Workshop on Von Neumann Algebras and Geometric Group Theory
UCSD, February 10-12, 2023
Description
This is the second in a series of workshops focusing on interactions between von Neumann algebras and geometric group theory. These workshops are organized by Ionut Chifan, Adrian Ioana, Denis Osin and Jesse Peterson, and are supported by the NSF through the organizers' FRG: Collaborative Research: von Neumann Algebras Associated to Groups Acting on Hyperbolic Spaces (FRG-DMS-1854074, FRG-DMS-1853989, FRG-DMS- 1854194). Support for this workshop is also provided by the Department of Mathematics and the School of Physical Sciences at UCSD.
All talks will be held in room 6402 (Halkin Room) in the AP&M (Applied Physics & Mathematics) building. See here for a map of the UCSD campus and building locator. We also plan to broadcast the talks live on zoom. Please email Adrian Ioana for the zoom link.
Invited speakers
Changying Ding (Vanderbilt University), Daniel Drimbe (KU Leuven), Alex Furman (University of Illinois at Chicago), Gil Goffer (UCSD), Isaac Goldbring (UCI), Ben Hayes (University of Virginia), Jingyin Huang (Ohio State University), Mehrdad Kalantar (University of Houston), Srivatsav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli (IPAM, UCLA), David Jekel (UCSD), Jesse Peterson (Vanderbilt University), Sorin Popa (UCLA), Dimitri Shlyakhtenko (UCLA), Bin Sun (Oxford University), Hui Tan (UCSD), Robin Tucker-Drob (University of Florida).
Participants
Adriana Fernández Quero, University of Iowa
Aldo Garcia Guinto, Michigan State University
Arianna Cecco, University of Houston
Bill Helton, UCSD
Brandon Seward, University of California San Diego
Caleb Barnett, University of Houston
Connor Thompson, Purdue University
David Gao, UCSD
Dulanji Amaraweera, University of Iowa
Dumindu Sandakith Kasiwatte Kankanamge, Vanderbilt University
Fabian Salinas, Vanderbilt
Gregory Patchell, UC San Diego
Hans Wenzl, UCSD
Ishan Ishan, UC Riverside
Jennifer Pi, UC Irvine
Juan Felipe Ariza Mejia, The University of Iowa
Jun Yang, Harvard University
Juniper Bahr, UCLA
Kai Toyosawa, Vanderbilt University
Koichi Oyakawa, Vanderbilt University
Krishnendu Khan, Purdue University
Michael Davis, University of Iowa
Nicholas Boschert, Ucla
Patrick DeBonis, Purdue University
Patrick Hiatt, UCLA
Pradyut Karmakar, Ohio University
Priyanga Ganesan, UC San Diego
Qingyuan Chen, UCSD
Rolando de Santiago, Purdue
Sayan Das, UC Riverside
Tanvi Telang, University of Houston
Tianyi Zheng, UCSD
Vincent Villalobos, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Xin Ma, University of Memphis
Yoonkyeong Lee, Michigan State University
Zhen-Chuan Liu, Baylor University
Schedule
Friday, February 10:
9:00-9:40 Ben Hayes
9:50-10:30 Hui Tan
10:30-11:00 coffee break
11:00-11:40 Isaac Goldbring
11:50-12:30 Gil Goffer
12:30-2:30 lunch break
2:30-3:10 Robin Tucker-Drob
3:10-3:40 coffee break
3:40-4:20 Bin Sun
4:30-5:30 problem session
Saturday, February 11:
9:30-10:10 Jingyin Huang
10:10-10:40 coffee break
10:40-11:20 Alex Furman
11:30-12:10 Dima Shlyakhtenko
12:10-2:00 lunch break
2:00-2:40 Sorin Popa
2:40-3:10 coffee break
3:10-3:50 David Jekel
4:00-4:40 Daniel Drimbe
Sunday, February 12:
9:00-9:40 Srivatsav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli
9:50-10:30 Mehrdad Kalantar
10:30-11:00 coffee break
11:00-11:40 Jesse Peterson
11:50-12:30 Changying Ding
End of the workshop
Titles and abstracts
Changying Ding (Vanderbilt University)
Title: Biexact von Neumann algebras (part II)
Abstract: The notion of biexactness for groups was introduced by Ozawa in 2004 and has since become a major tool used for studying indecomposability properties of von Neumann algebras. We will introduce the notion of a biexact von Neumann algebra, which allows us to place many previous indecomposability results in a more systematic context, and naturally leads to extensions of these results. We will give explicit connections between biexactness, malleable deformations, and closable derivations, allowing us to unify three separate approaches to solidity that were developed initially 15-20 years ago. The techniques also give a new characterization of weakly exact von Neumann algebras, answering a problem of Brown and Ozawa.
Daniel Drimbe (KU Leuven)
Title: Rigidity for von Neumann algebras of graph product groups
Abstract: In this talk I will discuss some rigidity results of group von Neumann algebras L(G), where G is a graph product group whose underlying graph is a certain cycle of cliques and the vertex groups are the wreath-like product property (T) groups introduced recently by Chifan, Ioana, Osin and Sun. By combining methods from Popa's deformation/rigidity theory with new techniques pertaining to graph product groups, we describe all the symmetries of these von Neumann algebras. This is joint work with Ionut Chifan and Michael Davis.
Alex Furman (University of Illinois at Chicago)
Title: Marked length spectrum and arithmeticity in negative curvature
Abstract: Given a closed manifold $M$ equipped with a Riemannian metric $g$ of negative sectional curvature, one can associate a positive real number $\ell_g(c)$ to each conjugacy class $c$ of the fundamental group $\Gamma=\pi_1(M)$, namely the $g$-length of the shortest loop on $M$ in the free homotopy class $c$.
In the talk we will discuss some conjectures and results, old and new related to the function $\ell_g(c)$, arithmeticity of rank one lattices, and commensurators.
The talk is based on a work by Yanlong Hao, Furman and Hao, and some related work by Bader and Furman.
Gil Goffer (UCSD)
Title: compact URS and compact IRS
Abstract: I will discuss compact uniformly recurrent subgroups and compact invariant random subgroups in locally compact groups, and present results from ongoing projects with Pierre-Emanuel Caprace and Waltraud Lederle, and with Tal Cohen.
Isaac Goldbring (UCI)
Title: II$_1$ factors with the Brown property are generic
Abstract: A separable II$_1$ factor $M$ is said to have the Brown property if for any separable subalgebra $N$ of the ultrapower $M^U$, there is a separable subalgebra $P$ of $M^U$ containing $N$ such that the relative commutant $P’\cap M^U$ is a factor. We show that the Brown property is generic for II$_1$ factors in the sense that every so-called infinitely generic II$_1$ factor has the Brown property. This is achieved by relating the Brown property to a uniform version of the super McDuff property (which states that the relative commutant of the II$_1$ factor in its own commutant is a factor) combined with the recent result by Chifan, Drimbe, and Ioana that II$_1$ factors with property (T) are embedding universal. In particular, infinitely generic factors are uniformly super McDuff, generalizing another recent result of Chifan, Drimbe, and Ioana. Time permitting, we will discuss the question of whether or not so-called finitely generic II$_1$ factors have the Brown property and why this problem is more difficult than the infinitely generic case. This is joint work with David Jekel, Srivatsav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli, and Jennifer Pi.
Ben Hayes (University of Virginia)
Title: Co-spectral radius, equivalence relations and the growth of unimodular random rooted trees
Abstract: I will speak on joint work with Mikolas Abert and Mikolaj Fraczyk. In it, we define the co-spectral radius of inclusions of discrete, probability measure-preserving orbit equivalence relations, using the sampling exponent of a generating random walk on the ambient relation. The co-spectral radius is analogous to the spectral radius for random walks on G/H for inclusion of groups G,H. Unlike the group case the almost sure existence of this pointwise limit is nontrivial to establish, and we provide a novel general method for proving almost sure existence of such limits based on the mass-transport principle. Time permitting, I will mention some analogies and connections with operator algebras and subfactor theory, as well as some applications.
Jingyin Huang (Ohio State University)
Title: Measure equivalence superrigidity for some generalized Higman groups
Abstract: In the 1950s, Higman introduced the first class of examples of infinite finitely presented groups without any non-trivial finite quotient. We study Higman groups from the viewpoint of measure equivalence - a notion introduced by Gromov as a measurable counterpart to quasi-isometry. For most Higman groups and some generalizations, we prove a strong measure equivalence rigidity theorem, and obtain W*-superrigidity results for all free, ergodic, probability measure-preserving actions of these groups. Moreover, our main result is a consequence of a more general theorem on measure equivalence invariants of certain classes of groups acting acylindrically on CAT(-1) spaces. In this talk, I'll sketch the proof, and possibly compare to some other measure equivalence rigidity/flexibility results in the literature if time allows. This is joint work with Camille Horbez.
Mehrdad Kalantar (University of Houston)
Title: A conjecture on type I locally compact groups
Abstract: The notion of type I, hailing from the very origins of operator algebras and representation theory, can be seen as a rigorous way to define the class of groups for which unitary representations can be classified in any meaningful manner. By a celebrated result of Thoma, a discrete group is type I if and only if it is virtually abelian. In the non-discrete case, the current state of the art is not nearly as complete, despite numerous results ensuring that various important families of groups (e.g. every connected semisimple Lie group) are type I. What is completely lacking, in contrast to Thoma’s theorem, is a definite structural consequence of type I. This talk is around the following conjecture: Every second countable locally compact group of type I admits a cocompact amenable subgroup. We motivate the conjecture, provide some supporting evidence for it, and prove it for type I hyperbolic locally compact groups admitting a cocompact lattice.
This is joint work with Pierre-Emmanuel Caprace and Nicolas Monod.
Srivatsav Kunnawalkam Elayavalli (IPAM, UCLA)
Title: Small at infinity compactification of a von Neumann algebra.
Abstract: In this talk I will describe a generalized notion of a small at infinity compactification a la Ozawa of a finite von Neumann algebra introudced by the speaker, Ding and Peterson. The key technical novelty here was to bypass a well known obstruction, involving the absence of interesting derivations from B (L^2 M) into the compact operators, by considering the closure of the compacts in a topology of Magajna from the theory of strong operator bimodules. By effectively working in this topological framework we clarify old problems of Anantharaman-Delaroche involving various viewpoints of the Haagerup property for II_1 factors, and also the notion of mixingness for bimodules. This work additionally allows for several kinds of rigidity results via a generalized notion of proper proximality (a la Boutonnet-Ioana-Peterson) for von Neumann algebras. Some of the applications I will talk about from this work include: absense of weakly compact cartan subalgebars for a wide class of II_1 factors; a structure result for subfactors of L (G) where G is non amenable bi-exact, settling a problem of Popa for the case of F_2 and solid ergodicity for various Gaussian actions, extending works of Boutonnet and Chifan-Ioana. By developing an abstract upgrading result for the notion of relative proper proximality, the speaker and Ding also recently obtained a new application of this framework, involving the structure of free products. I will discuss these results and touch on some key new ideas.
David Jekel (UCSD)
Title: Free entropy theory, model theory, and embeddings into matrix ultraproducts
Abstract: We define a new variant of free entropy using ideas from continuous model theory, and use it to study embeddings into matrix ultraproducts; in particular, we show that every non-strongly-1-bounded tracial von Neumann algebra admits an embedding into a matrix ultraproduct with trivial relative commutant. Voiculescu's free entropy and Jung and Hayes' 1-bounded entropy are measurements of the amount of matrix approximations of the generators X_1, ..., X_n of a tracial von Neumann algebra M, where 'matrix approximations' is interpreted as the matrix tuples with approximately the same non-commutative moments. We define analogous versions of entropy where the 'matrix approximation' is understood in terms of the model-theoretic type, meaning that instead of polynomials our test functions are formulas involving suprema and infima over auxiliary variables. The model-theoretic 1-bounded entropy has many natural properties in how it relates to the original 1-bounded entropy, change of coordinates, definable closures, and more.
Jesse Peterson (Vanderbilt University)
Title: Biexact von Neumann algebras (part I)
Abstract: The notion of biexactness for groups was introduced by Ozawa in 2004 and has since become a major tool used for studying indecomposability properties of von Neumann algebras. We will introduce the notion of a biexact von Neumann algebra, which allows us to place many previous indecomposability results in a more systematic context, and naturally leads to extensions of these results. We will give explicit connections between biexactness, malleable deformations, and closable derivations, allowing us to unify three separate approaches to solidity that were developed initially 15-20 years ago. The techniques also give a new characterization of weakly exact von Neumann algebras, answering a problem of Brown and Ozawa.
Sorin Popa (UCLA)
Title: In search of maximal amenable subalgebras of $L\mathbb F_n$ that are not freely complemented.
Abstract: Starting in early '80s, a series of absorption and in-decomposability phenomena in $L\mathbb F_n$, and more generally in (amalgamated) free product II$_1$ factors $M=M_1*_B M_2$, unravelled over the years. But a key question along these lines keeps lingering: do there exist maximal amenable subalgebras of $L\mathbb F_n$ that are not freely complemented? I will comment on this problem and also present a result with Remi Boutonnet, where we exhibit a large family of distinct maximal amenable MASAs in $L\mathbb F_n$, which seem to be good candidates for such examples.
Dimitri Shlyakhtenko (UCLA)
Bin Sun (Oxford University)
Title: Rigidity examples constructed with wreath-like
product groups
Abstract: Wreath-like product groups were introduced recently and used to construct the first positive examples of rigidity conjectures of Connes and Jones. In this talk, I will review those examples, as well as discuss some ideas to construct examples with other rigidity phenomena by modifying the wreath-like product construction.
Hui Tan (UCSD)
Title: Spectral gap characterizations of property (T) for II_1 factors
Abstract: I will discuss characterizations of property (T) for II_1 factors by weak spectral gap in extensions, and by the non-weakly-mixing property of the bimodules containing almost central vectors. I will explain how these are related and compare them to the corresponding characterizations of property (T) for groups.
Robin Tucker-Drob (University of Florida).
Title: Measure Equivalence, Schlichting Completions, and Baumslag-Solitar groups
Abstract: A subgroup H of a group Γ is commensurated by Γ if all H-orbits in Γ/H are finite. In this situation, the closure of Γ in the group of all permutations of Γ/H is a totally disconnected locally compact group called the Schlichting completion of the pair (Γ, H) and we denote it G(Γ, H). We show that if H and K are amenable commensurated subgroups of Γ and Λ respectively such that the associated Schlichting completions G(Γ, H) and G(Λ, K) are both hyperbolic with trivial amenable radical, then every measure equivalence coupling of Γ with Λ descends canonically to a measure equivalence coupling of the (possibly nonunimodular) groups G(Γ, H) and G(Λ, K). This unifies and generalizes theorems of Houdayer--Raum, Kida, and Monod--Shalom. I will discuss the consequences of this for the open problem of classifying Baumslag-Solitar groups up to measure equivalence.
Open Problems
The following is a list of open problems discussed during the problem session. Thanks for Greg Patchell for compiling the list.
Dining options on UCSD campus
Price Center is a few minutes away from the AP&M building. For a list of places to eat at in Price Center, including their weeekend hours, see here. This website also lists a few other dining options close to the AP&M building, under the heading Dining@Student Center.
Registration form and financial support
Registration is now closed.
Financial support for junior participants is available through the NSF grants FRG-DMS-1854074 and FRG-DMS-1853989.
Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.
For questions, please contact Adrian Ioana.
Reimbursement policy and instructions
Financial support for junior participants is available through the NSF grants FRG-DMS-1854074 (administered through UCSD) and FRG-DMS-1853989 (admninistered through Vanderbilt University). Participants who will be awarded financial support will be contacted with reimbursement instructions and policies, depending on the institution which will disburse the reimbursement.
As federal funds will be used, all flight itineraries must comply with the Fly America Act. All airfare must be booked on U.S. flag carriers and on coach/economy class.
Accomodations
Participants are expected to make their own hotel arrangements. Graduate students are encouraged to share a room. Some hotels to consider are:
1 Best Western Premier Hotel Del Mar (Del Mar Inn), located in Del Mar, close to the beach, about 5.4 miles north on campus. To get to campus, one can use the 101 bus route. To make a reservation, call the hotel ( (858) 755-9765 ), ask for the UCSD discount, and say that you are here for a conference at UCSD.
2 Sheraton La Jolla Hotel, next to the UCSD campus, 1.2 miles south of the AP&M building. To make a reservation, go to: www.sheratonlajolla.com
· Put in desired stay dates
· Go to special rate drop down arrow
· Go to Corporate/Promo code and type in: UC0 (zero, not ‘O’)
If the discounted rate is available, it will populate. If it’s not available, then the best available rate at that time will populate.
3 Residence Inn by Mariott, next to the UCSD campus, 0.9 miles south of the AP&M building.
Code-of-conduct
We are required by the NSF to provide the workshop participants with a code-of-conduct that addresses sexual harassment, other forms of harassment, and sexual assault, and that includes directions of how to report violations of the code-of-conduct.
The University of California is committed to maintaining a community dedicated to the advancement, application and transmission of knowledge and creative endeavors through academic excellence, where all people who participate in University programs and activities can work and learn together in an atmosphere free of harassment, exploitation, or intimidation. The University of California policies prohibiting harassment and discrimination on the basis of protected categories include the University of California Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Affirmative Action in the Workplace and the UC San Diego Student Conduct Procedures.
The University of California Sexual Violence and Sexual Harassment Policy addresses sexual violence, sexual harassment, retaliation, and other behavior prohibited conduct. The University will respond promptly and effectively to reports of such conduct. This includes action to stop, prevent, correct, and when necessary, discipline, behavior that violates this Policy. This Policy addresses the University’s responsibilities and procedures related to sexual violence, sexual harassment, retaliation, and other prohibited behavior as those terms are defined in this Policy (together, “Prohibited Conduct”) in order to ensure an equitable and inclusive education and employment environment. The Policy defines Prohibited Conduct and explains the administrative procedures the University uses to resolve reports of Prohibited Conduct.
The following resources on UC San Diego campus are avaiable to individuals impacted by discrimination and harassment:
CARE at the Sexual Assault Resource Center is an independent confidential campus resource for individuals impacted by sexual assault, relationship violence, and stalking. CARE at SARC is on-call 24 hours a day and on weekends throughout the year. For urgent support during non-business hours, weekends, or holidays, CARE at SARC can be reached at (858) 534-5793.
The Office for the Prevention of Harassment and Discrimination (OPHD) is the Title IX Office at UC San Diego. OPHS is responsible for assessing and investigating reports of discrimination or harassment based on race, ancestry, national origin, disability, religion, age, and other categories protected by law and University policy brought against academic personnel. OPHD can be contacted by emailing ophd@ucsd.edu or by leaving a voicemail 858-534-8298.
Reports to law enforcement can be made to UC San Diego's police department for on-campus incidents or to the local department where the crime occurred. To report a sexual assault, for the quickest response, call 911 to be connected to the nearest police department.To report anonymously and confidentially to the UC San Diego Police, call (858) 534-4357.
List of the links referenced above:
University of California Policy on Discrimination, Harassment, and Affirmative Action in the Workplace: https://policy.ucop.edu/doc/4000376/DiscHarassAffirmAction
UC San Diego Student Conduct Procedures: https://studentconduct.ucsd.edu/_files/policies-process/student-conduct-procedures-9-15-21.pdf
University of California Sexual Violence and Sexual Harassment Policy: https://policy.ucop.edu/doc/4000385/SVSH
CARE at the Sexual Assault Resource Center: https://care.ucsd.edu
The Office for the Prevention of Harassment and Discrimination (OPHD): https://ophd.ucsd.edu