What is the good game? What is the meaning of Gaming Competition? This is the fundamental proposition to prove. Imagine there are two games. One is Banking Simulation, another one is gender equalization. Both of the aspects are respectable. it is not a story that which one is better than another. So, we don't evaluate the theme itself. We tried to develop a rubric to evaluate simulation and gaming. However, it is obvious that baby game includes a lot of errors, contradictions, and setting . It is a nature of Gaming Simulation that to make a better game, to repeat trials and improvements in a long range. What we should do in ISGC is not to find faults, but to show suggestions to improve. Future possibility is the target of award. Thus, we apply the simple policy as below.
1) Simulation
The link between teaching objective and the game as the output must be matched.
2) Playability
It is common mistake, try to reflect the truth of the target like a mirror. Such game tend to become complexed. While remaining important ideas, but to wrap or cut-off branches. Any game must have physical limit and time period.
3) Creativity
The reviewer compare the games to find the advantages. Saying in the different way, we believe diamonds are hidden in much information.