How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want one flexible, food-grade silicone mat that fits most air fryers and toaster ovens and doubles as a swiss roll and cookie liner, choose X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake; if you need a stainless steel grill and crisper pan built specifically for the Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt air fryer toaster oven, choose GWY Air Fryer Baking.
• X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake — biggest strength: soft, flexible food-grade silicone (10" x 11" x 0.78") that is heat-resistant from -40°F to 440°F and works across air fryers, toaster ovens, microwaves and freezers.
• X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake — biggest trade-off: silicone can stain over time (functionality is unaffected), and it is a liner rather than a rigid tray, so it offers no structural support for heavy or runny foods.
• GWY Air Fryer Baking — biggest strength: a rigid stainless steel grill/crisper plate (11.2" x 10.5" x 1") with a 480°F max temperature, dishwasher-safe cleaning and a food-grade, BPA-free build.
• GWY Air Fryer Baking — biggest trade-off: it is made for one machine — the Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt air fryer toaster oven — so it will not fit other models, and it needs a 300°F preheat for 10 minutes before first use to avoid warping.
• Who each pick is for: X-Haibei for anyone who wants a flexible, universal liner for baking and swiss rolls in a range of appliances; GWY for a Nuwave Bravo owner who wants a dedicated, rigid grill and crisper pan for that exact oven.
The X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake is a rectangular food-grade silicone baking mat, listed in orange, measuring 10" wide by 11" long by 0.78" thick without the edges. That footprint is the whole point: it is sized to sit inside most air fryer baskets, toaster ovens and baking pans, so one mat can move between appliances instead of you buying a different accessory for each one. The silicone is rated from -40°F to 440°F, which covers everyday oven baking, air frying, microwave heating and freezer storage. The manufacturer also notes it can be used for cold storage and freezing, and that it strips away from baked goods easily.
Who should buy it: home bakers who bounce between an air fryer, a toaster oven and a regular oven, and anyone who wants a reusable liner for cookies, swiss rolls and small bakes. Who should skip it: if you need a stiff pan to hold a loose batter or to lift a heavy roast out of the basket, silicone this thin is not the right tool — look at the GWY plate instead. It is also worth noting that silicone mats can pick up stains over time; the brand says this does not affect how the mat works, but a buyer who wants a pristine-looking accessory should know that going in.
GWY Air Fryer Baking: Who It's For
The GWY Air Fryer Baking is a stainless steel grill pan and crisper plate sized 11.2" x 10.5" x 1", and the brand is unusually blunt about its target: it is designed for the Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt air fryer toaster oven, and it is not suitable for other models. That single sentence should decide the purchase for most people. If you own that specific oven, this is a drop-in replacement pan; if you don't, this is the wrong accessory no matter how good the specs look.
For the right owner, the specs are solid. The pan is food-grade steel with a BPA-free, aluminum-free, lead-free, cadmium-free, PFOS-free, PFAS-free and chemical-free material listing, and it has a maximum heat resistance of 480°F. It's rigid, so it holds its shape, lifts food out cleanly, and handles chicken wings, french fries, vegetables, pizza and steak — the brand positions it as a grill, bake and fry plate in one. It is dishwasher safe and described as non-stick and durable, with the caveat that you should not scrub it with a rough abrasive cloth or metal balls.
The one thing a new buyer must not skip: preheating. Because of how the steel behaves, the brand says you should place the pan in a preheated 300°F oven for 10 minutes before first use, otherwise it may deform, bend or be damaged and end up with a shorter lifespan. Follow that step and the pan should hold up for long-term use. Who should buy it: Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt owners who want a rigid, dishwasher-safe crisper plate for grilling and baking. Who should skip it: everyone with a different air fryer, and anyone who wants a flexible liner rather than a fixed-size metal pan.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for grilling wings, fries and vegetables → GWY Air Fryer Baking. The rigid steel plate with a 480°F ceiling is built for high-heat crisping and grilling.
• Best for appliance flexibility → X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake. It fits most air fryers, toaster ovens and baking pans; the GWY pan is locked to the Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt.
• Best for a specific Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt → GWY Air Fryer Baking. It's a purpose-made replacement pan, so fit is guaranteed if that's your oven.
• Best for easy cleanup → tie, with a caveat. The GWY pan is dishwasher safe; the X-Haibei mat is hand-wash simple and reusable but may stain over time.
• Best for freezer-to-oven use → X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake. Its -40°F to 440°F silicone range covers cold storage, freezing and oven baking in one item.
• Best for low-maintenance durability → GWY Air Fryer Baking. Steel resists bending and damage, though it demands the 300°F preheat and gentle washing to stay that way.
• Best for a first air fryer accessory → X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake. If you don't know your oven model or you use more than one appliance, the universal mat is the safer pick.
In my opinion, most shoppers should buy the X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake. It works in more appliances, handles both baking and air frying, tolerates freezer-to-oven temperature swings, and its flexibility is exactly what swiss rolls and cookies need. I would only steer you to the GWY Air Fryer Baking if you specifically own the Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt air fryer toaster oven and want a rigid, dishwasher-safe grill plate for that machine. If that's your oven, the GWY pan is the more purposeful tool; if it isn't, it simply won't fit, and the X-Haibei mat is the one I'd reach for.
FAQ
what is an air fryer baking pan
what is an air fryer cake pan
An air fryer cake pan is whatever you bake a cake in inside the air fryer — it can be a rigid metal pan or a flexible liner like the X-Haibei Swiss Roll Cake, a 10" x 11" x 0.78" silicone mat. The X-Haibei's pliable surface is what lets you roll a sponge cake without cracking it.
what is an air fryer safe baking pan
An air fryer safe baking pan is one rated to handle the heat your appliance produces. The X-Haibei silicone mat is rated from -40°F to 440°F, and the GWY steel plate is rated to 480°F, though GWY requires a 300°F preheat for 10 minutes before first use to prevent warping.
are air fryer pans oven safe
Not automatically — it depends on the material and rating. The X-Haibei mat is oven safe from -40°F to 440°F and also works for microwave heating and freezing. The GWY plate is rated to 480°F but is designed for the Nuwave Bravo 10-in-1 21 Qt air fryer toaster oven, so check your oven's fit and temperature before using it elsewhere. For current pricing on either option, check the latest price on Amazon.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners vs JolyWell 100Pcs: Air Fryer Cake, ReLuien 8 vs Wellsworth 40GSM: Air Fryer Cake, GWY 11.7"×11.7 vs GWYXC Air Fryer Basket