"A venture into the colorful wilderness of a mystic and spiritual Africa."
Set in a post-apocalyptic, mythological Africa, Okorafor’s “Who Fears Death” finds itself in the middle of a historic conflict between two ethnic groups, the Okeke and the Nuru. The Okeke have been reduced to slaves and are being subject to sexual conquest by the Nuru. The novel follows the brave and assertive Onyesonwu, on her journey in the midst of this conflict. Deemed as a child of violence, the circumstances of Onyesonwu’s birth condemn her to living a life of ostracization. In defiance of being cast out and denied by her very neighbors, Onyesonwu embarks on a long and arduous journey filled with African mysticism and forbidden love. This afrofuturist tale is one that tackles a myriad of social, political, and religious issues. The immersion of the desert is surprising in its presentation of all its colors.
Disclaimer: To be clear, I’d like to offer warning that this novel engages with problems of sexual violence in a graphic way throughout its storytelling. For the rest of this review I may reference some instances of violence that may be uncomfortable and unsettling to read.
Who Fears Death” breaks the mold of many works of afrofuturist novels to date. It takes place predominantly in Africa, with little to no reference of the West or a mythological West equivalent in the novel. Often, afrofuturist novels preoccupy themselves with inclusion of and an elucidation of the Western powers' role in the world. Having an Africa in this story that doesn’t exist in relation to the West and former colonial powers subverts this need and shows that a mythical Africa can have a future that belongs solely to itself. Additionally, there is a seamless blend of the aspects of science fiction and fantasy that are present in this story. Technology and magic come together to construct the expansive world. In fact, a lot of technology in the work is explained in a way that positions it in the past while mysticism and “juju” pave and shape the way of the future.
Within the committed centering of Africa, the novel entails the mobilization of ethnic cleansing going on, perpetrated by the lighter skinned Nurus against the darker skinned Okekes. This story is unfolded through the eyes of Onyesonwu, embroiled in this conflict by her biological father having been the General of the Nuru force which pillaged and raped women in an Okeke village. To avenge her mother who was subjected to that horror, Onyesonwu labors to unlock the magic and power that lies within her and break free from everything that limits her.
"The Okeke people have the skin color of the night because they were created before the day. They were the first. Later, after much had happened, the Nuru arrived. They came from the stars and that's why their skin is the color of the sun. These names must have been agreed upon during peaceful times, for it was well known that the Okeke were born to be slaves of the Nuru. Long ago during the Old Africa era, they had done something terrible causing Ani to put this duty on their backs. It is written in the Great Book."
Onyesonwu was severely limited. Being a product of rape, she was labeled as an “Ewu,” which is used to describe those born of violence. These children and people are demonized and persecuted by others because they are believed to only beget more destruction. Almost every person perceives Onyesonwu as an evil, untrustworthy, unstable person who should be avoided, or killed. When Onyesonwu attempts to find a teacher for her in “juju,” her inner power, she is rejected by elders and sorcerers on the basis that she is “Ewu,” and a woman.
Okorafor incorporates patriarchal tendencies in this work as men are perceived to be more capable and competent than women. Often comments made by men in the novel reflect a sense of superiority that hinders Onyesonwu in her journey to save an infinite amount of lives. Having to confront the matter of her existence in almost every interpersonal interaction and relationship, Onyesonwu defies the logic of her society and aims to fulfill the prophecy of rewriting the reality that plagues Africa in the novel.
Prophecy, religion, faith, and mysticism play a heavy role in the ethnic conflict and cleansing in the region. The narratives that antagonize Okeke people to the Nuru were espoused in “The Great Book,” a religious artifact that is the source of the belief systems of a wide sector of people in this society. Religious fanaticism is an intriguing phenomena that takes form in many surprising ways. Additionally, mysticism lends itself to some wondrous and disturbing fantastical elements such as a wise, white sorcerer found in the middle of a desert storm.
Religious elements also meet cultural ones in an uncomfortable way in the novel. Consensual female circumcision is a massive part of the novel and affects many characters on the journey to rewrite the great book.
Rooted in a cultural context, the inclusion of this phenomena subtly illuminates how femininity is understood when juxtaposed with masculinity, in the absence of male circumcision. Often, critiques are levied at any practices surrounding circumcision in the Global South that lend itself to cultural imperialist narratives and sentiments. The West imposes its own conceptualization of patriarchy and projects it onto those that stand on and in other cultural contexts.
The novel subverts this not by having characters separate themselves or alienate themselves from said culture, but grounds the practice in cultural tradition. It doesn’t trivialize or rehabilitate the image and perception of the practice. The novel doesn’t valorize tradition in any way. Room is given for this practice to exist without it being understood as an oppressive, patriarchal practice, as in a Western context.
"All of me was destroyed. I was dead, broken, scattered, and absorbed. It was a thousand times worse than when I first changed into a bird. I remember nothing because I was nothing. Then I was something. I could feel it. I was being put back together, bit by bit. What was doing this? No, it was not Ani. It was not a goddess. It was cold, if it could be cold."
"No she was not a sacrifice to be made for the good of men and women. She was Onyesonwu. She had rewritten the Great Book. All was done....He'd spoken those ancient mystical words to her, words that were truer and purer than love. What they shared was enough to shift fate."
It’s not an exaggeration to say that this africanfuturist story is a trek through the desert. Time is spent on characters in so much detail that you truly feel you are experiencing the heat of the desert with sand slashing harshly against your skin. The world feels massive and time seems to stand still. The characters, friends of Onyesonwu, are truly endearing, some more than others, and represent a varied number of experiences that could be had in this mythological, mystical Africa. The story at large and the interactions between these individuals are unpredictable. Okorafor unapologetically makes you adopt apprehension to any possibility of attachment. Any line of reasoning you follow, any tired tropes which exhaust and bore you, are thrown out of the window.
This is a must read for those who look to engage with new, interesting worlds within science fiction and fantasy. Many turns may stun readers of this novel, not least of which is how the central conflict of the story plays out and its resolution. “Who Fears Death” is a novel that doesn’t care for comfortability, in any respect. Readers will feel just as unsettled as the characters, and what is that if not the goal of speculative fiction. The novel is a venture into the colorful wilderness of mystic and spiritual Africa, plagued by ethnic conflict. Most intriguing of all, Onyesonwu, born to be hated, and prophesied to be a hero, must stop the violence from which she was first conceived. She makes this novel, when no one else wants her to. Okorafor truly wrote a dynamic, mysterious novel that challenges norms for afrofuturism and engages in dialogue with contemporary social, political, religious, and cultural issues. Onyesonwu and Okorafor join hands together to “rewrite The Great Book.”
Nnedi Okorafor is a Naijamerican (Nigerian-American) writer of science fiction and fantasy. She's garnered many awards over the years including the Hugo Award, Nebula Award, Eisner Award, and World Fantasy Award. She's written many novels over the years, other notable works include Binti, Akata Witch, The Book of Phoenix, and Noor.