(Zerflin, 2021)
This image showcases how segregation officially "ended" in the 1950s. However, there are still examples of modern de-facto segregation tactics seen in our current school systems that continue to contribute to education inequity. BIPOC and white students are still separated in various ways in our academic institutions.
In order to understand how to efficiently end racial inequity, it is necessary to recognize the origin of such disparities. By delving into the uncomfortable aspects that surround America's history in regard to race, such as the harmful imbalances that stemmed from slavery and segregation, it will allow both current and future generations the knowledge to comprehend what truly needs to be done to eradicate this pressing issue.
Racial inequity continues to exist on multiple levels in the lives of the American people, as seen in the various institutions in the United States. In education, specifically, the disparities between white and BIPOC students developed from the deep roots of racism and segregation that arose during the Jim Crow Era in 1877. However, even before the creation of the Jim Crow laws that solidified the inequities between Black and white students, there were already policies and laws set in place to restrict and even criminalize the access to education for Black individuals (Lynch, 2019). Due to the extreme impact of slavery 400 years ago and how it continues to uplifts the privileges of white individuals, denying the literacy of Black Americans continued to reinforce the discriminatory racial hierarchy that proceeds to impact students of color to this day.
(Patterson, 2020)
How the "separate but equal" doctrine from the Jim Crow Era became one of the main contributors to racial inequity that continues to impact BIPOC communities now. This harmful institutional mindset continued to set BIPOC communities back, while simultaneously elevating white individuals.
The laws set in place during the Jim Crow Era enforced the implementation of the “separate by equal” doctrine which was meant to create a form of “social peace” and equality between those of different races. Moreover, academic institutions that once denied the enrollment of BIPOC students began to implement this philosophy and through the Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) case, allowed Black students to attend school. While Black students were able to obtain literacy, there is evidence that showcased how academic institutions for BIPOC students were extremely underfunded and lacking in the quality of its educators, education, and more (Noltemeyer et al., 2012). In these schools, Black educators had to use their own personal funds to increase the quality of Black schools. At the same time, parents and others in the community had to pay an extra tax, “the Black tax”, to support these underfunded schools. Meanwhile, white schools were funded efficiently, their educators were paid more, and their students were properly catered to, which can be seen in their high levels in various academic subjects (Ramsey, 2021). As a result of segregated academic institutions, an unfair system that catered to students of color being disenfranchised of a higher equality education was established.
Along with Black students, in the 1800s-20th century:
Native American children were sent to boarding schools that forced them to distance themselves from their culture and language to assimilate properly with white individuals.
In California: Chinese American students were also denied their right to education due to their ancestry.
Latin American students were excluded from obtaining educational opportunities, similar to white students.
(Noltemeyer et al., 2012)
(Encyclopædia Britannica, 2021)
(Wade, 2009)
(Delmont, 2016)
It wasn’t until cases such as Tape v. Hurley (1884), Roberto Alvarez v. The Lemon Grove School Board (1931), along with cases such Brown v. Board of Education (1954), that began to desegregate and create more opportunities for students of color to gain access to education and generate potential. However, despite the victory that came from these cases, nowadays students of color are disproportionately still at a disadvantage in their academics (Noltemeyer et al., 2012).
In the 1950s, with the work that had been created by the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, NAACP, and the case Brown v. Board of Education (1954) it forced the Supreme Court to rule against the philosophy of “separate but equal” and desegregate schools (Ramsey, 2021). This case overrode the white supremacist mindset and created an extreme tension between the white and Black communities in America, especially in the South. Students of color were met with extreme racial inequity, white vigilante violence, and more with little to no help from their white educators and academic administrators. Since this case, other states followed suit to also implement desegregation in schools. For instance, in Massachusetts, the Racial Imbalance Act (1965) was implemented to desegregate Boston Public Schools (UMASS Boston History Department Archives, 2015).
Northeastern States Example:
→In Massachusetts:
Boston (MA) Desegregation Busing Crisis (1974-1988): City of Boston's efforts to desegregate public schools by integrating Black students into predominantly white schools. However, this effort to integrate schools was met with extreme backlash. As seen with Boston's white Irish-American population, there was an influx of "white flight" to the suburbs as many white children were bused to suburban schools that had more resources and could provide a higher quality of educators (Delmont, 2016). Additionally, another form of backlash was the increase in protests to reinstitute segregation in schools, along with several incidents of white vigilante violence, prejudice, and racism against BIPOC individuals (Delmont, 2016).
(CBS Boston, 2018)
This video demonstrates one of the many protests seen against the Boston Public School desegregation implemented policy seen in 1974.
"... We conclude that, in the field of public education, the doctrine of "separate but equal" has no place. Separate educational facilities are inherently unequal." -Chief Justice Earl Warren after the Supreme Court ruled in favor of ending academic segregation in Brown v. Board of Education
(Remnick, 2021)
(El-Mekki, 2018)
From then on, even despite BIPOC and white students attending the same schools, BIPOC students were seen as inferior in all aspects due to the white superiority complex that drives the actions of discrimination and implicit bias from white educators/administrators. Moreover, there are still various practices that are seen that continue to perpetuate the racist tendencies seen throughout American history. These practices, more specifically an academic institution’s discipline, and punishment standards, along with governmental policies that surround academics, such as standardized test scores are examples of the impact of the racial inequity from both slavery and the Jim Crow Era in the 1800s that put students of color at an extreme disadvantage.
This history matters because there are multiple examples of students of color being treated differently due to institutional racism in education. Such treatment leads to an increase in the dropout rates for BIPOC students, disinterest in education, and trauma that stemmed from high to low-level white supremacist mindsets that hinder their positive progression in maintaining a healthy relationship with both their peers and teachers. To understand the reasoning for why there is a continued issue of racial disparity in BIPOC students being at a disadvantage both academically and socially, one must look into the roots of racism and segregation that plagued this country. An academic institution should be one that promoted the success of their students, not intentionally (or intentionally), set certain demographics of students back, while also subjecting them to racially unjust treatment, especially in regards to discipline and punishment or other aspects seen in American education.
"There is no such thing as separate but equal. Separation, segregation, inevitably makes for inequality." -Martin Luther King Jr.