Cross-frequency coupling in the brain dynamics: Causality vs. lead-lag relationship
Milan Palus
Cross-frequency coupling in the brain dynamics: Causality vs. lead-lag relationship
Milan Palus
Abstract
Cross-frequency coupling (CFC) has recently attracted a lot of attention in neuroscience, since it enriches the cooperative behavior of neuronal networks and apparently plays an important functional role in neuronal computation, communication, and learning. A number of methods to detect CFC have been proposed and criticaly evaluated , however, aprroaches for inferring its directionality are just beening developed. We compare cross-frequency directionality (CFD), based on the phase slope index (PSI) with the conditional mutual information (CMI) known also as transfer entropy. The two methods give contradictory results when applied to intracranial EEG data from an animal experiment. We explain this contradiction using simulated data from unidirectionally coupled nonlinear oscillators and demonstrate that, in nonlinear systems, the lead-lag relationship is not equivalent to causality or the direction of coupling.