2023:
Daegen Vinduska: Barton County Community College
2022:
Zac Becker: Coffeyville Communitey College / Newman University
2021:
Brooks Whaley: Emporia State University
Mason Sturdy: Emporia State University
2019:
Toby Becker: Truman State University
2018:
Carson Zenger: Marshalltown Community College / Barton County Community College
Tucker Gehrt: Cloud County Community College
2017:
Cooper Schlochtermeier: Cloud County Community College
2016:
Caleb Rogge: Pitt State University / Cowley County Community College / Northeastern Oklahoma A & M
Justin Reiss: University of Dubuque
2015:
Alex Feldkamp: Barton County Community College
Jackson Goodmiller: McPherson College
Zach Nider: Independence Community College
Shilo Schaake: Hutchinson Community College
2013:
Shane Adams: Barton County Community College
Josh Srna: Washburn University / Longview Community College
Ryne Harshbarger: Longview Community College
Adam Schmitz: Manhattan Christian College
Eric Willard: Ottawa University
2011:
JD Garetson: Washburn University / Manhattan Christian College
2009:
Kegan Rawhouser: Cloud County Community College
Luis Gonzalez: Cloud County Community College
Matt Gee: Cloud County Community College
Dustin Miner: Kansas State University / Washburn University (football)
2006:
Eammon Bradley: Manhattan Christian College
Josh Garcia: Manhattan Christian College
Travis Beyer: University of Northern Oklahoma
2004:
Dustin Vaughn: Bethany
2003:
Luke Harrison: Barton County Community College