How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• KAWENDE 5 — biggest strength: five PTFE-coated fiberglass liners cut to rest on the crumb tray, so drips and crumbs land on the liner instead of the tray, and cleanup is a wipe or a rinse rather than a scrape.
• KAWENDE 5 — biggest trade-off: it is a fit-specific accessory, not a universal one. It is designed around the crumb trays of Cuisinart TOA-60/TOA-65/TOA-70 air fryer toaster ovens, and it is hand wash only.
• Luxshiny 12pcs — biggest strength: twelve food-grade silicone bumpers that soften contact points, reduce tray rattle and protect corners from scratches, with a universal-fit claim that lets them stand in for worn or missing feet.
• Luxshiny 12pcs — biggest trade-off: they are tiny. At roughly 1.18 x 0.59 x 0.31 inches each, they are consumable little parts — easy to lose, easy to misplace — and they do nothing about grease or crumbs.
• Who KAWENDE 5 is for: owners of a Cuisinart TOA-60/TOA-65/TOA-70 who are tired of scrubbing the crumb tray.
• Who Luxshiny 12pcs is for: anyone chasing a wobble, a rattle or a scratched tray before it becomes a bigger repair.
KAWENDE 5 is a maintenance product for one specific family of appliances. If you own a Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 or TOA-70 air fryer toaster oven, you already know the weak point: the crumb tray sits at the bottom, catches everything that falls, and slowly collects a layer of polymerized grease that no sponge wants to touch. These five liners rest directly on that tray. Grease drips, crumbs and food residue land on the liner instead of the metal, and because the surface is non-stick PTFE fiberglass, you wipe it with a cloth or rinse it under the tap instead of scraping.
The second benefit is less obvious but worth more over time. A liner creates a protective layer between hot oil and the original tray finish, which means the tray you cannot replace easily stays in better condition for longer. That is the real argument for buying a five-pack rather than one: you can rotate them, let one soak while another is in service, and still have spares when one finally gives out.
Luxshiny 12pcs: Who It's For
Luxshiny 12pcs solves a completely different problem: mechanical wear at the contact points. These are small black silicone bumpers — the manufacturer lists them at 1.18 inches wide, 0.59 inches deep and 0.31 inches high — made from food-grade silicone and described as non-scratch and high-temperature resistant. If your air fryer tray rattles when the fan spins up, if a grill pan slides when you pull the basket out, or if a corner has started scratching the surface it rests on, these are the cheap fix. They soften impacts, which is exactly the kind of small failure that otherwise leads to a tray being replaced outright.
The twelve-piece count is the point. These bumpers are genuinely tiny, and tiny parts vanish — down a drain, into a drawer, into the vacuum. A set of twelve means you can lose a few and still cover every corner of a tray or pan, or split them across two appliances. The universal-fit claim is the manufacturer's, not a promise that they will snap perfectly onto your specific model, so measure your existing feet or contact points before you order.
There is one specification worth flagging plainly: the product information lists an output wattage and a wattage of 1 watt and a capacity of 1 centiliter. Those fields appear to be automated listing artifacts rather than a description of what these bumpers do — silicone corner protectors are not powered devices and hold no meaningful volume. I would not read anything into them.
What Luxshiny 12pcs will not do is keep your oven clean. There is no grease barrier here, no liner, no crumb capture. It is a hardware fix, not a hygiene product.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for keeping the crumb tray clean → KAWENDE 5. The liners sit on the tray and intercept drips and crumbs before they bake on.
• Best for protecting the original tray's finish → KAWENDE 5. The liner adds a protective layer that reduces direct contact with oils and residue.
• Best when you don't know your exact model → Luxshiny 12pcs. Universal-fit silicone bumpers are far more forgiving than a liner cut for specific Cuisinart crumb trays.
• Best for high-heat cooking → Luxshiny 12pcs. Food-grade silicone handles intense cooking temperatures; the PTFE liner is capped around 450–480°F, so keep it below that.
• Best for low-effort cleanup → KAWENDE 5. Wipe or rinse, no scraping — but hand wash only, so no dishwasher.
• Best for owners of a Cuisinart TOA-60/TOA-65/TOA-70 → KAWENDE 5. That is precisely the fit it was designed for.
• Best for spares you'll actually use up → Luxshiny 12pcs. Twelve small parts means you can replace worn bumpers as they fail, one corner at a time.
I would buy KAWENDE 5 — but only if I owned a Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 or TOA-70. The whole value of that product is fit and function: five liners that land on the crumb tray, catch the mess, and turn a scrub job into a rinse. The heat ceiling is a real limitation and the hand-wash requirement is mildly annoying, but neither outweighs the daily benefit. If I did not own one of those models, or if my actual complaint was a rattling tray rather than a dirty one, I would buy Luxshiny 12pcs instead and treat it as the small, cheap hardware fix it is. Check the current price on Amazon and decide which problem you actually have.
Only reliably with Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 air fryer toaster ovens — it is designed to rest on those crumb trays. For other brands and models, fit is not guaranteed.
The manufacturer describes them as universal-fit and compatible with various air fryers and small appliance parts. That is a broad claim rather than a per-model guarantee, so measure your existing feet before ordering.
Hand wash is recommended. The non-stick PTFE surface wipes clean or rinses easily, so a quick hand wash is usually enough.
The KAWENDE 5 liner is capped at 480°F per the manufacturer's warning, with a listed 450°F maximum temperature setting — cook below that. The Luxshiny bumpers are food-grade silicone described as high-temperature resistant for intense cooking.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Furnsii 12Pcs vs VICASKY Air Fryer Tray: Air Fryer Safety, Luxshiny 3pcs vs Ciieeo Air Fryer Accessory: Air Fryer, Luxshiny 1000pcs vs LYHOLKEER Loaf Pan Liners: Air Fryer