Rich Wagner (Covington Catholic) 1987
Ryan Holloway (Ludlow) 1988
Greg Kleiman (St. Henry) 1992
Paul Grosser (Newport Central Catholic) 2014
Tony Spaulding (Holy Cross) 1990
Mitchell Jacobs* (Covington Catholic) 2011
Chris Brashear (Conner) 2014
Thomas Cody (Covington Catholic) 2016
Will Burnham (Highlands) 2018
Cody Sullivan (Pendleton County) 2018
Brian Locklear (Simon Kenton) 1990
Andrew Maitre (Boone County) 1990
Bill Krahel (Highlands) 1993
Nathan Turner (Pendleton County) 1991
Andy Hart (Campbell County) 1993
Cory Kearns (Grant County) 2008, 2010
Jacob Farwell (Pendleton County) 2011
Jordan Kearns (Grant County) 2013
C.J. Seay (Scott) 2014
Will Burnham (Highlands) 2018
*Had 2 separate 4-game-long shutout streaks during the 2011 season