Supects & Theories

SUspects & suspicious people in kem's life

Official Suspects

Jeremy Garth Anderson (Jerry) - Sister's Boyfriend

• He was out on bond at the time of her disappearance.
• Son of a Walton County sheriff deputy
• Link to his Arrest Record: https://mugshots.com/US-Counties/Florida/Walton-County-FL/Jeremy-Garth-Anderson.6681424.html?fbclid=IwAR2OYn9F9BRzcLaouZM7cTXtMQdTEYHukZgW9Kv-bMDP1P9KPiGxqScayKU
• Supposedly stole/borrowed a truck the night of her disappearance.
• Does not have an alibi during the night/morning hours
• Refused to take a polygraph
• He is from the 850 area where the 3 phone calls were made to.

Suspicious People in her Life

Secret Boyfriend (name withheld)

• He was in his 20s at the time
• He was divorced with young children
• He was the last person who is confirmed to have seen her.
• Had an alibi and was cleared by the FBI

Deidre (last name withheld)

• was supposed to hang out with Kem on Saturday
• rumored to have gone with Kem to a party on the night she went missing

theories in Kem's case

Primary Theory

• Kem left her boyfriend's house on the night of August 15, 1997. She made it home around 11:30 pm or a little after.
• She gets ready for bed, taking out her contacts and settling in her room.
• She is taken from her bedroom that night by somebody she knew.
  • There was no sign of forced entry into the home so it was possibly someone she let in or someone who had a key to the house.
  • Kem puts up a fight but is ultimately taken or killed there and never seen again.
• Whoever takes her disposes of her body in South Alabama or North Florida.

Other Important Information

• It is possible that Kem attended a local party after she left her boyfriend's house. This was not confirmed by law enforcement at the time.
• Jerry Anderson supposedly stole/borrowed a truck that night and then showed up at a friend's house early the next morning asking someone to help him get rid of the truck. He parks it at a local church and leaves it.