How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a liner that doubles as a genuine cake pan surface for square and larger air fryers, choose FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners; if you need a cheap, compostable everyday liner for a small 3–5 QT round basket and don't mind babysitting it with food, choose JolyWell 100Pcs.
• FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners — biggest strength: an 8.5-inch square sheet that fits square air fryers, oval and round baskets, and standard cake pans, so it works as a real baking surface for air fryer cake.
• FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners — biggest trade-off: it's a wider sheet, so it's overkill (and a poor fit) for small 3–5 QT round baskets.
• JolyWell 100Pcs — biggest strength: unbleached wood-pulp paper, silicone-coated and compostable, sized specifically for 3–5 QT round air fryers.
• JolyWell 100Pcs — biggest trade-off: a 6.3-inch round liner only fits small round baskets, and it must always sit under food.
• Who each pick is for: FLANCCI for bakers and owners of square, oval or larger round air fryers; JolyWell for owners of compact round fryers who want a disposable, compostable liner.
FLANCCI's liners are pre-cut 8.5-inch squares, and that shape is the whole story. A square sheet drops flat into a square basket without folding, curling or trimming, which is exactly what you want when you're pouring cake batter and need a level surface. The stated fit covers 8.6 to 9.6-inch square air fryers (roughly 5.3–5.8 QT), 10.5 to 11.5-inch oval fryers measured diagonally, and 11-inch round fryers — plus standard cake pans. That flexibility is unusual for a disposable liner.
The material is food-grade parchment rated to 450°F (230°C), and it's waterproof, oil-proof and non-stick. For air fryer cake specifically, that combination matters: batter doesn't weld itself to the paper, and the liner catches the overflow and crumbs that would otherwise bake onto the basket. Cleanup becomes a matter of lifting the sheet out. The brand also lists roasting, frying, steaming, microwave use, frying-pan use and even serving food, plus camping, BBQ and summer-party use, so it isn't a one-trick accessory.
Where it falls short is small fryers. If your basket is a 3–5 QT round, an 8.5-inch square is simply larger than what you're cooking in, and you'll be folding or trimming it — which defeats the point of a pre-cut liner. The other catch is stated plainly by the brand: the paper is lightweight, so you should always weigh it down with enough food. A bare liner with nothing on it can lift into the heating element. That's normal for parchment, but it's a real behavior change.
Buy it if you bake cakes, roast vegetables, or own a square, oval or larger round air fryer and want one liner that handles all of it. Skip it if your fryer is a compact round model.
JolyWell takes the opposite approach: 100 round liners, 6.3 inches across, built for 3–5 QT air fryers. If you own a small round basket and mostly cook single portions — a chicken thigh, a handful of fries, a couple of reheated pastries — the sizing is spot on and the round shape sits naturally in a round basket.
The material is the selling point here. These are made of wood pulp, unbleached, with no chemical substances, and the description notes a silicone-oil coating that makes them water- and oil-proof. They're described as compostable, which is a genuinely different disposal story from standard parchment. The paper absorbs fat and resists sticking, so food residue lifts away and the basket stays clean.
Temperature rating is 428°F (220°C), slightly lower than FLANCCI's 450°F, and the listed uses include toaster oven, microwave, frying pan, instant pot and baking cake. The brand's own usage tip is worth repeating: never use these liners without food on them, or they can catch fire in the air fryer. That's not a flaw unique to JolyWell, but it's the single most important thing to know before you buy.
The limitation is size and shape. A 6.3-inch round liner isn't going to cover the floor of a large square or oval basket, and it isn't a cake pan in the way an 8.5-inch square is. If your goal is baking a full-size air fryer cake in a square basket, this is the wrong tool.
Buy it if you have a 3–5 QT round air fryer, want a compostable liner, and cook with food every time. Skip it if you bake cakes in square pans or own a larger fryer.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for baking air fryer cake in a square pan → FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners (8.5-inch square, rated to 450°F).
• Best for compostable disposal → JolyWell 100Pcs (unbleached wood pulp, silicone-coated).
• Best for fit across multiple appliances → FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners (square fryers, oval fryers, 11-inch round fryers, cake pans, microwave).
• Best for high-heat roasting → FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners (450°F vs 428°F).
• Best if you want zero trimming → FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners for square baskets; JolyWell 100Pcs for round ones.
• Best for oven-to-table serving and BBQs → FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners (listed for serving food, camping, BBQ, parties).
• Best if you're unsure about price → check the current price on Amazon for both, since the two come in different pack formats and sizes.
In my opinion, if air fryer cake is the job, FLANCCI Air Fryer Liners is the one I'd buy. The 8.5-inch square is a real baking surface — it sits flat in a square basket or cake pan, takes 450°F, and doesn't need folding or cutting. The wider application list (roasting, microwave, frying pan, serving) means it earns its space in the drawer even on days you're not baking.
I'd only steer you to JolyWell 100Pcs if your fryer is a compact 3–5 QT round and you specifically want a compostable liner for everyday savory cooking. It's a well-matched product for that basket — just not a cake-baking liner for a square one. Whatever you pick, check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since the pack sizes differ.
how to air fryer cake
Line your basket first. With FLANCCI, drop an 8.5-inch square sheet flat into a square basket or cake pan; with JolyWell, use a 6.3-inch round liner in a 3–5 QT round basket. Always put batter or food on the liner before starting — both brands warn against running a bare liner, and JolyWell states plainly that an empty liner can catch fire.
how to air fryer cake mix
Boxed mix works the same way as scratch batter: pour it onto the liner, don't exceed a depth your basket can handle, and keep the temperature under the liner's limit — 450°F for FLANCCI, 428°F for JolyWell. The non-stick, oil-proof surface means the cake releases cleanly and the basket stays free of baked-on batter.
how to make air fryer cake
The liner does the heavy lifting. A pre-cut sheet gives you a flat, non-stick base so the cake lifts out in one piece instead of tearing, and it isolates the residue that would otherwise bake onto the basket. FLANCCI's square shape suits square baskets and cake pans; JolyWell's round shape suits round 3–5 QT baskets.
how to clean air fryer caked on grease
This is where disposable liners pay off. Because both papers are oil- and water-proof, they catch grease and crumbs before they reach the basket — lift the liner out and most of the mess leaves with it. FLANCCI lists stain isolation and reduced food residue directly; JolyWell markets the same "no mess, leaves fryer clean" benefit. Anything that escapes still needs a normal wash.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ZOWVAAM Air Fryer Liners vs MMH 4PCs, ctizne Air Fryer Liners vs Glazeal Three Stackable Dehydrator, GWBSXM Air Fryer Rack vs mutvle Air Fryer Liners