When deciding between Best Ball and Scramble as the preferred format for golf games, players often weigh the benefits and challenges of each to determine which suits their group and goals best. Both formats are popular for team play, but they cater to different types of experiences, skill levels, and competitive environments, making the question of which is better subjective and dependent on context.
Best Ball is a format where each player plays their own ball throughout the round, and the team records the lowest individual score on each hole. This setup rewards individual performance within a team dynamic, allowing skilled players to leverage their abilities while less experienced players can contribute without the pressure of carrying the team on every shot. Because every player plays their own ball, Best Ball maintains a traditional golf feel and encourages strategic decision-making — for example, deciding when to take risks or play conservatively based on teammates’ scores. This format is excellent for competitive outings, as it challenges players to perform their best while still fostering teamwork. The scoring system is straightforward, and it can accommodate players of different skill levels, making it popular for club competitions and casual rounds alike.
In contrast, the Scramble format is designed to emphasize teamwork and speed, often making it the preferred choice for fun, social rounds or charity tournaments. In a scramble, all players tee off, and the team selects the best shot. Then, all players play their next shots from that position, repeating the process until the hole is completed. This means that weaker shots are effectively minimized, and the team always plays from the most advantageous position. The result is generally lower scores and a faster pace of play, which appeals to groups with mixed skill levels or those looking to maximize enjoyment without focusing too heavily on individual performance. The scramble format encourages constant communication and support among teammates, creating a lively and social atmosphere.
Choosing which format is better ultimately depends on the group’s objectives. If the focus is on competitive golf with an emphasis on individual skill contributing to the team’s success, Best Ball is often preferred. It challenges players while allowing for individual accountability. However, if the goal is to have a relaxed, fast-paced, and inclusive game that maximizes fun and team interaction, Scramble is likely the better choice.
In summary, neither format is inherently better than the other — they simply serve different purposes. Understanding the strengths and unique characteristics of Best Ball and Scramble allows players to select the right format for their event, skill level, and desired golf experience.
Details at: https://ricksgolfshop.com/best-ball-vs-scramble/