How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a reusable set you can wipe clean and use again and again, choose LEKAYIHU 3; if you need a big stack of disposable liners you can toss after one messy cook, choose ailifeer 150PCS.
• LEKAYIHU 3 biggest strength: three reusable 8.5" square silicone liners in one pack — non-stick, rinse-and-reuse, and sized for square baskets.
• LEKAYIHU 3 biggest trade-off: you have to wash them, and the 8.5" square shape won't suit small round 2Qt–3Qt baskets.
• ailifeer 150PCS biggest strength: 150 disposable round paper liners at 6.3" — zero washing, just bin it after cooking.
• ailifeer 150PCS biggest trade-off: single-use by design, and it comes with real usage rules (never preheat with the paper alone, don't underfill the basket).
• Who LEKAYIHU 3 is for: everyday cooks with a mid-to-large square air fryer who hate repurchasing supplies and don't mind a quick rinse.
• Who ailifeer 150PCS is for: small-basket owners, batch cooks, campers and party hosts who want the fastest possible cleanup.
The LEKAYIHU 3 is a three-pack of 8.5" x 8.5" reusable square silicone liners, sold in red, grey and black. The pitch is simple: a non-stick silicone sheet sits in your air fryer basket, food releases cleanly, and cleanup is a wipe or a rinse rather than a scrub. Because silicone is reusable and durable, you're buying three items that are meant to keep working, not a consumable you restock.
The shape is the part that matters most. Square liners are built for square and rectangular baskets — the kind found on many mid-size and larger air fryers. If your basket is square-ish, an 8.5" liner drops in and covers a good chunk of the base, which is exactly what you want when you're doing quick meals: nuggets, veg, reheated leftovers, small bakes. The non-stick surface and heat-conducting property are there to keep food from welding itself to the basket and to help things cook through evenly.
Who should buy it? Anyone who cooks in an air fryer several times a week and is tired of buying paper inserts. Three liners means one can be in use, one clean, one drying — a rotation that covers most households. Who should skip it? If you own a small round 2Qt–3Qt basket, an 8.5" square sheet is the wrong geometry and will either bunch up or sit awkwardly. Skip it too if you genuinely never want to wash anything — reusable means reusable, and that means a rinse.
The ailifeer 150PCS is a different philosophy entirely: 150 round disposable liners made from food-grade silicone oil paper (unbleached parchment), each with a 6.3" base, a 1.77" high wavy edge, and a stated heat resistance up to 428°F. It's built for 2Qt to 5Qt small air fryers — the listing calls out COSORI, Cuisinart, Chefman, Nuwave, Philips and Ninja as examples of compatible baskets.
The wavy 1.8" edge is the clever bit. It's there to stop oil and food from splashing against the basket walls and heating element, which is why the brand frames it as a way to protect the fryer and cut down on cleaning. And because the paper is oil-proof and waterproof, you can use it for frying, baking and steaming, plus microwaves, ovens and steamers — not just the air fryer. That makes the 150-count useful beyond the kitchen: camping trips, potlucks, birthday parties, daily baking.
The operation is as simple as it gets: take one out, no tearing or cutting, put food on it, cook, throw it away. No washing, no soaking, no scrubbing the basket. Who should buy it? Small-basket owners who cook greasy or sticky food often, anyone who hosts, and people who value zero cleanup over everything else. Who should skip it? If you hate the idea of ongoing consumable purchases, or you own a large square basket, this 6.3" round liner is the wrong size class.
One honest caveat from the specs: this liner has rules. Never preheat the air fryer with the paper alone inside — it's light and can be blown onto the heating element. After preheating, add food first. And don't underfill the basket, for the same reason. Follow that and it behaves; ignore it and you risk a scorched sheet.
• Best for zero cleanup → ailifeer 150PCS. Cook, eat, bin the liner. No washing at all.
• Best for long-term value and less waste → LEKAYIHU 3. Three reusable silicone liners replace hundreds of throwaway sheets over time.
• Best for small 2Qt–5Qt round baskets → ailifeer 150PCS. The 6.3" round base is matched to that size class.
• Best for large or square baskets → LEKAYIHU 3. The 8.5" x 8.5" square footprint suits square and rectangular baskets.
• Best for greasy, sticky, sauce-heavy food → ailifeer 150PCS. The 1.77" wavy edge catches splatter and you throw the mess away.
• Best for eco-conscious daily cooking → LEKAYIHU 3. Reusable and durable by design, so less goes in the bin.
• Best for camping, parties and potlucks → ailifeer 150PCS. 150 disposable sheets plus microwave/oven/steamer use make it the portable, shareable option.
• Best for people who hate buying supplies → LEKAYIHU 3. Buy three, use them for the long haul.
In my opinion, most people cooking in a standard mid-size square air fryer are better served by the LEKAYIHU 3. Three reusable silicone liners do the same job as a paper insert — non-stick, easy release, fast cleanup — without turning into a recurring purchase, and the 8.5" square size is the more forgiving fit for the baskets most households actually own. I'd only steer you to the ailifeer 150PCS if your air fryer is a small round 2Qt–5Qt basket, or if you truly value tossing the mess in the bin over rinsing a liner. Match the shape to your basket first; that single decision matters more than anything else here.
How to use air fryer silicone liners
Drop the liner flat into the basket, then place food on top of it — don't preheat with an empty liner sitting in there. For the LEKAYIHU 3, the 8.5" square silicone sheet goes straight in and food releases cleanly off the non-stick surface. For the ailifeer 150PCS, take one 6.3" round paper liner out, no tearing or cutting, add food, and cook.
How to clean air fryer silicone liner
The LEKAYIHU 3 is the reusable one: a quick wipe or rinse is all the spec calls for, thanks to the non-stick silicone surface. The ailifeer 150PCS isn't cleaned at all — it's disposable, so you throw it away after cooking. That's the core trade-off between these two: rinse and reuse versus bin and replace.
How to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
A baking soda paste is a common household approach for stubborn residue on silicone, and it's fine for a reusable liner like the LEKAYIHU 3 — the spec only requires a wipe or rinse for normal use. Note that this doesn't apply to the ailifeer 150PCS, which is single-use paper and gets discarded, not scrubbed.
The ailifeer 150PCS is rated heat resistant up to 428°F and the brand advises not exceeding 30 minutes above that temperature. The real risk isn't normal cooking — it's putting the lightweight paper in alone during preheat or with too little food, which can let hot air blow it onto the heating element. Always add food before cooking.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Mistifi Air Fryer Silicone vs LEKAYIHU 3: Air Fryer Silicone, Zayookey 2 vs LA LECHLEY 2: Air Fryer Silicone Liner, BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer vs WEBROIL 2