focus towards counter-terrorism for the next two decades. NATO adapted its mandate once again in June 2020 after issuing the 2030 Initiative—an agenda highlighting NATO’s commitment to mitigating disinformation, the threat posed by Russia and China, and democratic backsliding.
The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region is a diverse and historic region encompassing six percent of the world’s population. There are 18 UN Member States—Bahrain, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Israel, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Libya, Morocco, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Tunisia, United Arab Emirates, and Yemen—that are always considered part of the MENA region. While nine Member States—Armenia, Azerbaijan, Djibouti, Malta, Mauritania, Somalia, Sudan, Türkiye and Western Sahara —are often, but not always, included in the MENA region. Palestine, despite its tenuous claim to statehood, is always considered part of the MENA region and will be diagnosed throughout this analysis. NATO’s mission to strengthen relations and alter strategy in the MENA region concerns all often included Member States. For decades, the MENA region broadly has been defined by its unstable security environment, conflict, and domestic terrorism. This creates challenges for NATO—an organization committed to security nationally and internationally—due to the potential for international insecurity to expand and create serious consequences for NATO Member States. Thus, NATO must reevaluate its past tactics and foster new connections in the MENA region to generate lasting international and national security.
Violence and instability were common occurrences within the MENA region in the mid-to-late 20th century. Embroiled in intractable conflict, Israel and Palestine clashed during the Six-Day War of 1967, Yom Kippur War of 1973, and First Intifada between 1987 and 1993. The 1979 Iranian Revolution was a bloody uprising that resulted in the overthrow of Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi. Subsequently, in the 1980s, roughly 500,000 militants and civilians died in the war between Iraq and Iran. From 1979 to 1989, between 800,000 and 2 million people died during the Soviet-Afghan War. Although NATO was concerned with the MENA region before the end of the Cold War between the US and USSR, it took a more active role in the region in the 1990s. Exemplifying this new policy objective, NATO indicated in its 1991 Strategic Concept that it wanted to build and maintain harmonious relations with the Middle East due to its burgeoning military posture and proximity to Europe. NATO’s contributions in the 1991 Gulf War inspired their objective of taking on a more active role—while NATO was not a direct participant, it provided administrative and air support to Türkiye, a regional partner at risk if the Gulf War conflict expanded across the MENA region. Furthermore, NATO deployed naval forces to secure the Mediterranean Sea, an important shipping route at risk from the conflict.
The 2000s and early 2010s were also a tumultuous period in the MENA region, introducing new threats to international security and various conflicts. In response to the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks perpetrated by the jihadist militant group al-Qaeda against the United States (US), NATO invoked Article 5—the collective defense principle—of the North Atlantic Treaty. Thereafter, the US led the multinational force, Operation Enduring Freedom, in October 2001 to topple the Taliban-led Afghanistan government and defeat al-Qaeda militants. However, the resulting war in Afghanistan proved unmanageable and lasted nearly 20 years. Furthermore, the invasion of Iraq in 2003 by NATO Member States and allies and subsequent occupation brought additional challenges. US forces introduced sweeping changes to Iraqi society by disbanding the military and removing government officials leftover from Saddam Hussein’s regime. While the US intended to dismantle the Hussein regime power structure and foster progress, the US was left short-handed in the absence of an Iraqi military or bureaucracy and was unable to impose security in Iraq, fostering resentment among Iraqi citizens. This social unrest paired with the insufficient rule of law emboldened terrorist organizations to take root in Iraq. Thus, the “War on Terror” undertaken by the US and NATO allies proved unsuccessful in mitigating terrorism and stabilizing the MENA region, demonstrating the negative consequences of an aggressive foreign policy approach.
Nonetheless, instability in the MENA region in the 2000s also originated from sources beyond al-Qaeda affiliates and NATO members. Hostility between Israel and the Palestinian Authority emanated during the “Second Intifada,” or Second Uprising. Beginning in 2000, tension escalated between the two parties, triggered by Palestinian resistance to extended Israeli occupation of East Jerusalem, resulting in thousands of deaths spanning both sides. Additionally, the violent tactics assumed by Sudanese militias in the Darfur region killed hundreds of thousands, displaced millions, and resulted in the genocide of various ethnic groups. Thus, this period in the MENA region accompanied significant instability and a need for more effective foreign policy.
In December 2010, pro-democracy protests spread across Tunisia and into the greater Arab world after 26-year old street vendor, Mohamed Bouazizi, self-immolated while protesting police harassment and governmental negligence. This series of protests, deemed the Arab Spring, overwhelmed MENA region Member States including Bahrain, Egypt, Libya, Syria, and Yemen. NATO Secretary-General, Anders Fogh Rasmussen, endorsed the Arab Spring as the pro-democracy and pro-freedom principles embodied in the movement were seen as compatible with NATO’s mission. The Arab Spring had lasting implications on the MENA region’s security — for instance, while Tunisia transitioned to a functioning democracy, and has remained that way, states including Egypt, Libya, and Yemen failed to maintain lasting democracy. In the case of Yemen and Libya, the mass protests further destabilized the states, while the Egyptian military overthrew its democratically-elected Muslim Brotherhood in 2013. Meanwhile, protests against the governing regime in Syria evolved into a civil war that lasted for the next 14 years.
Terrorist organizations continued to pose a significant threat to security in the MENA region and upend NATO’s objectives in the 2010s. The terrorist organization, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) grew in influence and conquered significant territory. To manage the threat posed by ISIS, the US and allies launched NATO-supported mission Operation Inherent Resolve, which was a task force dedicated to defeating the organization with lethal force. Furthermore, the terrorist organization, Ansar al Sharia, directly threatened NATO security interests in the MENA region when it launched an attack against US government facilities in Benghazi, Libya, in September 2012, killing members of the US foreign service. This attack followed an invasion of Libya in 2011 by NATO Member States to defeat Colonel Mu’ammar al-Gaddafi’s dictatorial regime. The history of the MENA region since the late 20th century highlights serious threats to NATO’s interests and NATO responses — varying in levels of success — demonstrated by the lingering negative consequences of the “War on Terror” and the efficacy of Operation Inherent Resolve.
After generations of political instability, violence, and economic turbulence, the MENA region still remains fractured and faces critical security challenges. Sectarian division and inequality in the MENA region exacerbate conflict and promote violent extremism. Al-Qaeda and ISIS remain active in certain parts of the MENA region, and militant groups menace civilians and destabilize rule of law in states including Iraq, Libya, and Yemen. Internal conflict in Sudan has amassed a serious death toll, annihilated urban centers, and made large swaths of land uninhabitable. Israel’s offensive in the Gaza Strip, launched after the October 7th, 2023 attacks by Hamas, has resulted in tens of thousands of Palestinian deaths and created widespread food insecurity. Approximately 16.6 million people in the MENA region are currently displaced due to armed conflict, straining Member States that are unable to provide asylum and protection for refugees. These challenges destabilize the MENA region and have the potential to spread outward, concerning all NATO Member States. These challenges also have broader implications on international security—for instance, the MENA region is home to resources and trade routes necessary for NATO Member States. As a result, a destabilized security environment in the MENA region is counterproductive to the interests and security of those Member States.
Interstate tension also poses a threat to international security, requiring NATO to manage and monitor these situations to restore peace and security. Algeria and Morocco have been historical adversaries, due to a dispute over ownership of the Western Sahara region in West Africa. While Morocco claims ownership of the region, Algeria favors sovereignty for the Sahrawi people native to the region. Furthermore, Algeria’s support for the Polisario Front, a nationalist movement representing the Sahrawi people through armed force, amplifies pressure between itself and Morocco. As a result, Algeria and Morocco cut diplomatic ties in 2021 while strengthening their military posture and border security through mounting tension. While NATO Member States including France, Spain, and the US have attempted to appease both Algeria and Morocco, directly recognizing Moroccan sovereignty over Western Sahara could damage relations with Algeria. However, alienating Algeria could push them further towards China and Russia’s embrace, creating additional challenges for NATO Member States that rely on Algeria as an affordable source for natural gas. Additionally, further escalation between Algeria and Morocco could destabilize the region and displace people along the border, including over 170,000 refugees living in the Algerian province of Tindouf.
Iran has been at the forefront of international discourse regarding the MENA region’s security. After 22-year-old Mahsa Amini was killed by law enforcement in September 2022, widespread protests engulfed over 100 Iranian cities. This unrest was met with significant force, precipitating greater and enduring dissatisfaction with Ayatollah Ali Khamenei’s regime. Social discontent paired with economic uncertainty presents a threat to Iran’s governing class, challenging their domestic security. Furthermore, widespread unrest in Iran has been linked to a larger “Shia Spring” movement in the MENA region in states including Iraq and Lebanon. Iran remains estranged from the West after generations of hostility, and its burgeoning defense partnership with Russia could upset the MENA region’s balance of power. Russia and Iran’s partnership also has implications beyond the MENA region, as Iran provides munitions including weapons, ammunition, and equipment — used against both military personnel and civilians in Ukraine — to Russia. In June 2025, Iran and Israel exchanged military strikes after years of rising tensions once Israel alleged that Iran was enriching uranium to develop nuclear weapons. In response, the US launched strikes against underground nuclear facilities in Iran, hurting its uranium enrichment capabilities. Just 12 days after the modern conflict began, Israel and Iran reached a ceasefire on June 24, 2025, but it is unclear whether or not this ceasefire will hold in the long term. NATO will have to evaluate its foreign policy approach with Iran due to its growing implications on the MENA region’s security, as seen in its domestic unrest, relationship with Russia, and conflict with Israel.
The Syrian Civil War is an ongoing crisis in the Middle East, contributing to the region’s destabilization and engendering international insecurity. Until 2024, this conflict involved Bashar al-Assad’s dictatorial regime and its allies against various oppositional forces. Syria and NATO’s relationship remained contentious throughout the war due to various factors. For instance, Russia and Iran were key allies for Assad, and Syria became the flashpoint for a conflict over influence in the MENA region between NATO and its adversaries. Another source of concern for NATO was Assad’s repression tactics, which included the use of chemical weapons on civilians. The protracted Syrian Civil War remained at a stalemate for years until opposition forces led by rebel organization Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) abruptly captured Damascus in December 2024. The rebels ousted the Assad regime, and the Syrian Salvation Government (SSG)—a technocratic political organization formed by HTS—was recognized by Syria’s Prime Minister. Ahmed al-Sharaa, leader of HTS and the SSG, became Syria’s de facto leader and was appointed president in January 2025.
The current situation in Syria requires NATO to reconsider its relationship and foreign policy approach with Damascus. Al-Sharaa has indicated that his new government is not an adversary of the West during an interview with the BBC in December 2024, and called for an end to Western sanctions against Syria. In May 2025, US President Donald Trump announced that sanctions against Syria would end, going into effect later that month after the Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control issued immediate sanctions relief. This development highlights the potential for a fresh start between the two and a joint commitment towards Syria’s prosperity. Although al-Sharaa indicated his commitment towards an inclusive government featuring separation of powers and participation, the temporary constitution that his constitutional committee unveiled in March 2025 suggests otherwise. The temporary document concentrates power in the executive branch with the expressed purpose of promoting swift and decisive action, to the dismay of critics who question al-Sharaa’s intentions. Furthermore, skeptics worry about al-Sharaa’s background prior to his interim presidency. In 2011, al-Sharaa formed Jabhat al-Nusra, an al-Qaeda affiliate against the Assad regime designated as a terrorist organization by the UN. However, al-Sharaa denounced al-Qaeda and cut ties in 2017, reforming Jabhat al-Nusra into HTS. New leadership provides an opportunity for NATO to forge lasting relations with Syria, spread its influence, and build security in a war-torn region. However, the temporary constitution and HTS’s background may be incompatible with NATO’s commitment to peace, security, and democracy.
Inconsistent cooperation and strategic complications in the MENA region remain a challenge for NATO.109 However, previous efforts by NATO illustrate best practices and potential for stronger relationships with MENA states. NATO launched the Mediterranean Dialogue (MD) in 1994, a political partnership forum between itself and non-NATO allies along the Mediterranean Sea. The MD seeks to contain shared regional security threats including terrorism, conflict spillover, and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. Seven non-NATO allies have joined the MD since its formation, including Algeria, Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Mauritania, Morocco and Tunisia. MD partners share expertise and knowledge bilaterally with NATO, and collaborate through a Partnership Cooperation Menu (PCM).114 The PCM provides MD partners military education and training for weapons management, cyber defense, protection of critical energy infrastructure, etc. Furthermore, Member States of the MD sometimes assist NATO in operations designed to restore international security. For instance, some MD partners supported NATO’s interventions in states including Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1995, Afghanistan in 2001, and Libya in 2011. These cases illustrate that the MD has been a diplomatic success, as the confidence-building between NATO and its MENA partners have facilitated deeper military integration, allowing both parties to respond to ever-changing security challenges.
After the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, NATO invoked Article 5 and launched Operation Active Endeavour (OAE) to prevent maritime terrorism in the Mediterranean, an important shipping route passing through the MENA region. NATO personnel monitored and boarded ships passing through Mediterranean chokepoints, aiming to protect people and cargo passing through from terrorist activity. OAE predictably strengthened the security partnership between NATO and its MD allies, while bearing unintended benefits. For instance, NATO helicopters and ships patrolling the Mediterranean saved over 100 people stranded on oil rigs and sinking vessels throughout OAE’s history. Operation Sea Guardian (OSG) succeeded OAE in 2016, and has three primary functions — to foster maritime security capacity building, strengthen situational awareness, and prevent terrorist activity. Each year, OSG conducts five-to-six operations in Mediterranean waters, using assets to monitor trade activities and ports. OSG incorporates MENA region partners in activities including intelligence-sharing and counter-piracy, strengthening cooperation around a shared security concern.
In 2004, NATO established the Istanbul Cooperation Initiative (ICI) to support regional and international security goals. The ICI fosters bilateral cooperation between NATO and members of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), a political alliance comprising six MENA states. Four GCC members—Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates—joined the ICI in 2005, while Oman and Saudi Arabia engage in ICI matters selectively. Founded in Kuwait City in 2017, the NATO-ICI Regional Centre provides a forum for ICC partners, streamlining practical cooperation between NATO and its Gulf allies. Like the MD, the ICI has fostered military and strategic integration between NATO and Gulf region partners—for instance, Bahrain participated in the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) in Afghanistan during its conflict with the US, and the UAE contributed in NATO’s military campaign against al-Gaddafi’s regime in 2011.
In July 2018, NATO launched NATO Mission Iraq (NMI) at the NATO Summit in Brussels to transform Iraq’s military and security institutions. Iraq requested the creation of NMI to promote self-reliance and stability, defend itself from terrorism, and stop ISIS from returning to its territory. Incorporating security experts and officials from NATO Member States and its allies, NMI provides training, education, and logistics for Iraqi military and civilian personnel. While NATO strives to bolster Iraq’s defense capabilities, NMI is a non-combat mission, meaning NATO refrains from deploying forces alongside Iraq in its combat operations. NMI has evolved multiple times since its introduction. NATO agreed to expand NMI in both February 2021 and August 2023, including more of Iraq’s security institutions in the program, suggesting the initiative was effective and successful. NMI represents the most comprehensive integration initiative between NATO and Iraq, fostering capacity-building in Iraq’s security sector and collaboration between the two parties.
NATO faces critical security challenges in the MENA region, a region of high geopolitical import, including hostile governments, terrorist organizations, and reconstruction of governments. The historical record suggests NATO and its Member States have had mixed foreign policy results. International security disasters, illustrate the consequences of inadequate foreign policy towards the MENA region. However, initiatives including the MD, OAE, OSG, ICI, and NMI display NATO’s policy for the MENA region suggest there may be merit for a diplomacy-first foreign policy approach. Ultimately, NATO must consider its relationship-building policy and strategies in the MENA region to address critical challenges of the modern age. An effective approach may allow NATO to foster a transcendent security environment and satisfy the geopolitical interests of its Member States.
Delegates should thoughtfully consider the topic from both angles—strategy and relations in the MENA region—to fortify international security. A varied and nuanced approach to managing the topic will be helpful for managing the multidimensional challenges presented by the unstable security environment in the MENA region. Delegates should consider success stories from past engagement with the MENA region when devising new and innovative ideas.
How can these be expanded upon or altered to further advance NATO’s regional and international security goals? Furthermore, delegates should analyze less fruitful strategies, diagnose the problems, and determine a more effective approach. Lastly, delegates should research foreign policy outside of the MENA region by NATO or other actors. In general, delegates should address these questions with realistic solutions for implementing their goals. Delegates should focus on building upon established NATO, UN, and other multilateral programs and initiatives rather than creating new bodies within NATO. Delegates should also focus on the issue as a whole and not specific situations.
Chattoraj, Diotima, Rahman, Mizanur, and Ullah, Ahsan. “The Middle East and North Africa (MENA): Fragility, Fragmentation, and Crisis,” The International Journal of Interdisciplinary Global Studies, vol. 18, no. 2, 2023, p.25. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Diotima-Chattoraj-3/publication/371600039_The_Middle_East_and_North_Africa_MENA_Fragility_Fragmentation_and_Crisis/links/ 648bad77c41fb852dd094d99/The-Middle-East-and-North-Africa-MENA-Fragility-Fragmentation-and-Crisis.
The International Journal of Interdisciplinary Global Studies is a peer-reviewed academic journal that covers the dynamics of globalization and the transformation of local contexts. “The Middle East and North Africa (MENA)...” expands upon the delicate relationship between the 21 MENA Member States, which has seen high conflict rates and regional instability given the diverse political, economic, demographic, and ethnic backgrounds within the region. Despite remaining religiously homogeneous, a lack of unity in diversity amongst MENA Member States has impacted regional cooperation and cohesion. The article is useful as it explains the factors that prompt fragility and fragmentation between Member States in the region, resulting in persistent inter- and intra-state conflict. The article further helps understand the necessary precautions to be taken when creating and implementing strategies to effectively address the situation.
Cordesman, Anthony H., and Grace Hwang. “The Changing Security Dynamics of the MENA Region,” Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), 2021. https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep30031.1.pdf.
The Center for Strategic and International Studies is an American nonprofit research organization focused on foreign policy and security issues. The report “The Changing Security Dynamics of the MENA Region” investigates recent developments in the security dynamics between Member States of the region. Inter-regional disputes, political extremism, and various political uprisings and conflicts have thoroughly reconditioned the international security implications of Member States within the MENA Region, affecting civil and military operations. The report’s exploration of how the security dynamics in the MENA region have shifted is essential as it acknowledges that effective reform must be implemented at both the military and civil levels.
“The Sunni-Shia Divide,” Council on Foreign Relations. April 27, 2023, accessed March 9, 2025. https://www.cfr.org/article/sunni-shia-divide.
The Council on Foreign Relations is a think tank based in the United States (US) focusing on international politics and US foreign affairs. The article “The Sunni-Shia Divide” explores the schism in Islam between Sunni and Shia Muslims, the two predominant Islamic sects. While the Sunni-Shia divide does not comprehensively account for the recent conflict in the MENA region, it has and can reinforce tension, deepen feuds, and fuel sectarian extremism and civil war, which generate immense humanitarian costs and engender international security concerns. The article is helpful as it explains the effects of this divide in Member States such as Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, and Pakistan, and how the social challenges presented by Sunni-Shia tension cannot be ignored. Therefore, this article clarifies cultural contexts and the importance of understanding them to find an appropriate policy response.