In the Name of God! Religiosity and the Production of Science
with Jeanet Sinding Bentzen (UCPH)
Revise and Resubmit, Review of Economic Studies
We examine the role played by religion for the emergence of modern science. To do so, we develop novel measures of religiosity based on arguments in psychology and sociology that given names reveal parents' cultural identity. Across multiple data sources, we confirm that first names reflect name-giver's religiosity in samples of individuals born in Europe between 1300 and 1940. Individuals with religious names are more likely to study theology, to hold religious occupations, to be born after earthquakes and in areas that other sources define as religious. Next, we document that individuals with religious names were less inclined to become scientists or engineers, and that areas with higher frequencies of religious names have fewer patents per capita. Our evidence suggests that the religiosity–science gap is driven by religious individuals selecting out of scientific careers, rather than selecting in religious ones. The religiosity–science gap widens precisely when and where the tension between religion and science intensified. Exploiting within grid-cell and birth-year comparisons, family links, and exogenous shocks to religiosity, we find no support for alternative explanations such as crowding out, Protestant-Catholic-Jewish differences, parental preferences for tradition or conformity, birth-order effects, name-changing, or parental social status. The results further our understanding of the role of religion for scientific development.
Paper