von Susanne Schmid, Mathias Huebener, Malin Mahlbacher & Gundula Zoch
Diese Studie untersucht den Zusammenhang zwischen dem mütterlichen Alter bei der Geburt und der kognitiven sowie sozial-emotionalen Entwicklung von Kindern in Deutschland. Dabei wurden Daten von über 2.300 Neugeborenen aus der Nationalen Bildungspanel (NEPS) genutzt. Die Ergebnisse weisen darauf hin, dass Kinder von Müttern unter 30 Jahren und von Müttern mit niedrigerer Bildung eine geringere Entwicklung aufweisen. Die Studie untersucht dann, inwiefern familiale und bildungsbezogene Faktoren die Entwicklungsunterschiede erklären können.
Kurzbericht als BiB aktuell. In der Presse: GEO, Welt.
Under Review. Preprint.
Abstract:
Objective: This study examines whether higher maternal age benefits cognitive and non-cognitive child development, and tests theory-derived mechanisms underlying this relationship.
Background: Rising maternal education and labor market participation have contributed to an increase in maternal age at first birth, linked to improved child abilities in the US. However, for Europe, where demographic dynamics and institutional settings differ, evidence remains limited. Theories of child development, human capital and concepts of maturity, which foster child development through improved learning environments, can explain this link.
Method: This study uses a random probability sample of newborns of the German National Educational Panel Study (NEPS-SC1; 2012-2021; N=2,387) to examine the relationship between maternal age at birth and cognitive (math, vocabulary) and social-emotional child development up to age nine. Linear regression analyses investigate the main relationship and explore potential mediators (parenting quality, maternal well-being, family resources).
Results: Results show statistically significant, inversely U-shaped associations between maternal age at birth and both cognitive and social-emotional development. Enhanced cognitive abilities are largely attributable to family resources and parenting quality. However, differences by maternal age are primarily driven by young mothers up to age 30 and lower educated mothers.
von Mathias Huebener, Malin Mahlbacher & Sophia Schmitz
Diese Studie beleuchtet, wie der Ausbau frühkindlicher Betreuung nicht nur Müttern den rascheren Wiedereinstieg in den Beruf ermöglicht, sondern zugleich das Engagement von Vätern beeinflusst – und wo die Grenzen dieser Politik liegen.
Under Review.
Abstract: Increasing fathers’ involvement in childcare is seen as an important strategy to reduce women’s child penalties in the labour market and address declining fertility rates in high-income countries. However, very little is known about the extent to which family policies can incentivise parents to share the burden of child rearing more equally. This paper examines the impact of universal, highly subsidised childcare provision — one of the most important measures to support mothers in the labour market – on fathers’ involvement across different stages of childhood. For identification, we exploit a major German reform generating large temporal and spatial variation in childcare coverage for children under the age of three, within a policy environment where fathers’ early engagement is incentivised through generous paternal leave provisions. Our generalised difference-in-differences estimations show that expanding universal childcare significantly accelerates children’s entry into childcare and increases fathers’ likelihood of taking paternity leave, in response to mothers’ shorter leave durations and earlier reentry into the labour market. Fathers’ subsequent caregiving roles remain largely unaffected by the expansion of childcare, whereas women exhibit pronounced labour supply responses at both the intensive and extensive margins, alongside modest reductions in fathers’ full-time employment. Overall, increased childcare availability seems to promote a more equal division of parental leave and labour supply; yet the significant policy effort could not substantially alter father’s caregiving responsibilities within the family.
von Mathias Huebener & Reto Odermatt
In dieser Studie zeigen wir, wie unterschiedlich Kinder das Leben und Wohlbefinden von Müttern und Vätern beeinflussen: Während Väter langfristig von höherem Wohlbefinden profitieren, erfahren Mütter nur eine kurzfristige Steigerung, gefolgt von einer deutlichen Belastung in Bezug auf Karriere und Hausarbeit. Mütter nehmen die Arbeitsaufteilung zunehmend als unfair wahr, was auf eine tiefergehende Ungleichheit in der Familienarbeit hinweist. Um mögliche Verzerrungen durch den Wunsch nach Kindern zu vermeiden, vergleichen wir in der Studie nur Menschen mit Kinderwunschbehandlung, von denen einige erfolgreich waren, und andere erfolglos bleiben. Ein neuer Blick auf die Kosten der Elternschaft!
Under Review. IZA Discussion Paper 18039.
Abstract: We assess the gendered effects of having children on well-being, careers, and the division of domestic work. As exogenous variation in parenthood, we exploit the quasi-random success of in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) treatments. Children increase mothers’ well-being only in the short term, while fathers experience longer-lasting gains. However, only mothers show a persistent decline in labor supply and a rise in domestic work. Their satisfaction with the division of work declines, and they are more likely to perceive it as unfair, implying that the new equilibrium deviates from mothers’ preferences.
von Mathias Huebener, Malin Mahlbacher, Susanne Schmid & Gundula Zoch
Immer mehr Mütter kehren nach der Geburt früher in den Beruf zurück – doch welche Rolle spielt der Arbeitsplatz selbst für ihre Kinder? Sind familienfreundliche Unternehmen auch kinderfreundlich? Diese Studie fragt, ob Firmenbedingungen die Entwicklung von Kindern indirekt fördern können. Die Ergebnisse zeigen: Solche Strukturen erleichtern zwar den Wiedereinstieg der Mütter, haben aber nur begrenzten Einfluss auf kindliche Entwicklungsverläufe.
Draft in Preparation.
Abstract: Prior to becoming mothers, women now spend more time in the labour market and in professional activities. This trend continues after childbirth, resulting in a significant shift in family life and early childhood environments. While a large body of literature analyses the consequences of maternal employment on child development, limited attention has been given to the role of pre-birth labour market experience and job characteristics. This study aims to fill this research gap by utilizing rich panel data on child development from the German National Education Panel Study, linked to administrative data on mothers’ employment histories (NEPS-SC1-ADIAB). First, to understand potential mechanisms, we investigate how pre-birth employment characteristics are related to mothers’ re-entry into employment after giving birth. Then, we analyse whether maternal employment conditions and workplace characteristics before childbirth are associated with cognitive and non-cognitive child development over the first ten years of children’s lives. Preliminary results indicate that various firm characteristics are relevant to the length of mothers' employment interruptions. However, at present, we have not found strong evidence suggesting that firm characteristics are linked to children's cognitive or non-cognitive development.
von Gundula Zoch, Susanne Schmid & Ann-Christin Bächmann
Wenn Mütter nach der Elternzeit in den Beruf zurückkehren, bringen sie mehr als nur Einkommen mit nach Hause – sie bringen Fähigkeiten, Denkweisen und Erfahrungen mit. Diese Studie untersucht erstmals mit deutschen Längsschnittdaten, ob und wie analytische oder spezialisierte Job-Skills mit kognitiven und sozialen Kompetenzen von Kindern zusammenhängen. Die Ergebnisse zeigen: Der Einfluss ist messbar, aber begrenzt – ein wichtiger Beitrag zur Debatte über Bildungschancen und Erwerbstätigkeit.
Under Review. Preprint.
Abstract: This study examines the link between maternal occupation-specific skills and child development following mothers’ return to work. We draw on the long-running Newborn Starting Cohort from the German National Education Panel Study, linked with administrative records on mothers’ employment biographies (NEPS-SC1-ADIAB, 2012-2021) and expert-coded occupational task data. Extending previous research providing mixed findings on mathematical and verbal competencies after age 5, we examine cognitive and non-cognitive child development between ages three and nine. Results from OLS-models show small but statistically significant associations between mothers’ highly specialised, analytical job skills and children’s vocabulary scores, while links with math, science, and socio-emotional behaviour were modest. Other types of job tasks showed only small associations with any child outcome. Additional fixed-effects models provide little support that changes in maternal occupations influence child development. Overall, our findings suggest a limited role of occupation-specific skills in the intergenerational transmission of educational inequalities.
von Susanne Schmid & Hannah Steinberg
Mütterliche Erwerbstätigkeit hat in den vergangenen Jahrzehnten stark zugenommen, insbesondere bei Müttern jüngerer Kinder. Während mütterliche Erwerbstätigkeit bereits breiter erforscht wurde, gibt es wenige Erkenntnisse darüber, wie Mütter diese Erwerbstätigkeit durch passende Kindesbetreuung ermöglichen. Die Studie untersucht daher das Zusammenspiel von mütterlicher Erwerbstätigkeit und kindlichen Betreuungsverläufen, womit ein erster Beitrag zur Erschließung dieses Themas erbracht wird. Ergebnisse zeigen weite Unterschiede in der Kombination von Beruf und Betreuung.
Draft in Preparation
Abstract: European countries increased funding for early childhood education and care (ECEC) to support maternal employment. While research mainly examines how institutional childcare supports maternal employment, knowledge about the simultaneous development of employment and childcare remains incomplete, despite external caregivers being crucial for mothers’ work participation. This study takes a trajectory-based approach to (1) examine how different childcare types and maternal employment are interrelated, and (2) analyze how childcare-work patterns vary by socioeconomic background.
Drawing on the life-course-perspective, we focus on the linked-lives paradigm to explore the interplay between mother’s and children’s life domains. Based on rational cost-benefit-considerations, we argue that advantaged mothers, facing higher opportunity costs of childcare, enter employment and ECEC earlier, while less advantaged mothers delay both. Therefore, we contribute (1) by providing novel evidence on the interplay of maternal employment and childcare histories from a trajectory-based perspective; and (2) we extend previous studies by considering the full range of employment and childcare statuses to deepen the understanding of social realities.
We use a linkage of the newborn-sample of the German National Educational Panel Study and administrative maternal employment trajectories (NEPS-SC1-ADIAB7521; 2012-2017; N≈1,642) to identify childcare-work-patterns conducting multichannel sequence and cluster analysis. We assess monthly information on childcare usage from birth until age five (parents, family, institutions, childminders and combinations) and maternal employment (full-time, part-time or marginal employment, parental leave, unemployment, inactivity). Using multinomial regressions, we identify characteristics predicting cluster affiliation.
Results reveal six childcare-work-trajectories that extend beyond typically expected patterns. Three family-focused-clusters show that lower maternal workforce participation occurs together with long parental childcare and late institutional enrollment. Conversely, three work-focused-clusters involve early employment re-entry, either with institutional childcare alone or with family support and both combinations. Next steps will explore heterogeneity within and between clusters more deeply.
von Susanne Schmid
Bildungsungleichheit von Kindesbeinen an ist bis heute auch in Deutschland noch stark ausgeprägt. Deswegen untersucht diese Studie, ob eine frühe Intervention in Form eines frühen Kindergartenbesuchs sich positiv auf den langfristigen Bildungserfolg der Kinder auswirkt. Ergebnisse zeigen eine beschränkte Wirksamkeit frühkindlicher Betreuung, unabhängig vom sozialen Hintergrund der Familie.
R&R at Child Development
Abstract: This study is the first to investigate the causal relation between universal childcare for three- to under six-year-olds and the long-term educational attainment in Germany by conducting an instrumental variable approach. A reform, which legally entitled three-year-olds to childcare in 1996, caused an exogenous expansion of childcare supply, which serves as instrument. Using the German National Educational Panel Study (NEPS, 2010-2021, N=7,886, 48 % female; 22 % migrant; Mean_AgeGraduation=17.4), the results suggest that the reform extended children’s childcare attendance by up to 1.7 months for each 10 %-points increase in supply, but a longer duration in childcare caused no higher attainment of school-leaving certificates. Findings illustrate the limited effectiveness of a mere quantitative expansion of universal childcare for enhanced educational attainment.