How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper — biggest strength: it's a purpose-built replacement rack for one specific family of machines (Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker air fryers), with a double-layer nonstick coating and a handle for lifting it out.
• QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper — biggest trade-off: it only fits Ninja 6.5QT FD302/OS301/FD305/OP302/OS300 Foodi units, and it's a single flat plate rather than a deep basket — so it's for crisping and grilling, not for holding a big batch of loose food.
• BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket — biggest strength: it's a two-piece set (ultra-fine mesh crisper basket plus a non-stick ceramic baking pan) sized for Ninja Foodi SP101/SP100/SP1001C/SP201 countertop air fry ovens, and both parts are dishwasher-friendly.
• BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket — biggest trade-off: it does not fit the Ninja SP151, and it's built for the oven-style SP series — not for the 6.5QT pressure cooker air fryers QLRGNE targets.
• Who each pick is for: QLRGNE if you own a Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker air fryer and want one better crisper plate; BBQ-PLUS if you own an SP-series Ninja Foodi air fry oven and want to replace or upgrade both the basket and the baking pan.
The QLRGNE crisper is a replacement grill plate, not a full accessory system. Its whole job is to sit inside a Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker air fryer — specifically the FD302, OS301, FD305, OP302 and OS300 — and give you a raised, perforated surface so hot air can move under the food instead of letting it sit in its own moisture. If you've ever pulled soggy-ish wings or pale fries out of that machine, a crisper plate is the classic fix.
Who should buy it: anyone with one of those specific Ninja 6.5QT models who wants a dedicated crisping surface for wings, fries, vegetables, or a grilled-cheese-style sear without buying a second appliance. Who should skip it: anyone whose machine isn't on that list, and anyone hoping to cook a large loose batch — this is a flat plate with a 7 x 7 inch footprint, so it's for single layers of food, not a pile of them. Also worth noting: QLRGNE explicitly warns against scrubbing it with abrasive pads or metal balls, so if you're a steel-wool person, this plate will punish that habit.
BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket: Who It's For
The BBQ-PLUS set is a different animal entirely. It's a two-piece replacement for Ninja Foodi SP-series air fry ovens — SP101, SP100, SP1001C and SP201 — and it measures 13 x 13 inches, which tells you immediately that we're talking about a countertop oven format, not a pot. One critical caveat straight from the listing: it does not fit the Ninja SP151, so measure and check your model number before you commit.
You get a mesh crisper basket in food-grade 304 stainless steel, rated heat-resistant up to 450°F, plus a baking tray with a non-stick ceramic coating that BBQ-PLUS says is built to handle repeated cooking cycles without warping. The mesh is deliberately ultra-fine to push air circulation and even heat distribution — the logic being faster, more uniform crisping rather than hot spots. The baking pan covers the other half of the job: cookies, cakes, casseroles, roasted meats. Using both at once lets you cook two different things in the same session, which is the real reason oven-style air fryer owners buy a set instead of a single piece.
Both parts are smooth and non-stick, so hand-washing is quick and the dishwasher is fine. At 2.55 pounds, this isn't a flimsy stamped tray — there's real metal here. Who should buy it: SP-series owners whose original basket is worn, stained, or lost, or who want the flexibility of basket-plus-pan cooking. Who should skip it: anyone with a 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker air fryer, and any SP151 owner, because neither machine is compatible.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Ninja Foodi SP-series air fry ovens → BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket. Designed for SP101, SP100, SP1001C and SP201.
• Best for crisping wings, fries and veggies → both, but differently. QLRGNE gives you a raised nonstick plate; BBQ-PLUS gives you an ultra-fine mesh basket tuned for airflow.
• Best for baking and roasting → BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket. Its ceramic-coated baking pan is the only true baking surface of the two.
• Best for cooking two things at once → BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket. Basket plus pan in one session is a real workflow advantage.
• Best for easy cleanup → both. QLRGNE is dishwasher safe with a handle for lifting; BBQ-PLUS parts are non-stick and dishwasher friendly.
• Best for maximum heat tolerance → BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket. Its stainless basket is rated to 450°F.
• Best if you're unsure about fit → check your model number first. QLRGNE fits one narrow machine family; BBQ-PLUS fits another and explicitly excludes the SP151.
In my opinion, the deciding factor here isn't quality — it's your appliance. If you own a Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker air fryer, I'd buy the QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper, because it's built specifically for that chassis and the handle plus double-layer nonstick make it pleasant to live with. If you own an SP-series Ninja Foodi air fry oven, I'd buy the BBQ-PLUS Air Fryer Basket, because you get two functional pieces, a 450°F-rated stainless basket, and a baking pan you'd otherwise have to source separately. Neither is a universal upgrade. Match the model, and you'll be happy.
FAQ
No. QLRGNE lists compatibility only with Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker air fryers — FD302, OS301, FD305, OP302 and OS300. For an SP-series air fry oven, the BBQ-PLUS set is the one designed to fit.
Both are dishwasher safe. QLRGNE's plate has a double-layer nonstick coating and a handle for lifting it out, but the brand warns against abrasive pads or metal scrubbers. BBQ-PLUS parts have a smooth non-stick finish on both the stainless mesh basket and ceramic-coated pan.
The two are not interchangeable, so price shouldn't drive the decision — fit should. Pick the one made for your machine, then check the current price on Amazon using the button on this page.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWYXC Air Fryer Accessories vs BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter, YEPATER Air Fryer Basket vs COOK WITH COLOR Colorful 1200W, OPENICE Air Fryer Basket vs GWYSY Air fryer Accessories