How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Furnsii 12Pcs biggest strength: A silicone buckle with a magnetic core that pins parchment liners flat against a metal basket, so lightweight paper can't curl up toward the heating element.
• Furnsii 12Pcs biggest trade-off: It only works on air fryers with a magnetic metal basket — if a regular magnet won't stick to your basket, this set has nothing to grip.
• VICASKY Air Fryer Tray biggest strength: A 30-piece set of small silicone bumpers that cushion trays, crisper plates and grill pans against impact and scratching, with plenty of spares.
• VICASKY Air Fryer Tray biggest trade-off: It does nothing about loose parchment liners — it's a tray and pan protector, not a liner-locking device.
• Choose Furnsii 12Pcs if: You cook with disposable parchment liners and want to stop them flying up or touching the element.
• Choose VICASKY Air Fryer Tray if: You use metal trays, crisper plates or grill pans and want to cut down scratching, rattling and edge damage.
Furnsii 12Pcs is a 12-count set of small rectangular silicone buckles in red, each built around a magnet core. The idea is simple: you lay a parchment liner in the basket, then use the buckles to hold the paper down flat. The silicone is food-grade and, per the manufacturer, rated to withstand temperatures up to 570°F without deforming or losing magnetic strength. That matters because the failure mode with liners isn't the paper tearing — it's the paper drifting upward mid-cook, folding over your food, or reaching the heating element. A liner pinned at the edge can't do any of that, and airflow through the basket stays unobstructed.
Who should skip it? Anyone whose air fryer has a non-magnetic basket — ceramic-coated, coated plastic, or some glass and non-ferrous designs. Furnsii's own guidance is to test whether a plain magnet sticks to your basket before buying, and that's the single most important compatibility check for this product. If your basket fails that test, no amount of clever design helps. People who never use parchment liners also don't need this; if you cook directly in the basket or use a silicone liner you already own, the buckles solve a problem you don't have. And if your concern is a rattling metal tray rather than a flying sheet of paper, this is the wrong category of accessory entirely.
VICASKY Air Fryer Tray: Who It's For
VICASKY Air Fryer Tray is a 30-piece set of black silicone bumpers — small protective tips measuring roughly 0.79 by 0.79 by 0.59 inches each. Think of them as replacement feet and corner cushions for your air fryer tray, crisper plate or grill pan. They slot onto edges and corners and act as a buffer, so the tray isn't grinding directly against the fryer walls or the basket when you slide it in and out. The stated benefit is protection against impact and abrasion: less scratching on your pan, less scratching on the interior of the fryer, and less of that metal-on-metal clatter that comes with a loose tray.
The material is silicone, chosen for high-temperature resistance and for being easy to detach and clean. Because the set is 30 pieces, it's built around the reality that these little bumpers are the kind of thing you lose, wear out, or want to share across more than one tray or appliance. VICASKY markets the fit as universal, so the same bumpers are meant to work across a range of air fryer models and grill pans rather than being tied to one brand.
This is a maintenance and protection accessory, and it's worth being clear about that. It will not secure parchment paper. It won't stop a liner from lifting into the heating element. If that's your worry, this set is irrelevant no matter how many pieces you get. It's also not a cooking surface or a liner itself — it doesn't change how food cooks, only how your tray wears. Skip it if your air fryer tray is integrated, unremovable, or already sits snugly without rattling. Buy it if you use a removable crisper plate or grill pan daily and you're tired of scratched edges, chipped coatings and noisy tray movement. The 30-count quantity is the real selling point: it's a consumable spares kit, not a one-time fix.
• Best for loose parchment liners → Furnsii 12Pcs. It's purpose-built to pin paper flat and keep it off the heating element.
• Best for scratched or rattling trays → VICASKY Air Fryer Tray. Silicone bumpers cushion tray edges against impact and abrasion.
• Best for high-heat reassurance → Furnsii 12Pcs. Furnsii states a 570°F silicone rating and a magnetic core that holds strength through heat cycles.
• Best for sheer quantity of spares → VICASKY Air Fryer Tray. Thirty bumpers versus twelve buckles; the VICASKY set is designed to be replaced and shared.
• Best for multi-model flexibility → VICASKY Air Fryer Tray. Universal bumpers fit a wide range of trays and pans; Furnsii needs a magnetic metal basket specifically.
• Best for easy cleanup → Furnsii 12Pcs. Wipe-clean, dishwasher-safe silicone that resists grease and stains.
• Best for people who use neither — skip both. If you don't use parchment liners and your tray doesn't rattle, neither accessory earns its place in your drawer.
• Best if you're unsure → check your basket with a fridge magnet. It sticks: consider Furnsii. It doesn't: Furnsii isn't an option, and VICASKY covers the tray-protection side instead.
In my opinion, most people searching "air fryer safety" are worried about the liner problem, and for that, Furnsii 12Pcs is the more directly useful buy. It targets a real, specific hazard — parchment drifting into the heating element — with a design made for exactly that job, and the magnetic, wipe-clean format is easy to live with. I'd only reach for VICASKY Air Fryer Tray if my actual complaint is a noisy, scratched crisper plate rather than a flying liner. They're not competitors so much as two answers to two different questions. Pick the one that matches the problem you keep having.
FAQ
Furnsii 12Pcs. It's designed to lock disposable liners flat so they can't lift, fold over food, or reach the heating element. VICASKY Air Fryer Tray doesn't address liners at all — it's a tray and pan protector.
Not usually. They solve different problems — liner security versus tray protection — so most people only need the one that matches their issue. Buying both makes sense only if you use parchment liners and want to protect a removable crisper plate.
Identify the failure you actually experience. Liner curling up or burning? Choose Furnsii 12Pcs. Tray rattling, slipping or scratching the fryer walls? Choose VICASKY Air Fryer Tray. Then check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Hoqqf Air Fryer Tray vs Garneck 3pcs: Air Fryer Cooking, KEESHA 100SG100 vs SOKHOND Tray Liners: Air Fryer Crumb Tray, lasuroa 12pcs vs ZOWXDI Air Fryer Magnets: Air Fryer Cooking