Federal Court
The Federal Court is the highest court in Malaysia and the final court of appeal. Its decisions set binding precedents for all lower courts and are also binding on itself.
Composition:
The Federal Court, established under Article 121(2) of the Federal Constitution, consists of:
• The Chief Justice of the Federal Court,
• The President of the Court of Appeal,
• The Chief Judges of the High Courts (Malaya and Sabah/Sarawak), and
• Four other judges.
Additional judges may be appointed under Clause (1A), making a total of seven Federal Court judges currently.
Court of Appeal
The Court of Appeal is the second-highest court in Malaysia, functioning solely as an appellate court.
Key Features:
• Jurisdiction:
• Criminal Appeals: Reviews High Court decisions, including cases from the Sessions Court handled by the High Court.
• Civil Appeals: Handles cases involving claims of at least RM250,000.
• Leadership: Headed by the President of the Court of Appeal and presided over by a panel of at least three judges.
Powers:
• Rehearses appealed cases and can:
• Confirm, reverse, or modify High Court decisions.
• Order a retrial.
• Refer cases back to the trial court with guidance.
• Issue any order deemed just, including exercising the trial court’s powers.
• May summarily dismiss appeals.
The Court ensures justice by thoroughly reviewing decisions from lower courts.
High Court
The High Courts in Malaysia consist of the High Court of Malaya and the High Court of Sabah and Sarawak, led by two chief judges. They are superior courts with original, appellate, and supervisory jurisdiction.
Key Features of the High Court:
• Original Jurisdiction: Unlimited authority in civil and criminal cases, including cases from lower courts involving matters in Malaysia or businesses operating locally. Criminal cases can only proceed if the accused is committed for trial after a Magistrate’s Court hearing.
• Appellate Jurisdiction: Hears appeals from Magistrates’ and Sessions Courts in civil and criminal matters.
• Supervisory Jurisdiction: Can inspect records of lower courts, transfer cases, or issue directives for justice.
The High Court’s decisions are binding on lower courts but not on itself. Lower courts are bound by the decisions of superior courts but do not bind other courts. The High Court is divided into:
1. Commercial Division
2. Civil Division
3. Criminal Division
4. Appellate Division.