How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer — biggest strength: Food-grade silicone liners sized for the 10QT Ninja SL401 DoubleStack, with perforations front and back so air still flows and food still crisps.
• BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: It is a liner, not a cooking surface. It only helps if you own one of the compatible dual-basket models, and it does nothing for a grill grate.
• WEBROIL 2 — biggest strength: A two-pack of stainless steel splatter shields cut to follow the contours of the Ninja IG651/IG600/IG601 Foodi Smart XL Pro indoor grill.
• WEBROIL 2 — biggest trade-off: It is a grease shield, not a basket liner. It will not hold food, catch crumbs, or fit a dual-basket air fryer.
• Bottom line: BYKITCHEN is for air-fryer owners who hate scrubbing baskets. WEBROIL 2 is for indoor-grill owners who hate wiping down the whole counter.
The BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer is a two-pack of rectangular silicone liners made specifically for the Ninja SL401 DoubleStack 10QT. That last detail matters more than anything else here. Generic liners get shoved into a basket and leave gaps; these are shaped for the dual-basket layout, so they sit where they're supposed to. They also fit other dual models in the Ninja family, including the DZ201, DZ401 and DZ550, which is useful if you own more than one machine or plan to upgrade.
What I like about the design is the perforation. A lot of people line their air fryer with foil or paper and then wonder why the food comes out pale and soggy. These liners have holes punched through both the front and back, so the fan can still push hot air around the food and the bottom of your chicken wings still gets some contact heat. You get the cleanup benefit of a liner without fully blocking the airflow your fryer depends on.
Who should buy it: anyone with a Ninja SL401 or a comparable dual-basket air fryer who is tired of scrubbing baked-on grease out of the basket, and anyone who wants a liner that survives more than one meal. Who should skip it: if you own a single-basket air fryer, a toaster-oven-style air fryer, or an indoor grill, this is simply the wrong shape for your appliance, and no amount of good silicone will fix that.
WEBROIL 2: Who It's For
WEBROIL 2 solves a completely different problem. It's a two-pack of stainless steel splatter shields made for the Ninja Foodi IG651, IG600 and IG601 Smart XL Pro 7-in-1 indoor grill. If you've ever seared a steak or grilled burgers indoors, you already know the issue: fat hits the hot surface, pops, and the next twenty minutes of your life belong to the countertop, the backsplash and the floor.
A shield like this sits between the food and the rest of your kitchen. Because it's stainless steel rather than a mesh or a thin screen, it holds its shape and doesn't warp or tear when it takes repeated heat. That durability is the whole argument for the material. The spec sheet also notes that the shield can help with heat dissipation around the grill, which means it isn't purely a barrier — it's designed to work with the cooking process rather than against it.
Cleaning is where the design details show up. The edges and overall size are shaped to follow the contours of the grill, and the surface is smooth enough that grease doesn't grab onto it. Wipe it with a damp cloth and you're mostly done. For anyone who grills indoors several times a week, that's a meaningful difference from scrubbing a textured grate or chiseling carbon off a tray.
Each shield measures 8.46" L x 6" W, made of high-quality stainless steel, and the pack gives you two. Who should buy it: owners of the Ninja IG651, IG600 or IG601 who grill indoors and want less mess and less cleanup. Who should skip it: if you don't own one of those grill models, or if your appliance is a basket-style air fryer, this product has no job to do in your kitchen.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for containing grill splatter → WEBROIL 2. A liner can't stop a steak from popping fat across your counter; a stainless shield can.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer. It's explicitly dishwasher safe; the WEBROIL 2 is designed for a quick damp-cloth wipe.
• Best for high heat with metal durability → WEBROIL 2. Stainless steel keeps its physical properties in a hot grill environment.
• Best for airflow during air frying → BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer. The front and back perforations are there so hot air still circulates.
• Best for multi-appliance flexibility → BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer. It's built for the SL401 but also fits the DZ201, DZ401 and DZ550.
• Best for a two-piece setup from day one → both. Each product ships as a two-pack, so you have a spare or a second zone covered.
• Best match to your actual appliance → whichever one fits it. Compatibility decides this comparison, not preference.
If I had to pick one, I'd pick based on the appliance on my counter, because these two products don't compete for the same job. For a Ninja SL401 DoubleStack, I'd buy the BYKITCHEN Silicone Air Fryer — the perforated, 450°F-rated, dishwasher-safe design turns a tedious basket-scrubbing chore into a ten-second rinse, and it's reusable instead of disposable. If I owned an IG651, IG600 or IG601 indoor grill, I'd buy WEBROIL 2 without hesitating, because stainless steel and a contoured fit are the right answer to splatter. Owning both makes sense if you own both appliances. Neither is a substitute for the other.
FAQ
No — that's the design's whole point. It has perforations in both the front and back so hot air still moves around the food and cooking stays even. It catches grease and crumbs without capping the basket.
Only if your appliance is a Ninja Foodi IG651, IG600 or IG601 Smart XL Pro 7-in-1 indoor grill. It's a splatter shield for that grill line, not a basket accessory, so it won't fit a dual-basket air fryer. Match it to your model before buying.
They're durable in different ways. The BYKITCHEN liners are flexible silicone rated to 450°F and built to be washed and reused. The WEBROIL 2 is stainless steel chosen for strength and toughness under sustained grill heat. Both are meant to last — just for different appliances.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: BYKITCHEN 220pcs vs Atchake 120Pcs: Air Fryer Cheese Sticks, CyHiThai 3.7QT vs Tizee Silicone Roasting Rack: Air Fryer, INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone vs Mkzruulf 6"x6: Air Fryer