How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Mistifi's biggest strength: A true basket-style liner — 8.5 x 7.7 x 2.6 inches with a 2.6-inch depth, raised bottom ridges for airflow and grease drainage, and dual side handles. It's rated heat resistant up to 482°F and comes as a 2-piece set.
• Mistifi's biggest trade-off: Only 2 pieces per pack and a rectangular 8.5 x 7.7 footprint, so it won't square up perfectly in every basket.
• LEKAYIHU 3's biggest strength: A 3-pack of 8.5 x 8.5-inch square liners in three colors (red, grey, black), with a 3-count unit and two included brushes — a lot of coverage for batch cooking or keeping spares on rotation.
• LEKAYIHU 3's biggest trade-off: The sheet is flat and shallow (no listed depth, no handles), and the sheet lists the material as plastic rather than silicone, with no stated heat-resistance figure.
• Pick Mistifi if you want one sturdy, deep, handle-equipped liner for saucy or greasy foods.
• Pick LEKAYIHU 3 if you want maximum pieces per purchase and don't mind a flatter, simpler liner.
The Mistifi liner is the more engineered of the two. The spec sheet describes a food-grade silicone liner measuring 8.5 x 7.7 inches with a 2.6-inch depth — that depth is the whole story. A liner that's 2.6 inches tall behaves like a shallow pot, not a sheet, so it holds juices, oil, marinade and crumbly toppings instead of letting them run out across your air fryer basket. If you cook chicken thighs, salmon, or anything glazed, that's the difference between a five-minute rinse and a twenty-minute scrub.
The raised lines across the bottom are the second detail worth calling out. They lift food slightly off the base, which does two things: it lets rendered fat drain away from what you're cooking, and it leaves gaps for hot air to move underneath. Even browning on the underside is one of the hardest things to get in a basket-style air fryer, and a ridged floor is a reasonable design answer to it. The side handles matter too — you can lift the whole liner out and tip food straight onto a plate instead of fishing around with tongs.
Heat resistance is listed at up to 482°F, and the material is described as non-stick, BPA-free, odorless and tasteless. It's dishwasher safe, and because it's soft silicone you can turn it inside out to push residue out. The brand also pitches it as a replacement for disposable parchment, and lists it as usable in microwaves, steamers, ovens and Instant Pots, not just air fryers.
Who should buy it: Anyone with a 5.8 to 8 QT air fryer who cooks wet, messy or greasy food and wants one liner they can lift out by the handles. Also a good fit if you already own a steamer or microwave and want one accessory that travels between appliances.
LEKAYIHU 3: Who It's For
The LEKAYIHU 3 pack takes the opposite approach: more pieces, less structure. You get three 8.5 x 8.5-inch square liners in red, grey and black — one per color — plus two brushes in the box. The 8.5-inch square footprint is the more common air fryer basket shape, so if your basket is square rather than rectangular, this is the geometry that actually matches it.
The pitch here is speed and convenience. The liners are described as non-stick with easy food release, cleanable with a quick wipe or rinse, reusable and durable. There's a "quick meal helper" angle built into the copy — the idea being that the liner's heat-conducting surface gets food cooked fast and the cleanup is trivial afterward.
The trade-offs are real, though. There's no listed depth, which means these read as flat sheets rather than baskets — fine for fries, nuggets, vegetables and anything dry, less ideal for saucy food that will simply pool and spread. There are no handles, so you're lifting a hot, floppy sheet out of a hot basket by its edges. And the product information lists the material type as plastic, not silicone, with no heat-resistance temperature stated anywhere on the sheet. That's the single biggest thing to verify before you buy, because a liner that isn't rated for air fryer temperatures is a different product category entirely.
Who should buy it: Anyone who wants three liners so they can cook back-to-back without washing, likes having color-coded liners, or wants a spare set to keep at a second location. Good for dry, quick foods.
Who should skip it: If you cook wet or greasy food, need a deep liner, or want handles for safe removal, this isn't the shape for you. And if a stated heat rating matters to you, note that Mistifi publishes one and LEKAYIHU doesn't.
• Best for saucy, greasy or marinated food → Mistifi Air Fryer Silicone. The 2.6-inch depth and ridges contain liquid and drain fat; a flat sheet can't.
• Best for dry foods like fries, nuggets and veggies → LEKAYIHU 3. A flat non-stick sheet is all you need, and you get three of them.
• Best for square baskets → LEKAYIHU 3. The 8.5 x 8.5-inch square matches square baskets more closely than Mistifi's 8.5 x 7.7-inch rectangle.
• Best for safe, easy removal → Mistifi Air Fryer Silicone. Two side handles beat pinching a floppy sheet's corners.
• Best for backup liners and batch cooking → LEKAYIHU 3. Three liners and two brushes means less mid-session washing.
• Best for documented heat tolerance → Mistifi Air Fryer Silicone. A stated 482°F ceiling versus no stated figure at all.
• Best for appliance flexibility → Mistifi Air Fryer Silicone. Listed for air fryers, microwaves, ovens, steamers and Instant Pots.
• Best for color variety → LEKAYIHU 3. Red, grey and black in one purchase.
In my opinion, the Mistifi Air Fryer Silicone is the one I'd buy. The 2.6-inch depth, the ridged floor and the side handles solve the three problems that actually make air fryer cleanup annoying — pooling liquid, uneven browning and burning your fingers on removal. It's also the only one of the two with a published heat-resistance rating, which I consider non-negotiable for something sitting inside a hot appliance.
The LEKAYIHU 3 pack is a reasonable pick if you just want cheap, plentiful liners for dry food and you've confirmed the material and heat rating on the listing itself. But between the two, Mistifi is the more complete tool.
FAQ
how to clean air fryer silicone liner
how to use air fryer silicone liners
Set the liner flat in your air fryer basket, then put food on top of it — never preheat with an empty liner sitting in the basket, since there's nothing to absorb the heat. Keep food in a single layer so air can still circulate, and use the side handles (on the Mistifi) or the edges (on the flat LEKAYIHU sheets) to lift it out once it's cool.
how to use air fryer silicone liners ninja
The principle is the same on any brand: drop the liner into the basket, add food in one layer, and cook as normal. Match the liner size to your basket — Mistifi's 8.5 x 7.7-inch liner suits 5.8 to 8 QT air fryers, while LEKAYIHU's 8.5-inch square suits most standard square baskets. If your Ninja basket is unusually deep or narrow, measure before ordering.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
Make a paste from baking soda and a little water, rub it onto stained or greasy spots, and let it sit for a few minutes before rinsing with warm water. It's a gentle option for the non-stick silicone surface on the Mistifi liner and won't scratch it. Follow with a normal soap wash if any residue remains.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: ZIP STANDING Reusable Silicone Air vs Komzon Silicone Air Fryer, LA LECHLEY 2 vs redamey Silicone Air Fryer: Reusable Air, Mistifi Oil Sprayer vs P&P CHEF 7.9: Air Fryer Vegetables