1990-1999
1990
League : TVC
TVC Champions: 8th TVC Title in school history
Captains : Josh Conkel, John Corwin
All Conference : Glen Flores, Heath Savage, Joh Corwin, Brice Fick, Jay Hook, Jason Conkel, Ryan Mitchell, Brian Withem
All District : 1st Team - Ryan Mitchell, Jay Hook, Heath Savage. Special Mention - John Corwin.
All State : 2nd Team - Jay Hook Special Mention - Ryan Mitchell, Heath Savage
RECORD 7 - 3
NYHS - 6 Athens - 25
NYHS - 20 Jackson - 6
NYHS - 37 Meigs - 19
NYHS - 49 Alexander - 8
NYHS - 27 Trimble - 0
NYHS - 52 Miller - 14
NYHS - 24 Vinton County - 25
NYHS - 52 Federal Hocking - 0
NYHS - 14 Belpre - 12
NYHS - 36 Wellston - 6
1991
League : TVC
Captains : Brice Fick, Matt Eckels, Todd Dennis
All Conference : Brice Fick, Matt Eckels, Todd Dennis, Glenn Flores, Casey Nungester, Tony Breeze, Tom Snyder
All District : 1st Team - Glenn Flores, Brice Fick. Special Mention - Casey Nungester, Tom Snyder
All State : Special Mention - Glenn Flores, Brice Fick
RECORD 8 - 2
NYHS - 27 Athens - 8
NYHS - 22 Jackson -44
NYHS - 46 Meigs - 7
NYHS - 33 Alexander - 8
NYHS - 25 Trimble - 13
NYHS - 43 Miller - 0
NYHS - 6 Vinton County - 7
NYHS - 42 Federal Hocking - 6
NYHS - 14 Belpre - 0
NYHS - 20 Bishop Ready - 14
1992
League : TVC
TVC Champions: 9th TVC Title in school history
Captains : Jeromey Sheets, Eddie Carter, Tony Breeze, Casey Nungester
All Conference : John Stover, Casey Nungester, Ed Carter, Jeromey Sheets, Tony Breeze, Brian Warren, Mike Pidcock, Dale Matheny, Justin Gail
All District : 1st Team - Brian Warren, Ed Carter, Casey Nungester, Tad Steinbrink, Tony Breeze. Special Mention - Mike Pidcock.
Coach of the Year - Dave Boston Sr.
All State : 2nd Team - Casey Nungester Special Mention - Brian Warren, Tony Breeze, Ed Carter, Tad Steinbrink
RECORD 10 - 1
NYHS - 35 Athens - 0
NYHS - 33 Logan -7
NYHS - 29 Meigs - 0
NYHS - 34 Alexander - 0
NYHS - 34 Trimble - 14
NYHS - 34 Miller - 0
NYHS - 41 Vinton County - 7
NYHS - 41 Federal Hocking - 0
NYHS - 34 Belpre - 0
NYHS - 27 Wellston - 0
Playoffs
NYHS - 0 Ironton - 14
1993
League : TVC - Ohio
TVC Champions: 10th TVC Title in school history
Captains : Jeff Warix, Chris Freer, Tony Bateson, Randy Cline
All Conference : Chris Freer, Chad Inman, Randy Cline, Mike Lewis, Jason Gail, Tony Bateson, Justin Gail
All District : 1st Team: Justin Gail, Chad Inman, Special Mention: Tad Steinbrink, Jason Gail, Randy Cline, Tony Bateson
All State : 2nd Team - Justin Gail Special Mention - Chad Inman
RECORD 8 - 2
NYHS - 38 Athens - 0
NYHS - 18 Logan -35
NYHS - 24 Portsmouth West - 0
NYHS - 35 Alexander - 16
NYHS - 50 Trimble - 14
NYHS - 14 Vinton County - 13
NYHS - 65 Meigs - 7
NYHS - 32 Wellston - 0
NYHS - 27 Belpre - 21
NYHS - 0 Magnolia - 10
1994
League : TVC - Ohio
TVC Champions: 11th TVC Title in school history
Captains : Mike Lewis, Jason Gail, Justin Gail, Matt Call
All Conference : Michael Lewis, Travis Rosser, Justin Gail, Jason Gail, Tad Steinbrink, Seth Collins, Matt Call
All District - 1st Team - Justin Gail (Offensive Player of the Year): Mike Lewis, Tad Steinbrink, Jason Gail, Matt Call Special Mention: Seth Collins, Travis Rosser
All State : 1st Team - Justin Gail (D IV Offensive Player of the Year), 2nd Team - Tad Steinbrink Special Mention - Mike Lewis, Jason Gail, Matt Call
RECORD 11 - 1
NYHS - 28 Athens - 0
NYHS - 20 Logan -19
NYHS - 16 Portsmouth West - 6
NYHS - 48 Alexander - 14
NYHS - 58 Trimble - 0
NYHS - 26 Vinton County - 21
NYHS - 43 Meigs - 6
NYHS - 41 Wellston - 3
NYHS - 47 Belpre - 6
NYHS - 48 Jackson - 7
Playoffs
NYHS - 41 Coshocton - 16
NYHS - 7 Wheelersburg - 28
1995
League : TVC - Ohio
Captains : Shaun North, Nathan McLaughlin, Seth Collins, Chris Williams
All Conference : Nathan McLaughlin, Chris Williams, Nathan Stalder, Seth Collins, Brian Elliott
All District : 1st Team - Chris Williams, Seth Collins, Nathan Stalder, Nathan McLaughlin, Special Mention - Brian Elliott
All State : Special Mention - Chris Williams, Seth Collins, Nathan Stalder, Nathan McLaughlin
RECORD 6 - 4
NYHS - 22 Athens - 15
NYHS - 18 Logan -21
NYHS - 0 Portsmouth West - 9
NYHS - 20 Alexander - 14
NYHS - 19 Trimble - 6
NYHS - 12 Vinton County - 13
NYHS - 22 Meigs - 20
NYHS - 16 Wellston - 0
NYHS - 24 Belpre - 6
NYHS - 21 Oak Hill - 20
1996
League : TVC - Ohio
Captains : Nathan Stalder, Eric Mitchell, Erik Kelly, Jamie Dishong
All Conference : Nathan Stalder, Eric Mitchell, Ben Robey, Parker Elliott, Daniel Carter, Eric Glass, Zach Odenthal
All District : 1st Team: Ben Robey, Eric Mitchell, Nathan Stalder, Special Mention: Parker Elliott
All State : 2nd Team - Nathan Stalder Special Mention - Eric Mitchell, Ben Robey
RECORD 6 - 4
NYHS - 9 Athens - 31
NYHS - 28 Logan -21
NYHS - 14 Portsmouth West - 20
NYHS - 34 Alexander - 14
NYHS - 35 Trimble - 13
NYHS - 6 Vinton County - 42
NYHS - 19 Meigs - 28
NYHS - 54 Wellston - 22
NYHS - 8 Belpre - 26
NYHS - 46 Oak Hill - 0
1997
League : TVC - Ohio
TVC Champions: 12th TVC Title in school history
Captains : Daniel Carter, Parker Elliott, Clay Watkins, Jason Russell
All Conference : Jason Russell, Darrin Lawson, Clay Watkins, Chris Glass, Josh Walker, Ben Robey, Eric Glass, Daniel Carter, Zach Odenthal
All District : 1st Team - Jason Russell (Defensive Player of the Year), Ben Robey, Eric Glass, Chris Glass, Special Mention: Darin Lawson, Clay Watkins
Coach of the Year: Kevin Meade
All State : (1st Team) - Jason Russell 2nd Team -Ben Robey Special Mention - Eric Glass, Chris Glass,
RECORD 11 - 1
NYHS - 48 Athens - 7
NYHS - 27 Logan -17
NYHS - 20 Coal Grove - 13
NYHS - 13 Miller- 0
NYHS - 54 Trimble - 0
NYHS - 20 Vinton County - 12
NYHS - 30 Meigs - 0
NYHS - 39 Wellston - 20
NYHS - 13 Belpre - 3
NYHS - 41 Alexander - 0
Playoffs
NYHS - 41 Wheelersburg - 14
NYHS - 6 Bellaire - 39
1998
League : TVC - Ohio
Captains : Ben Robey, Michael Warren, Zach Odenthal, Eric Glass
All Conference : Matt Katterhenrich, Zach Odenthal, Eric Glass, Michael Warren, Ben Robey
All District : 1st Team - Ben Robey (Defensive Player of the Year) Eric Glass, Zack Odenthal, Mike Warren, Special Mention: Flynt Smathers
All State : 1st Team - Ben Robey, Special Mention - Eric Glass, Zach Odenthal, Mike Warren
RECORD 9 - 3
NYHS - 21 Athens - 20
NYHS - 29 Logan - 34
NYHS - 17 Coal Grove - 14
NYHS - 28 Chesapeake- 14
NYHS - 29 Trimble - 25
NYHS - 34 Vinton County - 18
NYHS - 15 Meigs - 26
NYHS - 33 Wellston - 6
NYHS - 27 Belpre - 16
NYHS - 49 Alexander - 13
Playoffs
NYHS - 21 Lucasville Valley - 14
NYHS - 19 Wheelersburg - 61
1999
League : TVC - Ohio
Captains : Chad Brandeberry, Noah Watkins, Matt Katterhenrich, David Burnette
All Conference : Josh Stalder, Noah Watkins, David Burnette
All District : 1st Team - Ryan Horrocks, Matt Katterhenrich, David Burnette, Special Mention: Josh Stalder, John Fletcher
All State : Special Mention - Ryan Horrocks, Matt Katterhenrich, David Burnette
RECORD 4 - 6
NYHS - 35 Athens - 17
NYHS - 15 Logan - 42
NYHS - 7 St. Charles - 35
NYHS - 7 Chesapeake- 44
NYHS - 33 Trimble - 7
NYHS - 22 Vinton County - 25
NYHS - 14 Meigs - 32
NYHS - 18 Wellston - 38
NYHS - 33 Belpre - 19
NYHS - 35 Alexander - 14