We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
I recommend the Xumilas XL Air Fryer as my top pick for most kitchens — it's the only basket here that doubles as a full-size oven tray, and its 18.7" x 12.8" footprint fits a whole 5–6 lb chicken or 12 chicken legs in one batch.
• Xumilas XL Air Fryer — best for oven owners who want one large tray-and-basket setup; pick this if you need a 6.5L basket plus an 18.7" x 12.8" drip tray that handles a whole chicken.
• Gourmia Air Fryer Oven — best for countertop cooking without a full oven; pick this if you want a self-contained 5-quart unit with 12 touch presets and a dishwasher-safe basket.
• atgestore B-AFO-002G-1 — best for replacing a worn crisper tray in a Power XL grill oven; pick this if you already own a B-AFO-002, B-AFO-002G or B-AFO-002G-1 model.
• Milzeone 9.51QT — best for big-batch countertop cooking with a clear view; pick this if you want a 9.51-quart glass pot with 8 presets and a dishwasher-safe basket.
This is not a countertop appliance — it's a stainless steel basket-and-tray set that slides into your existing oven. The cooking area measures 18.7" x 12.8" and the basket runs 18.7" x 11.8", which works out to a 6.5L capacity. In practical terms, that's a whole 5–6 lb chicken, 12 chicken legs, or up to 5 lbs of vegetables in a single pass. If your current setup forces you to cook in two or three rounds, that gap disappears.
The mesh design lets air move 360 degrees around the food, and Xumilas states it cuts oil use by up to 70% versus deep frying. You also get a 4-in-1 setup: air fry, bake, roast or grill, using the same piece as a basket, baking pan, roasting rack or grilling tray. The material is 304 stainless steel at 0.24-inch thickness, rated to 450°F without warping, with no PTFE or PFOA coatings. For anyone who has watched a cheap oven tray bow in the middle of a roast, the thickness spec is the number that matters most.
Cleanup is where the design earns its keep. The 18.7" x 12.8" drip tray sits underneath and catches grease and crumbs, and 30 pre-cut parchment papers sized for that tray come in the box. Hand washing in warm soapy water is the recommendation; it's dishwasher safe below 150°F (65°C), so a hot wash cycle is the thing to avoid. Xumilas also covers it with a one-year limited warranty on manufacturing defects.
Two things to check before you commit. First, your oven needs at least 19" of depth, and the basket works with standard, convection and toaster ovens from brands like Whirlpool, KitchenAid, GE, Samsung, Bosch, Frigidaire and LG. Second, this is a manual piece of cookware — there's no digital display, no presets and no timer here, because your oven supplies all of that. It weighs 2.8 pounds, so it's manageable to lift in and out, but it's a large flat object and you'll need somewhere to set it down. In my opinion, it's the best fit for someone who already likes their oven and just wants it to cook like an air fryer.
Gourmia Air Fryer Oven
Where Xumilas hands control to your oven, Gourmia puts the whole thing on your counter. This is a self-contained 5-quart air fryer with 1500 watts of power, a digital touch display, and 12 one-touch cooking presets. It covers air fry, bake, roast, broil, dehydrate, reheat, toast and keep warm — a genuinely wide spread for a single compact unit measuring 13.3"D x 10"W x 12.5"H.
The cooking logic is what Gourmia calls Fry Force 360°, a turbo air flow system that circulates heat around the basket. Gourmia states the fat-removal design takes out up to 80% of fat during cooking, which is the kind of claim that matters if you're air frying wings or bacon regularly. The temperature range runs from 90°F up to 400°F, so the low end actually handles dehydrating rather than just pretending to. Guided cooking prompts on the display nudge you when to add food after preheating and when to turn it mid-cook — a small thing that makes a real difference if you're new to air frying.
The trade-off is capacity and shape. Five quarts is generous for a countertop unit but it's a single-basket design, so a whole chicken is out — you're cooking in portions. It also occupies permanent counter space, unlike the Xumilas set that lives in your oven. I'd point this at someone in a smaller kitchen, a dorm, an apartment or a rental where the built-in oven is unreliable or nonexistent.
This one is a direct replacement part, not a general-purpose basket. The tray measures 12.6"L x 10"W x 1.4"H and is built for Power XL air fryer grill ovens — specifically the B-AFO-002, B-AFO-002G and B-AFO-002G-1 models, plus some other Power XL replacement applications. If your original crisper tray has warped, rusted or lost its coating, this is the swap.
The construction is 304 stainless steel with a polished finish, and atgestore emphasizes that it's heavier and sturdier than typical alternatives, so it resists deforming over long use. There's a handle on each end for lifting it out, and the edges are finished smooth rather than raw, which matters when you're pulling a hot tray from a hot oven. Each wire crossing point is individually welded — a small manufacturing detail that's usually the first failure point on cheap mesh racks.
Functionally, the mesh circulates air around food so it heats evenly and crisps rather than steaming. atgestore lists it for baking bread, cookies, pizza and chicken, and describes it as a stable surface for cookware inside the oven. Cleaning is a soapy sponge and hot water, and it's dishwasher safe. The item weighs about a pound.
Here's the honest caveat: fit is everything, and this tray is narrow on purpose. At 12.6" x 10" it is significantly smaller than the Xumilas tray. atgestore is direct about this — check your existing tray's dimensions and confirm your model number before ordering. There's no warranty listed, and it ships as a single basket with no accessories. My take: this is the right buy only if you own a matching Power XL unit and need a replacement. It's not a general upgrade for a standard oven.
Milzeone goes the other direction on capacity. This is a 9.51-quart countertop air fryer running 1350 watts, with a temperature range of 194°F to 392°F and a timer adjustable from 1 to 60 minutes. That capacity is large enough to cook a main course, sides and snacks together without multiple batches — genuinely a small-family or small-gathering machine rather than a single-portion one.
The operation is touch screen with an LCD display, and there are 8 presets with reference temperatures and times: french fries, roast, chicken wings, egg tarts, grilled fish, sweet potatoes, grilled shrimp and steak. You can accept those defaults or override both temperature and time. The controls also handle pause, start and a delay/appointment function, which is more scheduling flexibility than most air fryers at this level offer.
The build mixes plastic and metal for heat, wear and scratch resistance, and the inner surface is nonstick with a glass pot. That glass is the standout detail: a clear lid lets you watch food as it cooks instead of opening the drawer and losing heat. Milzeone also notes suction-cup support feet that keep the unit stable and protect the countertop from scratches, plus a handle designed to stay cool enough to grab.
Cleanup is easy by design — the nonstick coating releases food without scrubbing, and the glass pot is dishwasher safe. It ships with a grill insert and measures 11.02"D x 13.58"W x 10.23"H, weighing 9.3 pounds.
The trade-offs are real. That 9.51-quart body takes up a lot of counter, and 9.3 pounds means you'll want a permanent spot rather than hauling it out of a cupboard. The temperature ceiling of 392°F is also lower than the 400°F-plus you'll find elsewhere, so very high-heat crisping has a slightly lower ceiling. If you want maximum volume on the countertop and like watching your food through the lid, I'd recommend it.
How We Picked
I compared published specifications and features — cooking area, capacity, materials, temperature ranges, controls, cleaning requirements and compatibility — and weighed how each design would play out in a normal kitchen. The ranking is my independent editorial opinion, not a measurement of sales or popularity. No brand paid for placement, and no product here was selected on the basis of price.
Measure your oven rack and depth before buying. The Xumilas basket needs at least 19" of oven depth and works best in ovens with a rack length of 18.7" or more. For countertop units, check the exterior footprint against your free counter space instead.
It depends on the specific product. The Xumilas set is dishwasher safe only below 150°F (65°C), so hand washing in warm soapy water is the safer default. The Gourmia basket and tray, the atgestore tray and the Milzeone glass pot are all listed as dishwasher safe.
An oven basket like the Xumilas uses your oven's heat and adds mesh air circulation — you keep your oven's capacity and skip buying an appliance. A countertop air fryer like the Gourmia or Milzeone is self-contained with its own heating element, fan, controls and presets, so it works without an oven at all.
Yes, and it matters more than dimensions alone. The atgestore tray is built for Power XL B-AFO-002, B-AFO-002G and B-AFO-002G-1 models. Confirm your model number and measure your existing tray before ordering, since a near-fit tray will sit unevenly or not seat at all.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer glass basket, dual basket air fryer accessories, air fryer basket divider