How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Eco Cooking Supplies' biggest strength: a 2-pack of 6.5" square food-grade silicone liners rated to 480°F, dishwasher safe, and reusable — you wash them and put them back.
• Eco Cooking Supplies' biggest trade-off: silicone is not a barrier you throw away. Grease and sauce stay on the liner, so somebody still has to rinse or dishwash it after dinner.
• Generic Square Air Fryer's biggest strength: 150 pre-cut 20cm (approx. 7.9") sheets with raised edges and a double-sided silicone coating that traps oil and juices — cook, lift, bin, done.
• Generic Square Air Fryer's biggest trade-off: it's a consumable. The pack runs out, and it tops out at 450°F versus the silicone's 480°F.
• Choose Eco Cooking Supplies if you cook often, hate repurchasing supplies, and don't mind a quick wash.
• Choose Generic Square Air Fryer if you want the absolute minimum cleanup and you'd rather not scrub anything, ever.
This is the liner for the person who air fries several times a week and is tired of buying consumables. You get two 6.5" square silicone mats, each measuring 10.25"L x 7.5"W, designed as a universal fit for 5-quart and larger air fryers, including common Cosori, Ninja, Instant Pot and Breville models. Because they're reusable, one purchase keeps working — no restocking, no running out mid-week.
What it does best is combine heat headroom with easy release. The silicone is rated to 480°F, which covers essentially any air fryer recipe you'd run, plus baking and steaming. It's BPA-free and food-safe, and the non-stick surface lets food lift off without tearing. When you're done, it goes in the dishwasher, which is the real selling point for anyone who cooks on repeat. The design also promotes air circulation, so you're not sacrificing even cooking or crispiness — the liner just sits under the food rather than sealing it in.
Who should skip it? Anyone who genuinely wants zero handling after cooking. Silicone still holds the mess; you're trading a purchase cycle for a wash cycle. If the idea of rinsing a mat after every single cook annoys you, this isn't your product. It's also worth checking that your basket is 5 quarts or larger — smaller fryers are outside its intended fit.
This is the liner for the person who wants the pan to stay clean without doing anything about it. You get 150 pre-cut sheets, each 20cm (about 7.9") square with raised edges, sized to drop straight into most 5 to 8-quart square baskets without folding, tearing or trimming. The raised lip is the quiet hero here — it catches spills and splashes that would otherwise run down into the basket.
The construction is what makes it work: 100% natural unbleached virgin wood pulp with a double-sided food-grade silicone coating. That coating is greaseproof and waterproof, so oils, juices and sticky sauces stay on the sheet instead of leaking through. It's rated to 450°F, which is safe for air fryers, ovens, microwaves and baking, and it's BPA-free and PFAS-free. Food slides off the smooth surface, so wings, fries, mozzarella sticks, pastries and roasted vegetables all come out intact instead of stuck.
The trade-off is honest and simple: it's disposable. You're buying convenience in bulk, and when the 150 run out, you buy again. It's also a slightly lower heat ceiling than the silicone mat — 450°F versus 480°F — which won't matter for normal air frying but is worth knowing if you push your appliance to its maximum. And if you're trying to cut down on kitchen waste, a single-use sheet is the opposite of that goal.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for repeated daily cooking → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. Reusable, dishwasher safe, no restocking.
• Best heat tolerance → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer at 480°F, versus 450°F for the paper sheets.
• Best for sticky, saucy, messy food → Generic Square Air Fryer. The double-sided silicone coating is built to trap juices and sauces.
• Best for baking and steaming versatility → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. Silicone works across air frying, baking and steaming.
• Best for bulk convenience → Generic Square Air Fryer. 150 pre-cut, ready-to-use sheets in one go.
• Best for reducing kitchen waste → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. Reusable beats disposable on that front.
• Best for larger baskets → Generic Square Air Fryer. Its 7.9" square fits most 5 to 8-quart baskets, while the silicone mat is a 6.5" square aimed at 5-quart-and-up universal fit.
I'd buy the Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer liners. In my opinion, the reusable 2-pack is the smarter long-term pick for anyone who air fries regularly: 480°F heat resistance, dishwasher-safe cleanup, and no supply to run out of. The Generic Square Air Fryer sheets are genuinely excellent at what they do, and if you hate washing anything, buy those instead — but you'll be buying them again. For most kitchens, once-and-rinse wins.
FAQ
how to use air fryer silicone liners
Set the liner flat in the bottom of your basket before adding food. Because these are designed to promote air circulation, keep food on top of the mat rather than wrapping it around, and leave the edges clear so hot air can still move. They're rated to 480°F and fit 5-quart and larger air fryers.
Rinse off loose grease, then either hand wash with warm soapy water or put it in the dishwasher — these are dishwasher safe. Food releases easily thanks to the non-stick surface, so heavy scrubbing usually isn't needed. Let it dry fully before storing flat.
how to use air fryer silicone liners ninja
The 6.5" square liners are made as a universal fit for 5-quart and larger air fryers, and Ninja is named among the compatible brands. Drop one into the basket, keep food on top, and confirm there's still airflow around the edges. If your Ninja basket is smaller than 5 quarts, check the fit first.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
Make a paste with baking soda and a little water, rub it onto any stained or greasy spots, let it sit briefly, then rinse and wash as normal. It's a gentle way to lift residue without abrasives. Since these liners are dishwasher safe, you can also just run them through a cycle instead.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Tikxlafe 400 vs Generic Silicone Coated Paper: Air Fryer, Generic Silicone Air Fryer vs Diyeeni Hamburger Bun Silicone, Gavigain Kitchen Fryer vs Generic Air Fryer Cooking