How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
These two products share a category — air fryer accessories — but they solve completely different problems. One is a flat silicone mat you cook on. The other is a raised metal rack you cook over. Reading the spec sheets side by side makes that split obvious, and it should drive your decision more than anything else.
• TOPINCN 2's biggest strength: food-grade silicone, non-stick, heat resistant and dishwasher-safe, sold as a 2-pack in a rectangular 8.7" x 8.1" size built specifically for the Foodi AG301.
• TOPINCN 2's biggest trade-off: it is a liner, not a rack — it sits flat in the basket, so it does not lift food for airflow underneath, and the sizing is tied to one model family.
• HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill's biggest strength: an iron rack with a non-stick coating that raises food roughly 2.87 inches off the surface for even heating, in a roomier 12.2" x 10.24" footprint.
• HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill's biggest trade-off: it is a single metal rack, so it does not shield your basket from grease and crumbs the way a liner does, and it needs hand care rather than a dishwasher cycle.
• Who TOPINCN 2 is for: owners of a Foodi AG301 who are tired of scrubbing the basket and want a cheap, low-effort barrier.
• Who HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill is for: anyone who wants a grilling surface — drumsticks, steaks, veg, seafood — and cares more about browning and airflow than about basket protection.
TOPINCN 2 is a two-pack of reusable silicone liners, each measuring 8.7 inches by 8.1 inches, cut rectangular to fit the Foodi AG301 air cooker. The pitch is simple: drop the mat in, cook your chicken drumsticks, wings or steaks on top of it, then rinse, wipe or run it through the dishwasher. Nothing sticks to the mat, and nothing sticks to your basket either, because the liner is doing the dirty work.
Who should buy it? If you own a Foodi AG301 and your routine is mostly quick proteins and reheats — wings, drumsticks, a steak, leftovers — this is the lowest-friction upgrade you can make. You get two mats, so one can be in the wash while the other is in use, which matters more than it sounds when you cook most days. You also get physical protection: the liner keeps the interior of the fryer from getting scratched by tongs and metal utensils, which is a real long-term wear issue on coated baskets.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants their food elevated. A flat liner does not create airflow underneath, so the underside of a chicken thigh will not get the same browning as the top. If you want crispness on all sides, you want a rack, not a mat. Also skip it if you do not own an AG301 or a similarly sized rectangular basket — the 8.7" x 8.1" footprint is sized for that machine, and in a much larger or rounder basket it will just slide around and cover less than you need.
HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill: Who It's For
HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill is a single metal roasting rack made from iron, measuring 12.2 inches by 10.24 inches and standing 2.87 inches tall. That height is the entire design argument. By lifting food off the basket floor, the rack lets hot air circulate underneath, which is how you get a grilled texture rather than a steamed one.
The rack carries a non-stick coating, and the manufacturer's framing is that this coating contributes to even heating and more uniformly cooked, flavorful results. That is a sensible claim for a raised rack: the coating stops food from welding itself to the bars, and the elevation stops the bottom of the food from sitting in its own juices. Together, those two things do most of the work in turning an air fryer into something closer to a small grill.
Versatility is the second selling point, and it is backed up by the spec rather than just marketing language. The listed use cases include steaks, chicken, vegetables, seafood, and the wider applications mention family gatherings, outdoor barbecues and camping — which tells you the rack is not locked to one appliance. A 12.2" x 10.24" rack is a plausible fit for a full-size air fryer basket, a roasting pan, or a grill topper setup outdoors. Iron construction is what makes that portability realistic; the rack weighs 11.5 ounces, light enough to move around but solid enough to feel like a tool rather than a disposable insert.
Who should buy it? People who want drumsticks with rendered, crispy skin. People who grill steaks indoors and want the underside to actually brown. People who cook vegetables and seafood and want them to drain instead of steam. And people who like the idea of one accessory that works in the air fryer, in the oven and on the grill outside.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for basket protection and easy cleanup → TOPINCN 2. Silicone liner, non-stick, dishwasher-safe, two in the pack.
• Best for grilling texture and airflow → HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill. A 2.87-inch raised iron rack lets heat move under the food.
• Best for a specific machine fit → TOPINCN 2. Sized at 8.7" x 8.1" for the Foodi AG301.
• Best for a bigger basket or mixed use → HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill. A 12.2" x 10.24" footprint also suits roasting pans, ovens and outdoor grills.
• Best for chicken drumsticks and wings → HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill. Elevation is what crisps skin on all sides.
• Best for reheating and quick everyday cooks → TOPINCN 2. A flat mat is all you need when browning is not the goal.
• Best for camping and gatherings → HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill. Iron build and portable size travel better than a basket-shaped silicone mat.
• Best for two-at-once workflow → TOPINCN 2. You get two liners, so one is always clean.
In my opinion, most people shopping this comparison should buy the HOMOBABE Air Fryer Grill. The reason is not that it is better made — it is that it changes what your air fryer can do. A raised rack turns the appliance into a small grill and gives you browning underneath, which is the single biggest limitation of air frying. The TOPINCN 2 liner is genuinely useful, but it is a maintenance product: it makes cleanup easier without changing the cook. If your priority is a cleaner basket, buy TOPINCN 2. If you want better food, buy HOMOBABE. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one fits your kitchen, since accessory pricing moves around.
Yes. The manufacturer states you can place the mat in the dishwasher after use, and it is described as reusable and washable. That is the main practical advantage over a metal rack, which you will generally want to hand wash to protect its non-stick coating.
It measures 12.2 x 10.24 x 2.87 inches, so it needs a basket or pan at least that wide. Measure your basket's interior before buying. It is also listed for roasting pans, ovens and outdoor grills, so it is not limited to one appliance.
It is designed for the Foodi AG301, with a rectangular 8.7" x 8.1" size. In a much larger or rounder basket it will not cover the base properly. If you own an AG301, the fit is the point.
For crisp skin, the HOMOBABE rack. Lifting the drumsticks lets hot air reach the underside, which a flat silicone liner cannot do. Use the TOPINCN 2 liner when you want the basket to stay clean and do not need all-around browning.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ZEENEEK 8 vs GWY Air Fryer Grill, ZuKaYeHome Air Fryer Replacement vs GZHCJJ Air Fryer Grill, AODPWEN 2 vs Onader Air Fryer Basket