How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• WMKGG's biggest strength: food-safe silicone that's non-stick, non-BPA and heat resistant from -40°F up to 428°F, with dozens of raised silicone lines built in for air circulation and even crisping.
• WMKGG's biggest trade-off: it's a 2-pack, so you're washing and reusing the same liners rather than reaching for a fresh one — and it's sized around dual-zone baskets (8.25 x 5.7 inches, fitting 8-quart double-basket fryers).
• mutvle's biggest strength: 200 pre-cut, bowl-shaped parchment liners (8 x 5 inches) with a 4.5 cm raised edge, made from unbleached wood pulp with a plant-based oil treatment, heat resistant to 450°F.
• mutvle's biggest trade-off: they're disposable, so the supply is finite, and the listing itself warns you to press the paper down with food so hot air doesn't lift it onto the heating element.
• Pick WMKGG if you want one purchase, zero paper waste and a liner you can flip inside out and wash.
• Pick mutvle if you want the fastest possible cleanup and don't mind throwing a sheet away each time.
The WMKGG liner is a molded silicone basket insert, sold as a 2-pack, shaped rectangular at 8.25 x 5.7 inches and 0.1 inches thin at the base. It's explicitly designed around dual-zone air fryers — the listing names the Ninja Z201/Z401 dual baskets and other dual-zone models — and the stated fit is 8-quart double-basket fryers. Each liner has handles on both sides, which is the detail that matters most day to day: you lift the whole insert out by the handles instead of fishing around in a hot basket.
What it does best is replace parchment entirely. Silicone is non-stick, so food releases, and the surface is covered in dozens of soft raised lines that create air channels under the food — that's what the design is for, better circulation and more even crisping than a flat sheet. The material is food-safe grade, non-BPA, and rated from -40°F up to 428°F, so it handles air frying, oven baking, steaming, Instant Pot and microwave use. It's dishwasher safe, and you can also just flip it inside out and rinse it with warm water.
Buy it if you cook in a dual-basket fryer most days and want a reusable liner you don't have to restock. It's also a good fit if you dislike the idea of disposable paper or you've had thin parchment curl up near the heating element. Skip it if you own a single-basket fryer whose shape doesn't match a rectangular insert, or if you know you'll never hand-wash anything — because even a dishwasher-safe liner has to be loaded, and two liners cover two baskets, nothing more. Note the care instructions list both dishwasher safe and hand wash only, so treat warm-water hand washing as the gentler option.
The mutvle liner is a different product category: a pack of 200 disposable parchment sheets, pre-formed into a rectangle 8 x 5 inches with a 4.5 cm raised edge, so you drop one in without tearing, folding, cutting or bending. The material is unbleached natural wood pulp with a plant-based oil treatment — no fluorescent agent, BPA-free and PFA-free — and the sheets are stated as 12% thicker than ordinary parchment, which is the claim behind "won't tear when lifting even after cooking." Heat resistance is up to 450°F / 230°C.
Compatibility is where mutvle earns its place: it's custom-designed for the CHEFMAN 6-quart dual basket air fryer oven, and the listing also names Ninja 6-quart dual basket models, the TurboFry Touch dual air fryer and the COSORI 9-quart dual air fryer. If you own one of those, the fit is the point — a liner that actually matches your basket catches drips instead of letting them run underneath.
Buy it if cleanup is the thing you hate. The oil-leak-resistant bowl shape means you lift the sheet out and throw it away, no scrubbing. It's also genuinely versatile: baking, roasting, frying, even serving food, and it travels well for camping, BBQ and parties because it's flat-packed paper, not a bulky silicone insert. Skip it if you want a one-time purchase — 200 sheets is a lot, but it is a finite supply — or if you're not willing to follow the manufacturer's own instruction to press the paper down with food. That warning exists for a reason: a light, underfilled sheet can get blown up onto the heating tube. It's also not the pick if you specifically want to cut paper waste.
• Best for zero restocking → WMKGG Silicone Air Fryer. Two liners, reused indefinitely, versus a 200-sheet consumable pack.
• Best for fastest cleanup → mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer. Lift, toss, done — no washing at all.
• Best for dual-basket Ninja and 8-quart double-basket fryers → WMKGG. The 8.25 x 5.7 inch insert with side handles is built around that layout.
• Best for CHEFMAN 6-quart, TurboFry Touch or COSORI 9-quart dual fryers → mutvle. Those are the models its 8 x 5 inch bowl shape is designed to fit.
• Best for air circulation and crisping → WMKGG. The raised silicone line pattern exists specifically to lift food and move hot air underneath.
• Best for catching grease and crumbs with no leakage → mutvle. The 4.5 cm raised edge and oil-leak-resistant bowl are the whole design.
• Best for camping, parties and travel → mutvle. Flat paper packs and travels far more easily than molded silicone.
• Best if you want to stop buying liners → WMKGG. In my opinion, the reusable route wins on long-term convenience even though it costs you a wash each time.
I'd buy the WMKGG Silicone Air Fryer liners. If you cook in a dual-basket fryer several times a week, a reusable insert you rinse and drop back in beats working through a stack of paper — and the built-in airflow ridges are a real functional upgrade over a flat sheet. I'd switch to mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer if cleanup, not restocking, is my pain point, or if I owned a CHEFMAN or COSORI dual basket and wanted a liner cut to match it. Both are sensible; they just solve different problems.
FAQ
The sheets are rated heat resistant up to 450°F / 230°C and are made from unbleached wood pulp with a plant-based oil treatment, BPA-free and PFA-free. Follow the included instruction to press the paper down with food so it doesn't lift into the heating element.
No — they're listed as dishwasher safe, and you can also flip them inside out and rinse with warm water. The care instructions also list hand wash only, so either method is acceptable depending on how careful you want to be.
WMKGG. It's a 2-pack of reusable silicone, so there's nothing to restock, while mutvle is a 200-sheet disposable pack. If you'd rather never scrub a liner, mutvle is the trade-off pick. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer vs ctizne 420PCS, iHuungry Air Fryer Silicone vs Boribim 2: What Can You Cook, Linda's Essentials Silicone Trivets vs MOKKHNB Rectangular Stainless S