Social variation in language refers to the differences in language use within a social group that are not related to linguistic differences. These variations are influenced by several factors such as social class, region, education level, societal norms, and cultural background. However, social variation is closely related to sociolinguistics.
According to Britannica, sociolinguistics is the study of the sociological aspects of language. The discipline concerns itself with the part language plays in maintaining the social roles in a community.
Sociolinguistics has evolved from early studies of dialects and the functional aspects of language to a comprehensive field that examines the intricate relationships between language, society, and power. According to Theory of The History of Sociolinguistics, Sociolinguistics was first used by Athanasius Selishev in the 1920s and was developed by Uriel Weinreich and William Labov in the 1950s and 1970s. However, William Labov is considered as the father of sociolinguistics due to his huge contributions in this field of study.
The main purpose of sociolinguistics is to study how society use language and how language change in the society affect language development. Choices of sounds, grammatical elements and vocabulary may be influenced by factors such as age, sex, education, occupation, race and social class.
‘Overt’ means open to view or observable. Overt Prestige means putting on or using an accent that is widely recognized as being used by the culturally dominant group in the community. We can also say that Overt Prestige is the dialect of people from higher social class either middle class or upper class. For example, in England this would be putting on a ‘posher’ accent where the 'a' sound may be elongated to sound more like 'ah' to fit in the dominant group.
The usage of overt prestige shows the divided social class in a community. Overt prestige is often associated with dialect or language of the people from higher classes. Overt prestige has become a standard in a formal setting. This indicates that Overt Prestige may be used in education, law and government. These days, as we can see, most of the education systems all around the world use Overt Prestige as their standard language. The usage of Overt Prestige is also widely recognized as it is standardized or seen as the proper way to speak to other people. For example, upon asking a stranger for directions, we will ask using Overt Prestige without realizing it as it is the politest way to ask for something from someone that we are not associated with.
‘Covert’ means concealed or secret. Covert Prestige is the opposite of Overt Prestige. It means to use an accent that shows membership of a particular community in that area rather than to fit in with the dominant group of the community. It is usually used by people from lower social classes such as working class, working poor and underclass. Using language or dialect associated with local community will lead to earning respect from people in the same community.
Covert prestige is often used in a community whereby people of a particular social group lives in. Covert Prestige is often associated with working class or working poor class or even underclass. Their use of language and dialect has become their own identity, and the usage of Covert prestige is a sign of membership in a particular social group. Unlike Overt Prestige, Covert prestige is not widely recognized by all parts of society. However, it maintains the identity of that group as their way of talking is not used by any other people.
The following video is an interview between Piers Morgan and Bassem Youssef regarding the mass genocide that is happening in Palestine. In the video, we can see that Bassem is using both Overt and Covert prestige. Bassem uses Overt Prestige while addressing the seriousness of the issue. By engaging in a serious topic, he appeals to a broad audience, demonstrating a form of language that is widely accepted. The use of Overt Prestige in this situation is critical as Bassem will surely want everyone watching the interview to understand the important points that he is addressing. However, he changes to Covert prestige right after he responds to a comment made by Ben Shapiro and Ron DeSantis which stated that “Israel is the only military force that warns civilian before bombing them”. His respond to the comment is ‘If Russia warns Ukraine before bombing them then we are cool with Putin, right?”. As we know, what Bassem said is Covert Prestige as he is using a language that is associated with non-standard varieties. By using Covert Prestige in this situation, Bassem is also able to use humor in addressing important points, even though not everyone will understand his points in the form of humor because he is aligning with a specific group instead of a universal group.
The heated interview between Youssef and Piers Morgan took place in October 2023, the same month that the mass genocide happens in Palestine. The interview's platform was on Piers’s famous YouTube show “Piers Morgan Uncensored’. At first, Bassem uses Overt Prestige as he respects Piers and the show, he also uses Overt Prestige to appeal to a wider range of audience. However, during responding to Ben Shapiro’s and Ron DeSantis’s comment on Israel, Bassem decides to use Covert Prestige in that moment to defend Palestine and using humor to make fun of their ridiculous comment.
According to IMDB, Bassem Youssef is an Egyptian cardiac surgeon, satirist, and the host of El Bernameg ("The Program"), a satirical news program broad casted by Egyptian television station Capital Broadcast Center (CBC). The press has compared Youssef with American comedian Jon Stewart, whose satire program The Daily Show inspired Youssef to begin his career. As reported by Harvard Kennedy School, the B+ show started as a 5-minute show on YouTube in 2011, gaining five million views in only three months. Nine webisodes later, Egyptian channel ONTV offered Youssef to create a weekly political satire TV show "Al-Bernameg". Al-Bernameg received wide acclaim around the world with coverage in some of the biggest media outlets.
Bassem Youssef who has been interviewed in a formal setting by Piers Morgan uses Overt Prestige to appeal to broader audience. However, while talking to Piers, he decided to change to Covert Prestige in the middle of the interview. He uses a way of talking that is known to align with a social group. The way he talked is interesting as he is brave enough to shift between Overt to Covert prestige in a formal setting, despite the pressure from being interviewed on a live show and is seen by millions on YouTube. He also appeared to use inappropriate words to counter the comments from Ben Shapiro and Ron DeSantis. This shows how we can shift between Overt and Covert Prestige based on the social context that we are facing.
In my opinion, Bassem did a good job in using both Overt and Covert prestige because he uses them in two different situations. He showed a good example of when to use both prestige. This will help us to use these prestige correctly in many different situations based on who we are talking to whether they are upper class or lower class. While both Overt and Covert prestige is mainly used because of other person’s status, we should also consider changing the prestige based on the context that we are facing. In this case, Bassem shift the usage of prestige to stand his ground against the disrespectful comment regarding the mass genocide in Palestine.
To conclude everything that has been stated, social variation in language demonstrates how factors like social class, education, and culture shape the way people speak. Sociolinguistics studies these variations to understand how language operates within society. Grasping these concepts helps us see how language changes across different social groups and contexts. Recognizing when to use Overt or Covert Prestige can enhance our communication, making it more effective and suitable for various situations. This awareness promotes better and more inclusive interactions in diverse social settings.
Definition:
The Editors of Encyclopedia Britannica. (2008). Sociolinguistics. In Encyclopædia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/science/sociolinguistics
Background:
Xamidullaevna, X. N. (2021). Theory of the history of sociolinguistics. Central Asian Journal of Literature, Philosophy, and Culture, 2(6), 29-31.
Fishman, J. A. (1971). Sociolinguistics
Concept:
. W Labov. (1972). Sociolinguistic patterns. University Of Pennsylvania.
Wardhaugh, R., & Fuller, J. M. (2021). An Introduction to Sociolinguistics (8th ed.). John Wiley & Sons.
Labov, W. (2006). The social stratification of English in New York City. Cambridge University Press.
Real world example:
Middle East Eye. (2023, October 18). Bassem Youssef’s viral Interview with Piers Morgan on Palestinian suffering. YouTube. https://youtu.be/221-eNg_sZI?si=DO4_s8nvGULzAiNR
Background of real world example:
Bassem Youssef - Biography. (n.d.). IMDb. Retrieved June 15, 2024, from https://www.imdb.com/name/nm5117997/bio/?ref_=nm_ov_bio_sm
Bassem Youssef | The Institute of Politics at Harvard University. (n.d.). Iop.harvard.edu. https://iop.harvard.edu/fellows/bassem-youssef