How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a stainless steel replacement tray for an oval 7-quart PowerXL Vortex, choose oecue Replacement Parts; if you need a nonstick carbon steel tray built for the square 8-quart PowerXL Vortex Pro Air Fryer Plus, choose ALJ Air Fryer Tray. These two trays look similar in photos and are often lumped together in the same search results, but they are not interchangeable — they fit different machines, use different materials, and solve slightly different problems. In my opinion, the single most important thing in a Power XL air fryer review is fitment, because a tray that is half an inch off will rattle, tilt, or block airflow. So before anything else: measure your basket, confirm your model, then pick.
• oecue Replacement Parts — biggest strength: food-grade stainless steel with an enameled coating, sized 10.1'' × 9.3'' for the oval 7QT PowerXL Vortex, plus a whirlwind airflow pattern and four rubber bumpers.
• oecue Replacement Parts — biggest trade-off: it is made for one model family only. If you own an 8QT Vortex Pro Plus, this tray is the wrong shape.
• ALJ Air Fryer Tray — biggest strength: a double-layer nonstick carbon steel build sized 9.6 × 9.5 inches (with rubber feet) for the 8QT PowerXL Vortex Pro Air Fryer Plus, and it ships with a cleaning cloth and six bumpers.
• ALJ Air Fryer Tray — biggest trade-off: the coating is the wear point. Carbon steel with a nonstick layer needs gentle washing to stay intact, and it is not built for the 7QT oval basket.
• Who each pick is for: oecue for owners of the 7QT oval Vortex who want a steel tray with a handle and a shielded inner wall; ALJ for owners of the 8QT Vortex Pro Plus who want a coated, easy-release tray with a spare cleaning cloth in the box.
The oecue tray is a direct replacement part, not a universal accessory. It is designed for the PowerXL 7QT air fryer with an oval basket, and the listed size is 10.1'' × 9.3''. The material story matters here: food-grade stainless steel with an enameled coating, no BPA, non-toxic and tasteless, and it states it meets FDA standards. If you are the kind of cook who reaches for metal tongs without thinking, a steel core is reassuring — the enamel is what you want to protect, not the structure underneath it.
The feature I like most is the whirlwind airflow design. In practice, a perforated tray with a directional pattern lets hot air move up and around food instead of pooling in one spot, which is exactly what you want for wings, fries, vegetables, steak, fish, and pizza. It also has a handle, which sounds minor until you have tried to lift a hot, greasy tray out of a deep basket with two forks. And the four rubber bumpers are a genuinely thoughtful touch: they keep the tray from grinding against the inner wall of the fryer, so you are not slowly scratching the coating on the appliance itself.
Who should buy it: owners of the 7QT oval PowerXL Vortex who want a stainless steel tray they can run through the dishwasher, and who value even airflow and a scratch-free basket wall. Who should skip it: anyone with an 8QT Vortex Pro Plus, anyone who needs a square tray, and anyone who prefers a heavy nonstick coating over an enameled steel surface. oecue's own instructions say it plainly — measure your original tray first, and do not scrub it with abrasive cloths or metal balls.
The ALJ tray is built around a different machine: the 8QT PowerXL Vortex Pro Air Fryer Plus. The listed size is 9.6 × 9.5 inches with the rubber feet on, and the product dimensions are given as 9.6 × 9.6 × 0.2 inches at 3.2 ounces. That is a light, square-ish insert, and the shape is the whole point — it is meant to sit flat in the 8QT basket rather than wobble around in a 7QT oval one.
Material-wise, ALJ goes a different route than oecue: food-grade carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick coating, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and it also states it meets FDA standards. Carbon steel is a sensible choice for a tray like this because it is thin and light, so it heats quickly and does not eat into your basket's usable depth. The double-layer coating process is the part ALJ emphasizes — the claim is that the coating resists flaking better than a single-layer finish, which extends how long the tray stays genuinely nonstick.
Two practical details stand out. First, there is a handle, so lifting it out of the basket is a one-hand job. Second, it is dishwasher safe, though the warm tips ask you not to use rough abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls. ALJ also includes six rubber bumpers and a kitchen nonstick cleaning cloth as a gift in the box — the cloth exists specifically because the coating is the part you are protecting.
Who should buy it: owners of the 8QT PowerXL Vortex Pro Air Fryer Plus who want a light, easy-release tray and a bit of backup hardware in the package. Who should skip it: owners of the 7QT oval Vortex, and anyone who wants a bare stainless steel surface with no coating to worry about. The listed tolerance is 1–3mm depending on how it is measured, so if your basket is a tight fit, keep that in mind.
• Best fit for the 7QT oval PowerXL Vortex → oecue Replacement Parts. Its 10.1'' × 9.3'' footprint is matched to that basket.
• Best fit for the 8QT PowerXL Vortex Pro Air Fryer Plus → ALJ Air Fryer Tray. Its 9.6 × 9.5 inch size is made for that model.
• Best for a steel rather than coated surface → oecue Replacement Parts. Stainless steel with an enameled finish and a whirlwind airflow pattern.
• Best for easy release and light weight → ALJ Air Fryer Tray. Double-layer nonstick carbon steel at 3.2 ounces.
• Best for airflow-focused cooking → oecue Replacement Parts. The whirlwind design is aimed at even heating across wings, fries, vegetables, steak, fish and pizza.
• Best for extras in the box → ALJ Air Fryer Tray. You get six rubber bumpers and a nonstick cleaning cloth along with the tray.
• Best for basket-wall protection → both. Each includes rubber bumpers, and oecue specifically notes they prevent scratches on the inner wall.
• Best for carefree cleaning → oecue Replacement Parts. Steel handles dishwasher cycles with less coating anxiety than a nonstick layer.
If I had to pick one, I would buy the oecue Replacement Parts tray for a 7QT oval PowerXL Vortex and the ALJ Air Fryer Tray for an 8QT Vortex Pro Plus — the choice is dictated by your machine, not by preference. Forced to name a single recommendation for the most common 7QT Vortex owner, I would go with oecue, because stainless steel with an enameled coating and a whirlwind airflow pattern is the combination I would personally want in a tray that gets scraped, soaked and shoved into a dishwasher. If you own the 8QT Pro Plus, ignore that and get the ALJ tray — it is the one shaped for your basket. Either way, confirm your model and measure before ordering, and check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
No. oecue lists it specifically for the PowerXL 7QT air fryer at 10.1'' × 9.3''. The 8QT Pro Plus uses a different basket shape, so you want the ALJ tray instead.
It is designed for the 8QT PowerXL Vortex Pro Air Fryer Plus at 9.6 × 9.5 inches with the rubber feet. Because the two baskets differ in shape, I would not expect a clean fit in the 7QT oval model.
Both are dishwasher safe and both warn against abrasive cloths or metal balls. The ALJ tray adds a double-layer nonstick coating and ships with a cleaning cloth, so it releases food more easily but needs gentler handling to protect that coating. The oecue tray is enameled stainless steel, so there is no nonstick layer to baby quite as much.
Yes — both brands say so in their own instructions. oecue asks you to measure your original tray, and ALJ notes a 1–3mm measuring deviation. A few millimeters is the difference between a tray that sits flat and one that tilts and blocks airflow.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GXF Replacement Parts vs Aqzfeuy Silicone Air Fryer, oecue Air Fryer Replacement vs M4Y Replacement Air Fryer, SIUDANGKA Crumb Tray Replacement vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer