2024: Xanadu

2023: The Addams Family

2022: You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown

2021: Carousel

2020: 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee

2019: SHREK The Musical

2018: The Fantasticks

2017: Once Upon a Mattress

2015: PIPPIN

2013: The Pajama Game

2012: Lucky Stiff

2010: Annie Get Your Gun

2008: Bye Bye Birdie

2007: The Wizard of Oz

2005: Once on This Island

2003: Hello Dolly

2001: The King & I