How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want one box of unbleached parchment sheets that fits quarter sheet pans, small baking trays, toaster ovens and most air fryer baskets, choose Beasea Parchment Paper Sheets; if you need pre-perforated liners cut to fit the Ninja Foodi XL Smart 6-in-1 / 4-quart indoor grill with air fryer (FG551, BG500A) and you want a reusable grilling mat in the box too, choose WMKGG Disposable Air Fryer.
• Beasea's biggest strength: 200 pre-cut 10x14-inch unbleached sheets at 42gsm, oven-safe to 428°F, and sized for small-to-medium trays, quarter sheet pans, air fryers and toaster ovens with no trimming.
• Beasea's biggest trade-off: no holes punched in the paper, so airflow around food is not engineered the way a perforated liner is — and you place food on the sheet rather than letting it sit over direct heat.
• WMKGG's biggest strength: perforated liners designed specifically for the Foodi XL Smart 6-in-1 / 4-quart indoor grill with air fryer (FG551, BG500A), plus a reusable black grilling mat in the pack.
• WMKGG's biggest trade-off: a narrower fit. 7.7" x 11.7" liners are built around one family of appliances, and the paper must never go in during pre-heat or touch the heating tube.
• Pick Beasea if you cook across several appliances and want a general-purpose liner.
• Pick WMKGG if your air fryer is the Foodi XL Smart 6-in-1 / 4-quart and you want holes doing the airflow work for you.
Beasea's pitch is simple: 200 sheets, already cut to 10x14 inches. That measurement matters more than it sounds. It lands right on a quarter sheet pan and on the trays inside a lot of small and medium air fryers and toaster ovens, which means the trimming step disappears. You pull a sheet, drop it in, cook, then lift the whole thing out and bin it. The tray underneath stays clean. I like that for anyone who roasts vegetables, bakes cookies, or reheats messy food several times a week and is tired of soaking pans.
The paper itself is unbleached, 42gsm, and rated to 428°F (220°C). That's a heavy-enough sheet that it resists tearing when you're sliding a chicken breast or a pile of chopped veg onto it, and it's meant to hold up without curling at the edges under normal oven and air fryer heat. Beasea's own tip is worth repeating: keep food on top of the paper rather than letting a bare sheet sit exposed to direct heat, and don't push it past its temperature rating.
WMKGG Disposable Air Fryer: Who It's For
WMKGG takes the opposite approach: fit one appliance really well. These 100 liners are 7.7" x 11.7" and the brand states they're designed exclusively for the Ninja Foodi XL Smart 6-in-1, 4-quart indoor grill with air fryer — model numbers FG551 and BG500A. If that's your machine, the sizing question is already answered for you. (Those brand names belong to their respective owners; WMKGG has no affiliation with or endorsement from them.)
The interesting design choice is the perforation. The liner is punched with holes in a pattern WMKGG describes as deliberate, so heat and steam can circulate up through the paper and reach food from all directions instead of only from the top. For anyone who's ever lined a basket with a solid sheet and noticed the underside of the food cooking unevenly, that's the feature to care about. The paper is double-coated with silicone on the food side and rated from -68°F up to 425°F, which keeps grease and sticky residue off the basket and rack.
You also get a reusable black grilling mat in the pack, which protects the bottom of the basket, rack or pan from residue and can be washed and used again. That's a genuinely useful pairing: disposable liner for the messy cooks, reusable mat for everything else.
The cautions are not optional reading. Don't put the paper in during pre-heat. Keep it under the food. Never let it touch the heating tube, because the tube runs far hotter than the paper's rating. Skip this one if your air fryer isn't in that model family, or if you'd rather have one liner size that works everywhere in your kitchen.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for frozen pizza rolls and other quick, greasy air fryer snacks → WMKGG. The perforated design lets heat reach food from multiple directions, which suits a basket full of small items that need even crisping.
• Best for baking and roasting across several appliances → Beasea. 10x14 inches covers quarter sheet pans, small trays, toaster ovens and many air fryer baskets.
• Best for exact fit on a Foodi XL Smart 6-in-1 / 4-quart (FG551, BG500A) → WMKGG. The liners are built for those models.
• Best for heat ceiling → Beasea, at 428°F versus WMKGG's 425°F — a small margin, but the higher number is the higher number.
• Best for airflow around the food → WMKGG. The holes are the whole point.
• Best for getting a reusable accessory too → WMKGG, which includes the black grilling mat.
• Best for cleanup simplicity → a tie. Both are designed so you lift the liner out and the basket or tray stays clean.
In my opinion, the deciding question isn't which paper is "better" — it's what your air fryer is and how you cook. If you own the Foodi XL Smart 6-in-1 / 4-quart (FG551 or BG500A), I'd buy WMKGG. The liners are cut for that machine, the holes are designed to push heat around the food instead of trapping it, and the reusable mat earns its place in the drawer. If your kitchen has more than one appliance, or you bake and roast as much as you air fry, I'd buy Beasea: 200 sheets at a size that fits quarter sheet pans and small trays is the more flexible box, and unbleached 42gsm paper rated to 428°F covers nearly everything you'll throw at it. Both are good; they just solve different problems. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
FAQ
how to air fry frozen pizza rolls
Spread them in a single layer so hot air can move between them. If you're using WMKGG liners, the perforations are designed to let heat circulate up from below, which helps the bottoms crisp instead of steaming. With Beasea sheets, keep the rolls on top of the paper and don't crowd the basket.
how long to air fry frozen pizza rolls
how long to air fry frozen pepperoni rolls
Same principle: single layer, shake once, check early and often. Because pepperoni rolls are thicker than small pizza rolls, expect the middle to need more time than the outside suggests. If you're lining with parchment, remember to keep food on the paper and never let it touch the heating element.
how long to air fry frozen totino's pizza rolls
Totino's is a brand name for a specific product, so use the package's air fryer directions as your baseline and adjust to your machine. The WMKGG caution applies here too: don't run the liner during pre-heat, and keep the paper weighted down by food so it can't lift into the heating tube.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GSSKIME Air Fryer Paper vs HOYDATE 2-Pack: Air Fryer, chengziyue 6QT vs Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners: Air Fryer, GXF Air Fryer Cooking vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement