How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
• Cosori Air Fryer Basket — best for full-size toaster-oven air frying; pick this if you own a Cosori CTO-R251S and want one wide basket instead of juggling small round inserts.
• oecue Air fryer Replacement — best for 4-quart Ninja owners who want a round crisper plate with a handle; pick this if your basket measures 8.2 inches across and you want dishwasher-safe cleanup plus bumpers included.
• GWY Air Fryer Grill — best for dual-zone Ninja Foodi cookers; pick this if you run a DZ090, DZ201 or DZ100 and want two rectangular 8.1 x 5.5 inch plates so both zones stay usable.
• BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket — best for large indoor-grill air frying with minimal cleanup; pick this if you own a Ninja Foodi FG551, DG551 or DG651 and want a wide basket plus 100 disposable liners.
This is not a divider in the small-insert sense. It is a full replacement air fry basket for the Cosori CTO-R251S air fryer toaster oven, and it is sized like it: 13.2 inches deep, 11 inches wide, and about an inch tall. That footprint is the whole story. In a toaster oven you are usually cooking a flat layer of food on a rack, and a basket this wide lets you spread a full batch of fries, nuggets or wings without stacking them into a soggy pile.
The material choices are sensible for oven duty. It is chrome-plated steel with a non-stick coating, and Cosori states it is BPA free and PFOA free. Chrome plating gives you the stiffness and heat tolerance you want at oven temperatures, while the non-stick layer is what makes roasted vegetables and sticky glazed wings release without a fight. Cosori also notes the basket supports air-fried meals with up to 85% less fat than traditional frying, which is the usual reason people move to air frying in the first place.
Who is it for? Honestly, one specific person: the owner of a Cosori CTO-R251S. The listing is explicit that it only fits that model, and Cosori points buyers toward other listings for other ovens. If you have a different Cosori, this is the wrong part. That narrow fit is the main trade-off, and it is a real one.
The second trade-off is cleaning. This basket is hand wash only. There is no dishwasher shortcut here, so plan on warm soapy water and a soft sponge after anything greasy. On the plus side, one basket replaces the foil-and-rack routine, and the low 1.1 inch height means it slides into the oven without eating your vertical cooking space. In my opinion, if you own the matching oven, this is the most practical way to get real air-fry results out of it.
oecue Air fryer Replacement
The design details are the selling points. There is a handle, which sounds minor until you have tried lifting a hot, greasy plate out of a deep basket with tongs. Oecue also includes three rubber bumpers that seat the plate so it does not slide around while the fan is running. That combination — handle plus bumpers — is what separates a plate that feels planted from one that rattles.
Material-wise it is food-grade 304 stainless steel with an enameled non-stick coating applied in a double layer, and it is dishwasher safe. The handle-and-bumpers kit also ships with a cleaning cloth. Beyond the air fryer, oecue describes using it in an oven, in a pressure cooker for steaming, and even on a barbecue, which makes it a more versatile pan than the round shape suggests.
Two things to know. First, size is on you: oecue explicitly asks buyers to measure the inner diameter of their air fryer before ordering, and a plate that is slightly too large simply will not seat. Second, the coating is non-stick, so skip abrasive pads and metal scouring balls, and do not wash it while it is still scorching hot. My take: this is the pick for a 4-quart Ninja owner who wants one well-behaved round plate rather than a stack of accessories.
Here is the dual-zone answer. GWY sells these as a two-pack of rectangular crisper plates measuring 8.1 x 5.5 inches with a 0.79 inch height, built for the Ninja Foodi DZ090 6-quart and DZ201 and DZ100 8-quart DualZone air fryers. The two-pack matters because dual-zone cookers have two baskets, and buying a single plate leaves one side doing nothing.
The shape is deliberate. A rectangular plate in a rectangular dual-zone basket covers more of the floor than a round one, so more food sits directly over the airflow. GWY also highlights a unique airflow design intended to heat food more evenly, which is the practical benefit of a perforated plate with a handle rather than a solid tray. The handle makes removal straightforward, and the food list is broad: barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, fries, pizza, beef, chicken wings, onion rings, and dehydrated fruit.
The trade-off is compatibility, and it is strict. GWY states plainly that these fit the DZ090, DZ201 and DZ100 and are not suitable for other models, and it asks you to measure your original tray first. If you own a single-basket Ninja, these will not help you. If you own a DualZone, I think a matched pair of plates with handles is the smarter buy than one generic round insert.
BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket
This is the biggest and most cleanup-focused option in the group. The basket measures 12.8 x 7.2 x 3 inches, so it has real depth — three inches of sidewall means wings and fries can pile up rather than lying flat in a single layer. It is made of carbon steel with a non-stick finish in a rectangular shape.
The compatibility list is long and specific: Ninja Foodi FG551, DG551 and DG651 Smart XL 6-in-1 Indoor Grill models, including BG500A, BG500C, BG550CO, BG550CCO, DG551, DG651, DG651Q, DG651QBK, DG651QCM, FG550, FG551, FG551B1, FG551B1NP, FG551C, FG551H, FG551HBK, FG551HBL, FG551HCO, FG551HEG, FG551HWH, FG551NP, FG551Q, FG551QBLK, FG551QCN, FG551QCO and FG551QWH. That is unusually thorough, and it is exactly why BBQ-PLUS tells you to verify your model number before ordering.
The airflow story is the sculpted cut-out design with an open bottom and raised edges, meant to push hot air around the food instead of trapping it. That is the difference between evenly golden fries and pale centers with burnt tips, and it is the reason a perforated basket beats a solid pan for air frying.
The standout feature is the 100 disposable paper liners. Drop one in, cook, lift it out and throw it away, and most of the mess never touches the basket. That said, the care instructions are strict: hand wash only, wash immediately after use, dry thoroughly, never soak, never use abrasives, and store only when fully dry, because the coating can rust if it sits wet. In my opinion this is the pick for someone feeding a crowd on a Ninja indoor grill who would rather spend less time scrubbing.
How We Picked
None of these are literal splitter walls. They are replacement baskets and crisper plates that change how food sits in the basket, which is how most people use the term. If you want to cook two foods separately, a dual-zone model with two plates, like the GWY pair, is the closest match.
Match the model number first, then the size. Measure the inner diameter for round plates and the tray dimensions for rectangular ones. Round plates like the oecue need roughly 8.2 inches; the GWY plates need a DZ090, DZ201 or DZ100; the Cosori basket is for the CTO-R251S only.
The oecue plate and the GWY plates are described as dishwasher safe. The Cosori basket and the BBQ-PLUS basket are hand wash only, and BBQ-PLUS specifically warns against soaking, abrasives and storing the basket wet.
Some, yes. The oecue plate is described for oven, pressure cooker and barbecue use. The others are built around specific air fryer and indoor grill models, so treat them as model-specific parts rather than universal pans.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: AODPWEN 2 vs Onader Air Fryer Basket, HELLO.HELEN Dual Basket Air vs Eslotre Air Fryer Liners, ctizne Air Fryer Liners vs NeoLame Air Fryer Basket