How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Numola's biggest strength: unbleached wood-pulp paper that's stated to be 1.2 times thicker than ordinary parchment, with a heat tolerance of up to 450°F (230°C) and a 100-count stack of 8-inch pre-cut sheets.
• Numola's biggest trade-off: it's a flat rectangular sheet, so there's no raised edge to trap grease and crumbs — and the brand itself notes you need to put enough food on the sheet for safe use in an air fryer.
• Apenkes 200's biggest strength: 200 square 8x8-inch liners with a 1.8-inch raised rim, sized for 5–8QT air fryers, so saucy or greasy food stays put instead of pooling in the basket.
• Apenkes 200's biggest trade-off: lower stated heat ceiling at 428°F (220°C), and the rim design is really built around basket cooking rather than flat baking trays.
• Pick Numola if you bake and roast across ovens, toaster ovens and pans as much as you air fry, and want the thicker, higher-heat sheet.
• Pick Apenkes 200 if your air fryer is your main appliance, you cook messy food often, and you'd rather have double the liners with a rim doing the containment work.
Numola's sheets are cut to 8 inches and sold as a 100-count pack, and the spec that stands out to me is the thickness claim: 1.2 times thicker than ordinary parchment. In practice that's the difference between a liner that lifts out cleanly with food on it and one that tears or soaks through mid-cook. The paper is unbleached, made from natural wood pulp with an oil coating, and described as non-toxic and non-wax — so no bleaching step and no greasing your pans before use.
Who should buy it? Home bakers and all-round cooks who want a thicker, higher-heat sheet and don't mind that it's flat. Who should skip it? If your air fryer does most of the work and you regularly cook saucy, greasy food, a flat sheet won't corral liquids the way a rimmed liner will — and Numola's own guidance is to load enough food on the sheet for safe air fryer use, which is an extra step to remember.
Apenkes 200: Who It's For
Apenkes built its liners around one job: keeping a 5–8QT air fryer basket clean. You get 200 square sheets measuring 8x8 inches, made from unbleached wood pulp, heat-resistant to 428°F (220°C), and described as heavy-duty enough not to rip or leak. The feature that separates it from a plain sheet is the 1.8-inch raised rim — that lip catches grease, crumbs and sauce instead of letting them run into the basket and bake onto the mesh.
The use cases the brand leans into are exactly where that rim pays off: teriyaki chicken, honey garlic wings, gooey cheese pizza, roasted vegetables, reheating cold takeout so it comes back crispy, and movie-night fries and nuggets. It's also positioned as fitting major air fryer brands in the 5–8QT range, and as a gift for people who host a lot and hate the cleanup afterward.
Who should buy it? Anyone whose air fryer is the most-used appliance in the kitchen and who wants to toss the liner and be done — no soaking, scrubbing or scraping. Who should skip it? If you bake cakes, use springform pans or regularly run your oven above 428°F, the lower heat ceiling and square rimmed shape make Numola the more flexible pick.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for maximum heat tolerance → Numola Parchment Paper Sheets (450°F / 230°C versus 428°F / 220°C).
• Best for greasy, saucy air fryer food → Apenkes 200, because the 1.8-inch raised rim contains the mess instead of letting it reach the basket.
• Best for sheet count per pack → Apenkes 200 with 200 liners versus Numola's 100.
• Best for thickness and tear resistance → Numola Parchment Paper Sheets, stated at 1.2 times thicker than ordinary parchment.
• Best for 5–8QT air fryer baskets → Apenkes 200, sized square at 8x8 inches for those models.
• Best for non-cooking uses → Numola, which also works as wrap, freezer paper and basket liner paper.
• Best for frozen pizza rolls and similar snacks → it depends on your priority: Numola if you want the thicker, higher-heat sheet under a full basket; Apenkes 200 if you want the rim to catch the grease and crumbs those rolls throw off.
For frozen pizza rolls specifically — the greasy, crumb-shedding kind that leave a basket looking like a crime scene — I'd buy the Apenkes 200. The 1.8-inch raised rim is doing real work there, and 200 liners means I'm not rationing them. That said, if you bake as much as you air fry, or you want the higher 450°F ceiling and the thicker unbleached sheet, I'd go Numola instead and accept that it's flat. In my opinion the Apenkes 200 is the better fit for a snack-heavy air fryer household, and Numola is the better fit for a kitchen that does everything.
Air fryer times vary by model and by how full the basket is, so follow the package directions as your starting point. What matters for liners is heat tolerance: Numola is rated to 450°F (230°C) and Apenkes 200 to 428°F (220°C), so both handle typical pizza roll temperatures — just don't exceed the ceiling of whichever liner you use.
How to air fry frozen pizza rolls?
Same rule applies — use the package timing for your air fryer and check partway through, since pepperoni rolls are denser than small pizza rolls. Neither liner changes cook time; they only change cleanup, and both are rated for the temperatures these snacks need.
They're built for different jobs, so compare by use rather than by pack size alone. Apenkes gives you 200 square 5–8QT basket liners with a rim; Numola gives you 100 thicker unbleached 8-inch sheets rated to a higher heat and usable across ovens and bakeware. Check the current price on Amazon for each and match it to how you actually cook.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Beasea Parchment Paper Sheets vs WMKGG Disposable Air Fryer, BYKITCHEN 9 vs SMARTAKE 200: Air Fryer Bread, ALJ Air Fryer Rubber vs GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper: Air Fryer