Tucker Beerman (Highlands) 2011
Forrest Schmitt (Grant County) 2012
Eddie Hoffa (Walton-Verona) 2013
Blake Schneider (Scott) 2014
Griffin Lamb (Covington Catholic) 2016
Charlie Wend (Conner) 2015
Tyrus Sciarra (Ryle) 2011
Evan Talkers (Covington Catholic) 2011
Austin Johnson (Grant County) 2014
Conner Harper* (Pendleton County) 2017, 2018
Ruben Rechtin (Beechwood) 2019
*Scored multiple goals in 3 straight games on 2 separate occasions in the 2017 season and 2 separate occasions in the 2018 season.