A review of a resourceful teaching tool!

~Provide a brief overview of how the technology works and its potential educational applications.

Dollar Street, created by Gapminder, is a unique online platform that uses photos as data to visually represent how people live at different income levels around the world. It organizes families and their belongings along a virtual "street" ordered by income, from the poorest on one end to the richest on the other.  

Here's a breakdown of its functionality:

• Photo-Based Data: Instead of relying solely on statistics, Dollar Street showcases everyday life through thousands of photographs of homes, possessions (like beds, toothbrushes, kitchens), and family members from hundreds of families across numerous countries.  

• Income Ordering: The core concept is to arrange these photos based on the families' approximate monthly income per adult equivalent, adjusted for purchasing power parity (PPP) to allow for meaningful comparisons across different countries with varying costs of living.  

• Visual Comparison: Users can easily browse the "street" and visually compare how people live at different income levels. They can filter by country, income level, or even specific objects to see how these vary across the income spectrum.  

• Family Stories: Each featured family has a brief profile providing context about their lives and income.

Potential Educational Applications:

Dollar Street offers a powerful and engaging way to explore various educational topics across different grade levels and subjects:  

• Social Studies/Global Citizenship:

  • Understanding Socioeconomic Diversity: Helps students visualize the vast range of living conditions globally and within countries, moving beyond stereotypes and fostering empathy.  

  • Challenging Misconceptions: Addresses common misconceptions about the "developed" and "developing" world by showing a more nuanced and continuous spectrum of income and living standards.  

  • Exploring Culture and Daily Life: Provides insights into the daily routines, possessions, and living spaces of families in different cultural contexts.

  • Analyzing Inequality: Offers a visual representation of income inequality and its potential impact on people's lives.  

  • Promoting Global Awareness: Encourages students to think critically about global issues and their interconnectedness.

• Economics:

  • Understanding Income and Poverty: Provides a tangible understanding of different income levels and what they might mean in terms of access to resources.  

  • Exploring Consumption Patterns: Allows students to observe how spending priorities and the types of goods people own vary with income.

  • Discussing Economic Development: Can be used to illustrate the challenges and progress in improving living standards in different parts of the world.

• Geography:

  • Connecting Income and Location: While income is the primary organizing principle, students can still observe some regional patterns in housing, infrastructure, and access to resources.

• Mathematics/Data Literacy:

  • Visualizing Data: Presents data in a visual and accessible format, helping students understand the concept of income distribution.  

  • Comparing and Contrasting: Encourages students to make observations and draw comparisons based on visual data.  

• Language Arts:

  • Developing Descriptive Skills: Students can describe the homes and possessions they see.  

  • Fostering Empathy and Perspective-Taking: Reading family stories can help students understand different life experiences.  

In summary, Dollar Street leverages the power of visual data to provide a relatable and impactful understanding of global socioeconomic diversity. Its free accessibility and intuitive interface make it a valuable tool for educators seeking to engage students with real-world issues and foster a more nuanced and empathetic worldview.

~Discuss the impact of this technology in the classroom—how does it change the way students learn? Does it improve engagement, collaboration, or understanding? (Think SAMR)

Dollar Street, as an educational technology, can significantly impact classroom learning and engagement across the SAMR (Substitution, Augmentation, Modification, Redefinition) model:

Substitution:

• Traditional: Students might read text descriptions of living conditions in different countries or look at static images in a textbook.

• Dollar Street: Students can directly view photographs of homes and belongings on Dollar Street instead of relying solely on text or limited textbook images.
  1  

• 1. Website Review: GapMinder and Dollar Street - Literary Fusions

• literaryfusions.com

• Impact: Technology acts as a direct replacement for traditional media. Engagement might be slightly improved due to the visual nature, but the core task of observing different living conditions remains the same.

Augmentation:

• Traditional: Teachers might show a slideshow of diverse homes with brief captions.

• Dollar Street: Students can actively navigate the Dollar Street website, filter by income or country, and zoom in on specific details in the photographs. They can also read the brief family stories associated with each home.

• Impact: Technology enhances the traditional task by providing more control to the student, offering a wider range of visual information, and adding contextual details through family stories. This can improve engagement and initial understanding by allowing for more personalized exploration.

Modification:

• Traditional: Students might compare and contrast the living conditions of two pre-selected countries based on provided information.

• Dollar Street: Students can design their own comparative studies, selecting countries and income levels to investigate specific questions (e.g., "How does access to clean water change with income in different regions?"). They can collect visual evidence (saving or noting specific photos) and analyze patterns across a wider range of examples. They might create presentations or reports using the visual data they gathered.

• Impact: Technology allows for a significant redesign of the task. Students become more active researchers, formulating their own questions and using the visual data to support their analysis. This fosters deeper understanding, critical thinking, and potentially collaboration as students discuss their findings.

Redefinition:

• Traditional: Students might write a report on global poverty based on secondary research.

• Dollar Street: Students can connect directly with classrooms in other countries (if feasible and ethically sound) and use Dollar Street as a shared visual language to discuss their own living conditions and compare them to others at similar or different income levels. They could collaboratively curate a "global classroom Dollar Street" focusing on specific themes, fostering cross-cultural understanding and empathy in ways previously impossible. They could also use Dollar Street as a springboard for creating interactive presentations or virtual tours that offer a unique and visually rich perspective on global socioeconomic realities for a wider audience.

• Impact: Technology enables the creation of new tasks that were previously inconceivable. Dollar Street can facilitate authentic global connections and collaborative projects that promote deeper empathy, understanding of diverse perspectives, and digital storytelling.

Overall Impact:

Dollar Street has the potential to significantly impact student learning and engagement by:

• Improving Understanding: The visual nature of the data makes abstract concepts like income inequality and global living standards more tangible and relatable, leading to deeper and more intuitive understanding.

• Increasing Engagement: The interactive platform and compelling photographs can capture student interest and encourage active exploration and discovery.

• Fostering Collaboration: The platform can serve as a shared resource for group discussions, comparative studies, and collaborative projects.

• Developing Empathy and Global Citizenship: By providing a window into the lives of people around the world, Dollar Street can help students develop empathy, challenge stereotypes, and cultivate a more informed and nuanced global perspective.

By moving through the levels of the SAMR model, educators can progressively leverage the unique capabilities of Dollar Street to transform learning experiences from simple substitution to the creation of entirely new and impactful educational opportunities.

~What are some perceived barriers to implementing this technology? Does it require additional teacher training, specific resources, or infrastructure? (Think SECTIONS)

While Dollar Street offers significant educational potential, several perceived barriers can hinder its widespread implementation in the classroom, analyzed through the SECTIONS framework:

S - Students:

• Digital Access and Equity: While Dollar Street is free online, consistent and reliable internet access and suitable devices (computers, tablets) for all students can be a significant barrier, particularly in lower-income communities or schools with limited infrastructure. This can exacerbate existing digital divides.

• Digital Literacy Skills: Students need basic digital literacy skills to navigate the website, use filters, and interpret the visual information. Some students may require initial support and guidance.

• Emotional Impact: Viewing the living conditions of families in extreme poverty might evoke strong emotions in some students. Teachers need to be prepared to address these feelings sensitively and provide appropriate support.

E - Ease of Use:

• Teacher Familiarity: While the Dollar Street interface is generally intuitive, teachers need time to explore the platform, understand its features, and develop effective pedagogical strategies for its use. Lack of familiarity can lead to reluctance in implementation.

• Time for Integration: Integrating Dollar Street meaningfully into existing curriculum requires planning and time for teachers to adapt lessons and activities. This can be a challenge given packed teaching schedules.

• Technical Issues: Although the platform is generally stable, occasional technical glitches or website downtime could disrupt lessons.

C - Cost:

• Financial Cost (Indirect): Dollar Street itself is free, but the indirect costs associated with its use can be a barrier. These include the cost of reliable internet access, sufficient devices for students, and potentially professional development for teachers.

• Time Cost (Teacher Preparation): As mentioned under "Ease of Use," the time teachers need to invest in learning the platform and designing effective lessons is a significant cost factor.

T - Teaching Functions:

• Alignment with Curriculum: Teachers need to carefully consider how Dollar Street aligns with specific learning objectives and curriculum outcomes. While versatile, it might not directly fit into every topic.

• Guiding Student Inquiry: The open-ended nature of Dollar Street requires teachers to effectively guide student exploration and ensure they are focusing on relevant aspects and developing deeper understanding rather than just passively browsing images.

• Assessment Challenges: Developing appropriate assessment methods that leverage the unique visual and comparative aspects of Dollar Street might require some creativity and effort.

I - Interactivity:

• Level of Direct Manipulation: While students can navigate and filter, the primary interaction is visual exploration rather than direct manipulation of variables as in some simulations. Teachers need to design activities that encourage active engagement beyond simply viewing images.

O - Organizational Issues:

• Infrastructure Readiness: Schools need adequate internet bandwidth and a sufficient number of devices to support classroom use of Dollar Street, especially if aiming for individual or small group exploration.

• Scheduling and Logistics: Planning time for students to access and effectively use the platform within the constraints of the school day can be a logistical challenge.

• Support and Training: Schools need to provide teachers with adequate technical support and professional development opportunities to effectively integrate Dollar Street into their teaching practices.

N - Networking/Novelty:

• Sustaining Engagement: While the novelty of the visual approach can initially be engaging, teachers need to design varied and purposeful activities to maintain student interest over time and ensure the technology is used for meaningful learning rather than just as a visual break.

S - Security/Privacy:

• Data Privacy: Dollar Street primarily uses photographs of homes and belongings. While aiming to avoid sensitive personal information, teachers should be mindful of the images students are viewing and guide discussions in a respectful and ethical manner.

• Website Reliability: As a free online resource, there is a potential (though likely low) risk of the website becoming unavailable in the future. Teachers should consider this and potentially curate key images or resources if planning long-term use.

In conclusion, while Dollar Street offers a powerful and free tool for global education, successful implementation requires addressing potential barriers related to digital equity, teacher preparedness, curriculum integration, and organizational readiness. Thoughtful planning, adequate resources, and ongoing teacher support are crucial for maximizing the educational impact of this innovative technology.

~How might you integrate this technology into your own teaching practice? What are some lesson ideas or activities you’d like to try? (Include two educational scenarios with curriculum connections and explanations on how you would see the tool being used. You may want to look at the citation resource from this mornings discussion?

Integrating Dollar Street into my teaching practice holds exciting possibilities for fostering global awareness, empathy, and critical thinking across various subjects. Here are two educational scenarios with curriculum connections and explanations of how I would envision using the tool:

Scenario 1: Grade 6 Social Studies - Global Communities (Connecting to Saskatchewan Curriculum)

• Curriculum Connection (Saskatchewan Social Studies 6): Analyze the ways in which people in diverse communities meet their basic needs (e.g., food, shelter, clothing, education, health care).

Lesson Idea: "A Roof Over Our Heads: Comparing Homes Around the World"
Activity:

• • 1. Introduction (15 minutes): Begin with a class discussion about what constitutes a "home" and the different types of homes students are familiar with in their own community. Introduce the concept that homes look very different around the world due to various factors like climate, culture, and economic resources.

    2. Exploring Dollar Street (30 minutes): Introduce Dollar Street (projecting it on the board and guiding navigation). Focus students on the "Homes" category. Divide the class into small groups and assign each group a specific income range (e.g., $50-$100/adult equivalent per month, $500-$1000, $2000-$3000). Instruct each group to explore homes within their assigned income range from at least three different countries (encouraging a mix of continents).

    3. Data Gathering (20 minutes): Provide each group with a simple observation sheet. They should look for similarities and differences in:

       • Building materials used.

       • Size and layout of the home (as visible in photos).

       • Features present (e.g., running water, electricity, separate rooms).

       • The surrounding environment.

       • Note any initial impressions or questions that arise.

    4. Sharing and Discussion (20 minutes): Each group shares their observations with the class, focusing on the variety of homes within their income range and across different countries. Facilitate a class discussion using questions like:

       • What surprised you about the homes you saw?

       • What basic needs seem to be met in different ways at different income levels?

       • How might the type of home a family lives in affect other aspects of their lives (e.g., health, education)?

       • What does this tell us about the diversity of global communities?

    5. Wrap-up (5 minutes): Briefly revisit the essential question about meeting basic needs, emphasizing that "shelter" takes many forms and is influenced by a complex interplay of factors.

How Dollar Street is Used: Dollar Street provides the primary visual data for students to directly observe and compare homes across different income levels and geographical locations. The income-based organization allows students to see patterns and variations related to economic resources. The variety of countries showcased broadens their understanding of global diversity.

SAMR Connection: This scenario primarily operates at the Augmentation and Modification levels. It augments traditional textbook images by providing a much wider and more diverse range of visual examples that students can actively explore. It moves towards modification by allowing students to conduct their own comparative investigations based on self-selected countries and income levels, rather than being limited to pre-determined examples.

Scenario 2: Grade 9 Geography - Global Inequalities and Development (Connecting to Saskatchewan Curriculum)

• Curriculum Connection (Saskatchewan Geography 9): Analyze spatial patterns of disparities in human development (e.g., income, health, education) at local to global scales, and the factors contributing to these disparities.

Lesson Idea: "Visualizing the Development Gap: Access to Resources"
Activity:

• • 1. Introduction (10 minutes): Review the concept of human development indicators (e.g., income, health, education). Discuss how these indicators can vary significantly across the globe, highlighting the issue of global inequality.

    2. Focusing on Specific Resources (15 minutes): As a class, brainstorm essential resources that impact human development (e.g., access to clean water, sanitation, healthcare, technology, education materials). Choose 2-3 of these resources to focus on.

    3. Guided Exploration on Dollar Street (30 minutes): Introduce Dollar Street and guide students to explore specific categories related to the chosen resources (e.g., "Toilets," "Water," "School"). Instruct students to compare the visual representation of access to these resources for families at very low income levels versus families at higher income levels, both within the same country and across different countries.

    4. Evidence Collection and Analysis (25 minutes): Provide students with a structured observation sheet where they can record:

       • The income level of the families they are observing.

       • Visual descriptions of their access to the chosen resources.

       • Inferences they can make about the potential impact of this level of access on health, education, and overall well-being.

       • Identify any patterns they observe related to income and access to resources.

    5. Group Discussion and Synthesis (15 minutes): Facilitate a group discussion where students share their observations and analysis. Guide them to connect the visual evidence from Dollar Street to the broader concept of global inequalities in human development. Discuss the factors that might contribute to these disparities.

How Dollar Street is Used: Dollar Street provides a powerful visual representation of the disparities in access to essential resources at different income levels globally. By focusing on specific categories, students can directly observe the tangible differences in living conditions and the realities of global inequality.

SAMR Connection: This scenario moves towards the Modification and potentially Redefinition levels. It modifies the traditional approach of learning about development indicators through statistics by providing a direct visual and comparative experience. Students are actively analyzing spatial patterns of disparities based on the visual data they collect. If students were to then use this visual evidence to create a compelling visual presentation or campaign to raise awareness about specific development issues (potentially sharing it online and connecting with others), it could move towards redefinition by creating a new task that leverages the unique visual communication power of Dollar Street for a wider impact.

By integrating Dollar Street in these ways, I aim to move beyond passive learning and empower students to become active observers, critical thinkers, and empathetic global citizens. The visual and comparative nature of the tool offers a unique and engaging way to connect with complex social and geographical concepts, fostering deeper understanding and a more nuanced perspective on the world.

Resources:

https://www.gapminder.org/dollar-street?

https://gemini.google.com/app