(George,2015)
(Lee,2018)
When some people think of the North East region, they may see it as more "liberal" or more democratic than a majority of the other states within the U.S. While this may be true when it comes to presidential elections and policies having to do with Marijuana, there is still an underlying racial bias and inequity within our schooling that has negatively affected generations of black, brown, and indigenous students. In order to better understand how race has an unacknowledged impact on a student's academic career and ability to reach their potential, we have look at three major components of the schooling system; Redlining, Disciplinary Policies, and Nonrepresentational Environments.
Redlining: The Not so Subtle New Wave Segregation
Redlining can be defined by the Fair Housing Act (1968) as the illegal practice of denying an applicant a loan for housing due to the area in which they reside. Major cities such as Boston, New York City, New Jersey, Baltimore, and Philadelphia can be seen to have areas within their cities that are smaller red sections either in the center of their city or on the outside parameter. These red sections were outlined as a warning to loan lenders that people of color resided there, and that giving out loans within this area would be a poor financial decision on the banker's behalf (Perry & Harshbarger, 2019). Redlining doesn't only affect the ability to take out a loan as a person of color, it also hinders the ability for schooling, investments within the community, and resources for schools within these red districts. Gene Demby of NPR narrates a short video (seen to the right) about the ways redlining has affected BIPOC communities living in these areas in nearly every facet of their lives. To summarize redlining in schools, Demby states:
The primary way that people fund public schools is by paying property taxes. People that live in more valuable homes have better funded local schools, better paid teachers, better school facilities, and more resources (NPR,2018).
In order for red districts to have a flourishing school system, they need to be able to build property values within their area. When investors and bankers are warned to not invest in these areas, it is nearly impossible for this to be accomplished. So if this act is illegal, then why is it still happening? Michel Martin of NPR spoke in an interview with the former Vice President Walter Mondale, and also the co-writer of the 1968 Fair Housing Act Bill. In this interview, Mondale is questioned on why he believes that the FHA seems to be so rarely enforced within our nation. For his answer, he gives this statement:
It's been a sad fact of American life that the practice in many communities has been quite the opposite. That's why we passed the bill - to make a change. There's a lot of bad consequences that flow from segregation. The kids don't do as well. We live separately. We don't learn about each other. We're all Americans. And yet, we separate based on, basically, race. And I believe it's got to stop (NPR, 2018).
Redlining needs to be tackled head-on to diminish the racial barrier that has been affecting students of color for generations. When resources are poured into a community that has constantly been discriminated against and treated unfairly, they will have the chance to fund their schools, as well as have access to fair schooling, safer housing, and more community resources.
(NPR,2018)
(Steinhardt,2015)
(Jung,2018)
(Parker-Smith,2020)
Attending school from ages 5-18, it is not surprising for students to have predominantly white teachers. This ties into the history of desegregation within schools during the Civil Rights Era in America. The integration of BIPOC students into all white schools caused a widespread shut down of schools that were filled with highly experienced teachers of color. Most of these teachers were forced to retire or find a job of lesser status due to the lingering racism when it came to hiring black educators at white schools (Parker-Smith,2020). This has caused a disproportionate white to non-white teacher ratio within our schooling systems. When there are a majority of white teachers teaching students of all ethnic backgrounds, it is harder for these teachers to create a relationship with these students and vice versa. In a short YouTube video titled "The History of Racism in Education" by Ms. Parker-Smith (2020), she dives into the complications of Black students being less likely to succeed when they are surrounded by white teachers rather than Black teachers. She reiterates a study from John Hopkins University by stating:
If a black male student is exposed to one black teacher in elementary school, it decreases the risk of dropping out by 39%, and on the flip side, black students are three times less likely to be assigned to gifted and talented reading courses when those students are assigned to non-black teachers (Parker-Smith, 2020).
Schools that are filled with majority white teachers are also filled with predominantly white school boards. School boards have the responsibility of developing the curriculum, policies, budgeting, and most important of all, making sure that all students are getting the education and support that they need (PCNSC, 2021). Laura Mae Lindo, a member of the Provincial Parliament for Kitchener Centre spoke at a conference in which she talked about how racism in schools and a disconnect with students of color is something that can't just be "hugged out." She dives into the experiences of Black students as well as the "band-aid like" policies that aid white students into feeling like racism isn't present anymore, rather than asking what students of color need to feel safer and heard in school. A big part of that is hiring more teachers of color and board members of color. She states in her talk that,
If we [BIPOC] are not at the decision making tables, nobody even believes that the problem is urgent. When there's no sense of belonging, and no sense of urgency to address racism, cycles of racial injustice continues in schools" (Laura Mae Lindo,2020).
When students are not put into a school environment where they feel welcome, they are less likely to want to be involved. Schooling is an extremely important aspect in the way that it shapes somebody's life. Schooling can determine your social group, extra curricular activities, determination and drive to succeed, along with your future as an adult. When we look at the problem to erase racial bias in schools, there needs to be a change in policies. Also, academic institutions need to make sure students of color feel like they're a part of the curriculum being taught and establish policies that include more faculty members of color.
School policies in America have normalized the belief that having police, metal detectors, drug searches, and harsh disciplinary action is what is necessary to keep kids under control in schools. However, what happens when these policies that have been put in place are dis proportionally aimed at black and brown students? This is where racial bias comes into play within our school systems.
According to Jayanti Owens and Sarah McLanahan in the published work titled, "Unpacking the Drivers of Racial Disparities in School Suspension and Expulsion," the use of expulsion and suspension of students has increased by nearly 50% over the last 40 years (2019). These expulsions have been primarily targeted at students of color. While there are white students that experience these disciplinary actions, "Black students are 3.2 times more likely to be suspended or expelled, Native American students are 2.0 times more likely, and Hispanic/Latinx students are 1.3 times more likely" (Owens-McLanahan, 2019). Their studies conclude that often these students are more targetable based on their performance in school. Poor performance in school is linked to the differential treatment of a non-representative teacher workforce as discussed above. The more interaction that people of color have with schools' "zero tolerance policies" the more likely they are to serve jail time within their future. This is known as the School-To-Prison Pipeline. One example of the school-to-prison pipeline in the Mid-Atlantic would be in New York City High Schools. The Rockaway Youth Task Force (2014) states:
Black students in New York City served 53 percent of suspensions over the last 10 years although they only make up 33 percent of the student body. Black students also served longer suspensions and were more likely to be suspended for subjective misconduct, such as profanity and insubordination (RYTF,2014).
The majority white teacher-body, suspending and/or expelling students of color for minor misconduct has caused racial divide for generations. Students of color do not feel safe in schooling systems and feel as if they cannot trust people in school environments. "This system almost directly mirrors the prison system, where black civilians are convicted for things that their white peers often aren’t and are given longer sentences for the same crimes"(RYTF, 2014). It is crucial for schools to implement systems where BIPOC students feel safe while simultaneously eliminating the systems that threaten these student's future.
(The Root, 2017)
In order to halt the school-to-prison pipeline, schools need to:
Be held accountable for their unfair treatment of black, brown, and indigenous students.
Abolish zero tolerance policies that punish students for minor offenses.
Abolish policing in school systems.
Develop policies/programs that resolve a students misbehavior, while keeping them in a learning environment.