How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• GWY 11.7"×11.7" — biggest strength: A 11.77" × 11.77" × 1.06" food-grade steel pan that lists compatibility with several Breville Smart Ovens (BOV800XL, BOV810BSS, BOV845BSS, BOV900BSS) as well as Ninja SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201 models.
• GWY 11.7"×11.7" — biggest trade-off: It's one flat pan, not a mesh fry basket, so airflow around food is more limited, and the brand stresses a mandatory 300°F / 12-minute preheat before first use to avoid warping.
• GWYXC Air Fryer Basket — biggest strength: A two-piece set — a 16.4" × 11.6" mesh basket plus a 16.5" × 12.2" wire rack — made of stainless steel, giving you mesh airflow for air frying and a rack for roasting or dehydrating.
• GWYXC Air Fryer Basket — biggest trade-off: It's sized for one oven only (Breville BOV900 / BOV900BSS), the brand explicitly says it's not compatible with other models, and the larger footprint may not fit smaller ovens.
• Who each pick is for: GWY 11.7"×11.7" for owners of several Breville/Ninja models who want one versatile pan; GWYXC Air Fryer Basket for BOV900BSS owners who air fry and roast often and want two pieces.
This is a flat baking pan, not an air-fry basket, and that shapes everything about who should buy it. At 11.77" × 11.77" by 1.06" tall and weighing 0.46 kg, it's a single-piece tray in food-grade alloy steel, BPA-free, listed as meeting FDA standards and finished in silver. The brand positions it as a multi-purpose surface: chicken wings, fries, vegetables, pizza, steak, sheet-pan style dinners. It's also dishwasher safe, with the usual warning to skip abrasive pads and metal scrubbers.
The real draw is compatibility. GWY lists this pan as designed for the Breville Compact Smart Oven and Mini Smart Oven, and names the BOV800XL, BOV810BSS, BOV845BSS and BOV900BSS, plus Ninja SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201 Foodi Air Fry Ovens. If you own one of those — or you've moved between them — one pan that covers all of them is genuinely convenient.
Two things worth knowing before you buy. First, GWY is unusually explicit that you must preheat this pan at 300°F for 12 minutes before first use, and warns it may deform, bend or be damaged otherwise, shortening its lifespan. Take that seriously; it's a steel pan with a stated 480°F max. Second, because it's a solid pan rather than a mesh basket, air circulation is more limited — the brand describes 360° heat circulation around the tray and says you don't need to flip food, but a mesh design simply moves more hot air. I'd steer you here if you want one sturdy, dishwasher-safe pan that fits a range of ovens; I'd skip it if crisp, deep-basket air frying is your main goal or your oven isn't on that compatibility list.
This one is a purpose-built set, and it's narrow on purpose. The GWYXC Air Fryer Basket is a two-piece kit: a 16.4" × 11.6" mesh basket and a 16.5" × 12.2" wire rack, both in food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free and heat-resistant. It's designed specifically for the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900 / BOV900BSS), and the brand states plainly that it is not compatible with other models and suggests measuring your oven's interior before ordering. Package dimensions run 16.93" × 12.56" × 1.69", and the set weighs about 1.47 lb.
The two-piece design is the point. The mesh basket is for air frying — wings, fries — with the 360° airflow a mesh surface allows. The wire rack handles roasting meats or works as a dehydrator rack for fruit snacks. Having both means you can run two batches or two different dishes at once, which is a real workflow win in a countertop oven.
Maintenance is straightforward: 100% dishwasher safe, with a warm-water soak recommended for stuck-on food and a warning to avoid steel wool or abrasive scrubbers to protect the polished finish. Like the GWY pan, GWYXC asks for a preheat before first use — 10 minutes at 300°F — to help the metal adapt and reduce minor warping. Buy this if you own a BOV900BSS and air fry or dehydrate regularly; skip it if your oven is any other model, because the brand says it won't fit.
• Best for oven compatibility range → GWY 11.7"×11.7" — it lists multiple Breville and Ninja models; GWYXC lists only the BOV900/BOV900BSS.
• Best for true air frying → GWYXC Air Fryer Basket — the mesh basket is built for 360° airflow; the GWY pan is a solid surface.
• Best for roasting and dehydrating → GWYXC Air Fryer Basket — the included wire rack doubles as a dehydrator rack.
• Best for cooking two things at once → GWYXC Air Fryer Basket — two pieces versus GWY's single pan.
• Best for a simple all-rounder pan → GWY 11.7"×11.7" — one flat tray for pizza, wings, veggies and sheet-pan meals.
• Best for smaller ovens → GWY 11.7"×11.7" — its 11.77" square footprint is smaller than GWYXC's 16.4"–16.5" length.
• Best for material spec → a tie on safety, a split on type — both are food-grade, BPA-free and dishwasher safe; GWY is alloy steel, GWYXC is stainless steel.
• Best for buyers who want a low-fuss first-use routine → GWYXC Air Fryer Basket — 10 minutes at 300°F versus GWY's 12 minutes.
In my opinion, the deciding factor isn't quality — both are food-grade, BPA-free and dishwasher safe — it's your oven and your cooking style. If you own a Breville BOV900BSS and you air fry or dehydrate often, I'd buy the GWYXC Air Fryer Basket: the mesh basket plus rack set does things a flat pan can't, and it's sized for that exact oven. If you own a different Breville or a Ninja, or you mainly want one sturdy pan for roasting and sheet-pan meals, I'd buy the GWY 11.7"×11.7" instead. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and measure your oven interior either way.
FAQ
Yes, per the brand. It lists compatibility with Ninja SP100, SP101, SP1001C and SP201, plus Breville BOV800XL, BOV810BSS, BOV845BSS and BOV900BSS.
Both brands say yes. GWY asks for 300°F for 12 minutes; GWYXC suggests 10 minutes at 300°F. Both say this reduces the risk of warping and helps the metal last.
Both are dishwasher safe. Both brands recommend a short warm-water soak for stuck-on food and warn against steel wool or abrasive scrubbers that can damage the finish.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Brentwood AF-400DBK vs ZAWAYINE Air Fryer: Best Mini Air, Webake 6 vs JSJMOFA Round Air Fryer: Air Fryer Bacon, Kunovo 【2 vs KSENDALO 2: Air Fryer Spatula