How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper — biggest strength: a purpose-built 8qt fryer accessory with a handle and rubber bumper, so you can pull a hot tray without burning your fingers or scratching the coating.
• TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper — biggest trade-off: it is one single 10-inch iron plate built around 8qt fryers, so it does nothing for your oven and gives you no size options.
• Zihvfzu 3 — biggest strength: three different pan diameters (9, 11 and 12 inch) in one set, all rated to 450°F and all dishwasher friendly, which covers personal, family and party bakes.
• Zihvfzu 3 — biggest trade-off: it is oven bakeware, not an air fryer insert, so if your goal is crispier wings inside an 8qt basket, this set is not the tool.
• Who TOPINCN is for: air fryer owners who want better airflow and easier food removal inside the basket.
• Who Zihvfzu 3 is for: home bakers and oven cooks who make pizza, bread, pastries and roasted vegetables at several different sizes.
The TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper is a single replacement tray, about 25.5 x 25 cm (roughly 10 x 9.8 inches), designed as a universal accessory for an 8qt fryer. It's made of iron with a double-layer sprayed nonstick coating and a perforated surface. That perforation is the whole point: TOPINCN describes it as a whirlwind airflow design meant to keep hot air circulating around the food instead of letting it sit in one spot, which is exactly the problem a solid tray creates.
What it does best is the practical stuff. There's a handle, so you lift the plate out of a hot basket without tongs and without burning yourself — a small detail that matters every single time you cook. The rubber bumper is heat resistant and sits against the basket to hold the plate steady while protecting the nonstick coating from scratches. Cleanup is dishwasher-friendly, and the coating is nonstick, so food releases rather than cementing itself to the surface. TOPINCN lists barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, French fries, pizza and chicken wings as fair game, which tells you it's meant to be a daily driver rather than a one-trick accessory.
Who should buy it: anyone with an 8qt air fryer who is tired of food steaming on a flat surface, and anyone who wants a tray they can grab by the handle and drop straight into the dishwasher. Who should skip it: people with fryers in other capacities, since this is sized specifically around 8qt, and anyone hoping to bake full-size pizza in a regular oven — this is an in-basket accessory, not oven bakeware. One care note worth repeating: don't scrub the coating with an abrasive pad or metal tool, because that's what kills nonstick surfaces early.
Zihvfzu 3 is a completely different product category wearing similar language. It's a three-pack of round perforated pizza pans in 9, 11 and 12 inches, made from thickened carbon steel with a food-grade nonstick coating. The steel is rated for high-temperature resistance up to 450°F, and Zihvfzu specifically calls out that it resists warping, scratching and rusting — the three failure modes that make cheap bakeware frustrating within a few months.
The perforations here serve the same physics as the TOPINCN plate, just for a different job: dense holes let air move under the crust and let excess moisture escape, which is what separates a crisp bottom from a soggy one. If you've ever pulled a pizza out of the oven and watched the center go limp, that's trapped steam, and a perforated pan is the standard fix.
The real story, though, is the size spread. A 9-inch pan handles a single personal pizza or a small batch of cookies. The 11-inch pan is the everyday family size. The 12-inch pan is the one you reach for when people are coming over. All three are described as fitting standard home and commercial ovens, and all three handle hand washing or the dishwasher. Beyond pizza, Zihvfzu positions them for cookies, cakes, bread, pastries, roasted vegetables and bacon — so it's a general baking set, not a single-purpose gadget.
Who should buy it: anyone who bakes in a conventional oven and wants consistent, crisp results at more than one size without buying pans one at a time. Who should skip it: air fryer owners who need an insert for their basket — these round pans are meant for an oven, and a 12-inch round pan won't do anything useful in an 8qt fryer basket.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for 8qt air fryer owners → TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper. It's sized for that basket, and nothing about the Zihvfzu set is.
• Best for oven pizza and baking → Zihvfzu 3. Three round perforated pans in 9, 11 and 12 inches, rated to 450°F.
• Best for cooking for a crowd → Zihvfzu 3. The 12-inch pan is the party size; a single 10-inch plate can't match that surface area.
• Best for protecting your coating → TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper. The rubber bumper is there specifically to keep the basket and plate from scratching each other.
• Best for versatility across dishes → Zihvfzu 3. Pizza, cookies, cakes, bread, pastries, vegetables and bacon from one set.
• Best for a single, simple upgrade → TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper. One plate, one job, done well.
• Best for someone setting up a kitchen from scratch → Zihvfzu 3. Three sizes covers more ground than one accessory ever will.
In my opinion, most people reading this should buy the Zihvfzu 3. Three usable sizes, a 450°F ceiling, dishwasher-safe cleanup and a material spec that promises to resist warping and rusting is a lot of everyday value, and it works in the oven you already own. I'd only steer you to the TOPINCN Air Fryer Crisper if an 8qt air fryer is your main cooking appliance — in that case the handle, the bumper and the airflow-focused perforation make it the more useful tool for the basket you actually use. Buy for the appliance you cook in most, not for the one you wish you had.
If you own an 8qt fryer, yes in my opinion. The perforated airflow design, the grab handle and the rubber bumper are the three things a generic flat tray usually lacks. Check the current price on Amazon to see whether that upgrade fits your budget.
Does the Zihvfzu 3 work in an air fryer?
No, not as intended. These are round oven pans in 9, 11 and 12 inches built for standard ovens, with a 450°F rating. For an air fryer basket, the TOPINCN plate is the correct shape and size.
Both are dishwasher safe and both use nonstick coatings, so it's close. The TOPINCN plate is one item; the Zihvfzu set is three pans, which means more surface to wash when you use all three. Neither coating should be attacked with abrasive pads.
Yes. On the TOPINCN plate they're there to circulate hot air around food in the basket; on the Zihvfzu pans they let moisture escape so pizza crusts crisp instead of steaming. Same idea, two different cooking environments.
TOPINCN uses iron with a double-layer sprayed coating; Zihvfzu uses thickened carbon steel with a food-grade nonstick coating. Carbon steel is the more common choice for oven bakeware and is rated to 450°F here, while the iron plate is built specifically as a fryer insert.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: TOPINCN 2 vs HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill, AODPWEN 2 vs Onader Air Fryer Basket, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs AKS Magnets Air Fryer Cheat