How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• SAWNZC 24Pack — biggest strength: 24 cups across three shapes (round, square, rectangular) in a single set, with a declared safe range of -104 °F to 446 °F, so it covers baking, freezing, microwaving and dishwasher duty.
• SAWNZC 24Pack — biggest trade-off: With 24 cups and three different shapes, you're storing a fair amount of silicone, and the "regular size" format is aimed at standard muffins and lunchbox portions rather than deep, oversized bakes.
• Generic Silicone Air Fryer — biggest strength: Lift handles plus a deeper footprint (listed at roughly 3.94 x 3.94 x 1.18 inches) make it the friendlier pick when you want to pull a hot muffin straight out of an air fryer basket without mangling it.
• Generic Silicone Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: You get four cups in one size only, so it's a small-batch tool rather than a bulk baking set.
• Who each pick is for: SAWNZC 24Pack suits bakers and lunchbox packers who want volume and shape variety; Generic Silicone Air Fryer suits air fryer owners making a few muffins, egg bites or custards at a time.
This is the set you buy when you think in batches. Twenty-four cups means you can fill a muffin tin, run a second tray, and still have cups left over for snacks — without washing anything mid-project. The three shapes are the real differentiator: round cups for classic muffins and cupcakes, square and rectangular ones that slot into bento boxes and containers as dividers. If you pack lunches, that dual role matters more than any single baking feature, because the same object that holds a muffin on Sunday can separate fruit from crackers on Monday.
The material story is straightforward. Food-grade silicone, BPA-free per the description, non-toxic per the listed material features, and rated from -104 °F to 446 °F. That range covers oven baking, microwave reheating, fridge and freezer storage, and dishwasher cleaning — the whole loop, no hand-washing required. The cups are described as thicker and sturdier than typical liners, holding their shape under heavy fill and standing upright on a baking sheet without tilting. That's the failure point of flimsy silicone cups, so it's a meaningful claim to weigh.
Who should skip it? Anyone baking for one or two people who doesn't want 24 pieces of silicone living in a drawer. And if your priority is pulling individual portions out of an air fryer basket, the flat-sided cups here are less convenient than a handled design — you'll be prying rather than lifting.
This one is designed around a specific gesture: reaching into a hot air fryer basket and lifting a muffin out. The lift handles exist for exactly that, and the description emphasizes removing baked treats "while keeping them intact and visually appealing" — which is the everyday problem with silicone cups in an air fryer, where a soft cup with no grip tends to collapse or dump its contents when you grab it.
Four cups, one size, gray, dimensions listed at 3.94 x 3.94 x 1.18 inches and 3.63 ounces. That's a small-batch kit: two muffins for you and two for someone else, or a round of egg bites, puddings, tarts or custards. The stated use cases lean breakfast and dessert portions rather than full-scale baking. The nonabrasive silicone is also positioned as safe on nonstick pans, so if you're setting these inside a coated air fryer basket or on a nonstick tray, the soft material won't scuff the surface.
Skip it if you need volume, shape variety, or lunchbox dividers — it does none of those. It's also not the set for someone who wants to bake a dozen muffins at once. This is a focused, four-cup tool, and it should be judged that way.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer muffins → Generic Silicone Air Fryer — the lift handles and deeper 1.18-inch profile make removing a hot muffin from a basket the easy part.
• Best for bulk baking → SAWNZC 24Pack — 24 cups in one set, no rotating batches through the wash.
• Best for shape variety → SAWNZC 24Pack — round, square and rectangular cups in the same box.
• Best for lunchbox use → SAWNZC 24Pack — the square and rectangular cups work as bento dividers that keep foods separated and prevent flavor transfer.
• Best for freezer-to-oven flexibility → SAWNZC 24Pack — the declared -104 °F to 446 °F range covers freezing and high-heat baking in the same cup.
• Best for nonstick cookware owners → Generic Silicone Air Fryer — the nonabrasive design is explicitly aimed at protecting coated surfaces.
• Best for egg bites, custards and puddings → Generic Silicone Air Fryer — small, deep, handled cups fit single-serve portions better than flat liners.
For air fryer muffins specifically, I'd buy the Generic Silicone Air Fryer. In my opinion, the lift handles and the deeper cup solve the one problem that actually frustrates people — getting the muffin out in one piece — and four cups is the right count for air fryer batches, since baskets hold limited volume anyway. I'd choose the SAWNZC 24Pack instead if my baking leaned toward full trays, lunchbox packing, and mixed shapes, where its volume and versatility clearly win. Different jobs, and I'd match the tool to the job rather than pretend one set covers both.
how to air fryer muffins
Mix your batter, then fill silicone cups about two-thirds full and set them directly in the air fryer basket. Bake at a moderate temperature until a tester comes out clean. Both sets here are silicone and reusable, so no paper liners are needed. The handled Generic cups are easier to lift out; the SAWNZC cups need a gentle push to release.
how to make air fryer muffins
Keep the batter slightly thicker than a pancake batter so it doesn't overflow, and don't overfill the cups. Silicone cups hold their shape on their own, so you can place them straight into the basket without a metal tin — the SAWNZC set notes its cups stand firmly without tilting, which helps here. Leave a little space between cups for air to circulate.
how to air fry english muffins
English muffins are usually split and toasted rather than baked, so this is a short, high-heat job, not a batter recipe. Place the halves cut-side up in the basket and toast until the edges crisp. Neither silicone set is required for this, but the Generic cups are handy if you're simultaneously poaching an egg to go on top.
how long to air fry muffins
Expect a shorter time than a conventional oven because air fryers run hotter and more compact. Start checking around the halfway mark of your usual oven time and pull them when a tester inserted in the center comes out clean. Cup size matters — the deeper Generic ramekins hold more batter than the SAWNZC regular-size liners, so they'll need a little longer.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Air Fry Cooking Oven Chef For Air vs Generic Silicone Muffin Pan, Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer vs Generic Square Air Fryer, Tikxlafe 400 vs Generic Silicone Coated Paper: Air Fryer