Paraguay: A Safe Haven for Nazis
Paraguay: A Safe Haven for Nazis
During the war, Paraguayan passports were used to escape from Europe. With the favorable change in Paraguayan immigration policy in 1944, Jewish immigrants kept on arriving in the South American country and reuniting with the Jewish diaspora that had settled there. Thus, when the war ended, Holocaust survivors arrived in Paraguay, were reunited with their families, and hoped to start their lives over again, leaving the catastrophic war behind.
However, painting a black stain on Paraguayan history, Holocaust survivors were not the only ones to arrive. Escaping trials after the defeat of Nazism and the Allies’ discovery of concentration camps and mass graves, Nazi officials also found in South America a safe haven. Taking advantage of predominantly authoritarian regimes in South American countries, some of which had Nazi tendencies themselves, high-ranking Nazi officials like Adolf Eichmann, Klaus Barbie, and Josef Mengele escaped to Argentina, Bolivia, and Paraguay/Brazil respectively. In the Argentinian case, Eichmann lived a comfortable life in the South American country under the protection of the dictator Juan Domingo Perón, until he was discovered by a Holocaust survivor, kidnapped (not extradited) by Mossad, and taken back to Israel where he faced trial and was hanged for his countless crimes against humanity.
Similarly, Josef Mengele lived a relatively peaceful life in the countryside of Paraguay by assisting farmers with his medical skills. He was known as the “Angel of Death” for his macabre experiments in Auschwitz, and for being responsible for the death of approximately 400.000 Jews. Mengele first escaped and lived in Argentina for a few years until finally relocating to its neighbor country, where a clandestine branch of the Nazi party was still functioning.[1] At the time of his first visit to Paraguay in 1951, Alfredo Stroessner was not yet the all-powerful dictator who would rule the South American country for 35 years. However, when Mengele finally decided to settle in Paraguay and apply to Paraguayan citizenship in 1959, Stroessner had already consolidated his uncontested supremacy in politics. As the supreme dictator, Stroessner had power over everyone and everything, and whoever dared to contradict him would have faced terrible consequences that ranged from exile, to torture, to death.
Under Alfredo Stroessner´s dictatorship, Mengele “Paraguayanized” his name by changing it to José Mengele.[2] With allies who protected him along the way, such as Hans Ulrich Rudel, a Nazi war hero and a close friend to Stroessner, Mengele lived a good life in the countryside of Paraguay, reading, writing, and sometimes even offering medical attention to people who needed it. While with Stroessner´s protection Paraguay seemed to be a safe place to live, after Eichmann´s kidnapping in 1960, and after being recognized by a Holocaust survivor in Asunción, Mengele decided to move and spend the rest of his days in Brazil. A few years after relocating, Mengele drowned due to a stroke, once more avoiding trial for the crimes he committed.[3]
Fig. 9: Reproduced with permission from the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, Josef Mengele.
Another Nazi official named Eduard Rochsmann, known as the “Butcher of Riga,” escaped to Argentina and then to Paraguay, where he ended up dying in a public hospital.[4] Unlike Mengele, Rochsmann did not received protection or assistance from the supreme dictator. However, similar to Mengele, Rochsmann was a prominent SS Nazi official in Latvia who was in charge of the Riga ghetto, and who had the blood of hundreds of thousands of Jews on his hands. While it could be argued that the regime or the clandestine Nazi Party´s support to Rochsmann was nonexistent, it should also be considered that he entered the country without any obstacles. Perhaps if he had escaped death after only being in Paraguay for a couple of days, he could have followed Mengele´s fate of an ensured protection and assistance from Nazi sympathizers and governmental authorities.
Fig. 10: Eduard Rochsmann.
Fig. 11: Chart tracking Josef Mengele´s presumed whereabouts in Charles J. Hanley, “Elusive Dr. Mengele: unpunished symbol of Holocaust,” The Galveston Daily News, (Galveston, TX), May 20, 1985.
Fig. 12: Collage by author of all the known names or aliases utilized by Josef Mengele during his stay in Argentina, Paraguay, and Brazil. From Andrés Colmán, Mengele en Paraguay, (Asunción: ServiLibro, 2018).
[1] The first branch of the National Socialist Party in a foreign land was founded in Paraguay in 1929. For a more detailed history of the presence of Nazism in Paraguay during the interwar years, see Alfredo Seiferheld, Nazismo y Fascismo en el Paraguay: Vísperas de la II Guerra Mundial (1985), and Nazismo y Fascismo en el Paraguay: Los Años de la Guerra 1939-1945 (1986), (Asunción: Editorial Histórica).
[2] Andrés Colmán, Mengele en Paraguay, (Asunción: ServiLibro, 2018): 162.
[3] Andrés Colmán, Mengele en Paraguay, 314.
[4] Juan Cálcena Ramírez, Un nazi en el sur: El carnicero de Riga en Paraguay, (Asunción: Tiempo Ediciones & Contenidos, 2017).