We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a simple, dishwasher-safe crisper plate that drops straight into a Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker and air fryer, choose QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper; if you need a larger rectangular basket for a Ninja Foodi Smart XL indoor grill, with disposable liners to cut cleanup, choose BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket. These are two different tools for two different machines, and picking the wrong one is the main mistake buyers make.
• QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper — biggest strength: a food-grade carbon steel plate with a double-layer nonstick coating, a built-in handle, and dishwasher-safe cleanup. It is sized specifically for Ninja 6.5QT Foodi models (OS300, OS301, FD302, FD305, OP302).
• QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper — biggest trade-off: it only fits those 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker and air fryer units. It is a single flat 7 x 7 inch insert with no basket walls and no liners, so it does not fit the larger Smart XL grill line.
• BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket — biggest strength: an XL rectangular basket (12.8" x 7.2" x 3") with raised edges, a sculpted cut-out design for airflow, and 100 disposable paper liners bundled in.
• BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket — biggest trade-off: it is hand-wash only, and it fits the Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 indoor grill family, not a 6.5QT pressure cooker air fryer. It also needs careful drying to protect the nonstick coating.
• Who each pick is for: QLRGNE for 6.5QT Ninja Foodi pressure cooker owners who want a low-effort, dishwasher-safe crisper plate. BBQ-PLUS for Smart XL indoor grill owners who want a bigger batch and near-zero cleanup.
The QLRGNE crisper is a replacement grill plate and rack insert built for a specific family of machines: the Ninja 6.5QT Foodi OS300, OS301, FD302, FD305, and OP302 pressure cooker and air fryers. That narrow fit is the whole point. If you own one of those, this is a direct drop-in piece that sits in the basket and gives you a raised surface to crisp on, with a handle so you can lift the whole plate out instead of fishing around with tongs.
It is dishwasher safe, which is the real selling point for most people. You cook wings or frozen fries, pull the plate by the handle, and let the dishwasher do the rest.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a Ninja Foodi Smart XL indoor grill, or a pressure cooker air fryer in a different capacity. It is a 7 x 7 inch plate, so it is not the tool for big-batch cooking either. And if you use metal spatulas or abrasive scrubbers on habit, be aware the care notes specifically warn against rough cloths and metal balls, since those will wreck the nonstick surface.
BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket: Who It's For
The BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket is a different animal entirely. It is a rectangular replacement basket for the Ninja Foodi FG551, DG551, and DG651 Smart XL 6-in-1 indoor grill family, and the compatibility list is long and specific — BG500A through FG551QWH, dozens of model numbers. That precision is useful, but it also means you should check your exact model number before buying. On a grill this size, a near-miss fit is a return.
Where it wins is capacity and airflow. At 12.8" x 7.2" x 3 inches, it is a genuinely large basket, and the raised edges plus open-bottom, sculpted cut-out design are engineered to push hot air around the food rather than trap it. That is the difference between fries that crisp evenly and fries that go pale in the middle. It is the kind of basket you fill once for a family batch instead of cooking three rounds.
The 100 disposable paper liners are the headline convenience. Place a liner, cook, lift it out, toss it. For anyone who hates scrubbing a grill basket after wings, that alone changes the nightly routine.
The trade-off is care. This basket is hand-wash only, and the instructions are strict: wash right after use, dry it thoroughly, never soak it, never use abrasives, and store it only when completely dry. Skip that and you risk rust or a degraded nonstick coating. It also does not fit 6.5QT pressure cooker air fryers, so if that is your machine, this is the wrong pick no matter how good the basket is.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Ninja Foodi Smart XL indoor grill owners → BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket. It matches the FG551, DG551, and DG651 lines.
• Best for easy cleanup → QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper. It is dishwasher safe; BBQ-PLUS is hand-wash only.
• Best for large batches → BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket. The 12.8" x 7.2" x 3" size dwarfs a 7 x 7 inch plate.
• Best for airflow and even crisping → BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket. The raised edges and open-bottom cut-out design are purpose-built for hot air circulation.
• Best for skipping scrubbing altogether → BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket. The 100 disposable liners let you cook and discard.
• Best for low-maintenance durability → QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper. The double-layer coating and included rubber tabs reduce wear and rattle.
• Best for a grab-and-go handle → QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper. The built-in handle makes lifting the plate out simple.
In my opinion, the right call comes down to which machine is already sitting on your counter, not which basket is objectively better. If you own a Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker and air fryer, I would buy the QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper — it fits, it has a handle, and it goes in the dishwasher, which is exactly what you want from a crisper plate. If you own a Ninja Foodi Smart XL indoor grill, I would buy the BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket for the bigger capacity, the airflow design, and those 100 liners. Buy for your appliance, and both are sensible. Buy the wrong one, and neither works.
FAQ
No. It is sized for the Ninja 6.5QT Foodi pressure cooker and air fryer models OS300, OS301, FD302, FD305, and OP302. It is a 7 x 7 inch plate, so it is not built for the larger Smart XL grill.
For even crisping, I would lean toward the BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket. Its raised edges and open-bottom, sculpted design are made to maximize hot air circulation, which helps avoid hot spots and pale centers.
If you want minimal cleanup, the BBQ-PLUS Combo Crisper Basket includes 100 disposable liners you place, cook on, and discard. If you prefer to just load a dishwasher, the QLRGNE Air Fryer Crisper is the easier option. Both are worth checking the current price on Amazon before you decide.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: HYUEEWX Barbecue BBQ Stainless vs NOLITOY Air Fryer, Fondpen Air Fryer Basket vs Hapivida Fryer Grill Plate, air fryer combo