Judge
Learn and teach how to determine the accuracy of information from any source
Learn and teach how to determine the accuracy of information from any source
Librarians and information professionals can help parents and students alike evaluate information we take in from the world. That might mean evaluating or contextualizing sources of news, weighing what we know about an information source to determine its overall reliability, or identifying where information might be missing or inaccurate. Librarians strive to provide students and parents with the tools and critical thinking skills necessary to become savvy consumers of information.
Stop by the front desk at your local public library.
Email your public library.
Call the library branch.
Visit your library's website.
Visit the 24/7 Chat.
Scroll through the FAQ's for answers.
Make an appointment with a librarian at your public library.
Do the same with the professional teacher librarian at your child's school library.
The American Library Association (ALA) has reaffirmed librarians' professional commitment to "actively seek and and provide sources of accurate information that counter disinformation." Librarians and other library workers are dedicated to teaching information literacy skills that allow patrons to evaluate the accuracy of sources.
Evaluating information is important in everyday life. Some of the benefits of evaluating sources of information include more accuracy and effectiveness when:
Misinformation and disinformation are rampant on social media, spread by state and non-state actors with malicious intent as well as by unwitting users. These individuals and entities abuse social media to promote information that serves their political/financial interests. Given the proliferation of social media and online information in general, this can have profound social consequences. According to an October 27, 2022 Pew Research poll, adults under 30 are now almost as likely (50%) to trust information from social media sites as they are to trust information from national news outlets (56%). Social media information can be harder to verify than information found in newspapers or television reports, given the unknown or unclear original source. In the United States, trust in news media has become ever more sharply polarized along partisan lines in recent years. For these reasons and more, the ability to discern reliable sources and information from untrustworthy ones has become more important than ever.
How can we know what sources of information we can trust on social media? The nonprofit First Draft offers “Five Pillars of Verification” for verifying online information:
1. PROVENANCE: Are you looking at the original account, article, or piece of content?
2. SOURCE: Who created the account or article, or captured the original piece of content?
3. DATE: When was it created?
4. LOCATION: Where was the account established, the website created, or piece of content captured?
5. MOTIVATION: Why was the account established, the website created, or the piece of content captured?
The Informed Learner & The STIC Model by Dr. David Loertscher Create by Design
For many years, many librarians taught the CRAAP test, but that was in an earlier and more simple information environment. Now as the types of information have proliferated and the channels have multiplied, Loertscher created the STIC Model as another way to help teens. The simple idea is: When confronted with a piece of information that I need to evaluate, should I allow this information to stick in my brain, or, should I just flush it. Below are the actual pages from the book that you are welcome to use with your teens in an interesting exchange. In addition, a helpful website is at: https://sites.google.com/view/theinformedlearner/home