In an effort to generate wider and more holistic discussions of sustainability concerns, we have designed a few lesson plans that multiple instructors can pick up. The lessons have been designed to be easy to pick up and incorporate into whatever agenda it needs to. The ultimate goal here is to have an independent website that allows multiple groups across multiple organizations to discuss the same concerns. This will allow more minds to connect to each other and allow deeper, more involved, and more holistic discussion.
Jevons Paradox arises when an increase in efficiency has a corresponding increase in gross consumption. The term was coined by English economist William Stanley Jevons in his 1865 book the Coal Question when he noticed coal was being consumed at a faster rate despite the improved efficiency of the factories. The paradox does not just apply to coal. It can also apply to food, lighting, water, pretty much anything you can consume. The reason for this is that when a consumable gets cheaper, people just buy more of that consumable. When gas is cheap, more people buy gas. Simply Explained has an informative video below on the Jevons Paradox.
However, that does not mean that increasing efficiency is bad. To see how increasing efficiency is good you only have to look at the Grand Valley University campus. Looking at Image 1, GVSU’s campus has doubled in size over the past twenty years. Despite this, looking at Image 2, electricity consumption on campus has stayed roughly steady since 2005. This is because, through various energy saving initiatives such as motion sensor light, high efficiency boils, and low flow flush valves, GVSU has managed to increase their energy efficiency each year (see Image 3). Image 2 also shows what GVSU’s current energy consumption would be with 2001 efficiency.
As GVSU has shown, increasing efficiency can counteract growing consumption. What are ways you can make your own life more efficient? Find five things in your life that you can change to become more efficient and less wasteful and how. It can range in any scale, from buying local food only to riding your bike everywhere. Next, choose two of these changes and commit to doing them for one week. After that week is over, reflect on your experience. How drastically did it change your daily routine? Is it something you can continue to commit to? Did it cost anything or did you save on expenses or time? The post should be a minimum of 250 words and contains references to outside sources. If another person did the same thing as you, respond to their post on how your experiences were similar or different. Otherwise add a meaningful contribution to another's post.
Graph depicting GVSU's campus size over the past 20 years. It is a positive slope.
Graph depicting GVSU's energy usage over time. The blue line is actual usage and has stayed mostly steady since 2005 and the orange line is usage based on GVSU's efficiency from 2002.
Graph depicting GVSU's annual energy efficiency over the past 20 years. Energy used per square foot has been decreasing over time.
Sources:
Meredith, R. (2022, February 3). Vladimir’s Interview with Rence Meredith (V. Tomorsky, Interviewer).
Simply Explained. (2020, April 19). Jevons Paradox & The Rebound Effect. Retrieved March 23, 2022, from www.youtube.com website: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTfwhbfMnNc
Right now there is a growing demand for renewable energy sources to replace the environmentally harmful fossil fuels. There is concern that the particulate matter released into the atmosphere will accelerate the effects of global warming, making life worse for future generations. To combat this potential future, changes in energy sources may be necessary. Many see this switch as an imperative to saving the planet, but do not take into consideration that there are costs of alternative energy sources such as solar, wind, hydroelectric, nuclear energy, natural gasses, and others.
For example, the batteries used to store the energy retrieved from solar panels is typically stored in lithium ion batteries. Lithium mines are one of the most harmful mines due to the fact that they release a ton of carbon into the atmosphere, enhancing the effects of global warming. While the carbon released from the mines may not be as environmentally harmful as the burning of fossil fuels, it is still important to consider the materials in the actual solar panels themselves. Some of the metals on solar panels are toxic. When the life of the solar panel is over and they go into the dump, they have a tendency to leach into the soil and harm the soil and water quality nearby.
There is also an international relationships element to consider. As of right now, the US has imposed a sanction on Russia in reaction to the recent invasion of Ukraine. This decision was made by officials because they valued cutting off our enemies financially over keeping gas prices low. Likely, there will always be moral conundrums like this surrounding energy sources. Similarly, in 2021 Biden banned the import of solar panels and solar panel materials from China because they were mistreating their workers.
As shown in the graph below, the US has not changed its proportion of renewable energy. The only essential difference between our energy consumption now and in 1950 is that there is a greater overall number of thermal units. The key point being we are not replacing any energy sources. Each additional energy source is just adding on to the total amount of energy consumption.
As shown in the graph below, the US has not changed its proportion of renewable energy. The only essential difference between our energy consumption now and in 1950 is that there is a greater overall number of thermal units. The key point being we are not replacing any energy sources. Each additional energy source is just adding on to the total amount of energy consumption.
Every energy source has a certain amount of unavoidable consequences, but it is up to our collective discretion to weigh which negative effects are most acceptable. What other negative effects of alternative energies can you think of or find online? Compare and contrast the effects of fossil fuels to an alternative energy source besides solar. Provide the negative and positive of both options and explain why one is more desirable than the other.
Sources:
CNBC. (2021, June 24). U.S. bans imports of solar panel material from Chinese company. Retrieved from CNBC website: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/24/united-states-bans-imports-of-solar-panel-material-from-chinese-company.html
Energy production and consumption in the United States. Energy Production and Consumption in the United States | EBF 301: Global Finance for the Earth, Energy, and Materials Industries. (n.d.). Retrieved March 23, 2022, from https://www.e-education.psu.edu/ebf301/node/457
Shellenberger, M. (2021, June 21). Dark Side To Solar? More Reports Tie Panel Production To Toxic Pollution. Retrieved March 23, 2022, from Forbes website: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2021/06/21/why-everything-they-said-about-solar---including-that-its-clean-and-cheap---was-wrong/?sh=44d0003f5fe5
The Renewable Energy Hub. (2018). What is a Solar Cell Made Up of? - The Renewable Energy Hub. Retrieved from The Renewable Energy Hub website: https://www.renewableenergyhub.co.uk/main/solar-panels/what-is-a-solar-cell-made-up-of/
If you ask the average person their thoughts on climate change they are probably going to say that it is bad. If you ask them why they will most likely answer with something along the lines of a warming earth or rising sea levels. However, most people usually do not think of how climate change affects people specifically. They may know that global warming is a part of climate change but they do not know what that means in a real world context outside of shorter winters.
For instance, the Midwest, including West Michigan, is not going to experience the worst of climate change. If you are a middle- to working-class person in West Michigan you will see very little of climate change. The Great Lakes and temperate climate act as a moderating influence against climate change. The Midwest is not immune to climate change, still experiencing severe floods and weather, but not to the same extent as the coasts or more arid regions. This, coupled with relatively developed infrastructure and policies, means that West Michigan is being considered as a climate haven. However, this just gives the area unique challenges. They will have to adapt to both climate change as well the flow of people moving to the area because of climate change. Will the Midwest be able to support these people whilst keeping its relatively high quality of life and its status as a climate haven?
How does climate change affect other demographics? Choose one demographic to research; an ethnic group, an age group, or the population density of a city or a region are few examples. Next, find one negative aspect of climate change and one positive aspect that affects them and write a 250 word response on your findings. Are they disproportionately affected by climate change? How are they adapting to the challenges posed by climate change? Also provide a meaningful contribution to another person’s post.
Sources:
Francis, J. (2021, July 6). Will Michigan become a “climate haven?” Retrieved March 23, 2022, from WOODTV.com website: https://www.woodtv.com/news/michigan/will-michigan-become-a-climate-haven/
Marlon, J., Neyens, L., Jefferson, M., Howe, P., Mildenberger, M., & Leiserowitz, A. (2019). Yale Climate Opinion Maps 2019 - Yale Program on Climate Change Communication. Retrieved from Yale Program on Climate Change Communication website: https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us/
Yoder, K. (2021, December 7). Fleeing global warming? “Climate havens” aren’t ready for you yet.. Retrieved from Grist website: https://grist.org/migration/fleeing-global-warming-climate-havens-arent-ready-for-you-yet/
Grading/Evaluation Rubric
By: Vladimir Tomorsky & Mason Burkeen