How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• INFRAOVENS biggest strength: Pre-cut 8.7 x 8.7 inch unbleached parchment squares sized for the Ninja Air Fryer Pro XL 6-in-1 6.5 qt (AF181) — flat, natural paper that won't leave a metal taste, plus a reusable fiberglass grill mat in the box.
• INFRAOVENS biggest trade-off: Flat sheets do nothing to contain liquid or runny batter, and the perforated paper is a single-use item, so you're reaching for a new sheet every cook.
• Tonmom biggest strength: A square bowl shape with a 4.5 cm raised edge, made from two layers — food-grade aluminum foil inside, parchment outside — for full oil and water resistance and no tearing, folding or cutting.
• Tonmom biggest trade-off: At 6.3 x 6.3 inches it's a smaller footprint, and the foil-lined construction is a disposable one-and-done product with no reusable piece.
• Pick INFRAOVENS if you own a large square-basket air fryer and mostly roast, bake or reheat foods that don't release much liquid.
• Pick Tonmom if you cook sticky, saucy or marinated dishes and want the liner to act like a shallow bowl inside the basket.
INFRAOVENS is the pick for anyone whose air fryer basket has a specific shape and size to match. The sheets are 8.7 x 8.7 inches, square, and explicitly built around the Ninja Air Fryer Pro XL 6-in-1 6.5 qt (AF181). That's the whole appeal: you pull one sheet out of the pack, drop it in, and the basket is covered. No trimming, no curling corners, no paper flapping up into the heating element. With 100 sheets in the set, you're set for a long run of everyday cooking.
The material choice matters here too. The paper is natural and unbleached rather than foil-backed, which means no metal taste transferring into your food — a real difference if you've ever pulled foil-wrapped leftovers out of a hot oven. INFRAOVENS also includes a food-grade, PFOA-free fiberglass reusable liner in the box, and that piece is where the set gets interesting. It's dishwasher safe and designed for the foods that would wreck plain paper: sticky marinades, wet batters, anything that soaks straight through a thin sheet. It also doubles as a barrier to keep residue off the bottom of your tray.
So who should skip it? Anyone with a small round basket, for starters — 8.7 inch squares are simply too big and you'll be folding them down, which defeats the point. And if your go-to meals are saucy stir-fries or marinated wings sitting in a pool of liquid, flat parchment won't hold any of that. The juices will run off the edge and onto the basket, and you're back to scrubbing. This set is at its best with roasting, baking, and reheating — meats, vegetables, pizza, dumplings, wings, cakes, cookies, brownies — where the mess is residue rather than volume.
Tonmom takes the opposite approach: instead of a flat sheet, each liner is a square bowl with a 4.5 cm raised edge. That rim is the entire design story. It catches drips at the sides of the basket, keeps food from touching the metal walls, and — most importantly — gives liquid somewhere to go. If you cook with marinades, wet rubs, or anything that releases fat as it heats, this is the shape that actually contains it.
The construction is two layers: food-grade aluminum foil on the inside, parchment paper on the outside. Tonmom states the foil layer is heat resistant up to 600°C and won't easily deform, and the double-layer build makes the liner noticeably thicker than a single sheet. The foil is also what makes it fully oil and water resistant — nothing soaks through, so food residue stays in the liner and out of your basket. The brand also notes the material is chlorine free and food safe.
Ease of use is the other selling point. There's nothing to tear, fold, cut or bend — you take one out, set it in, and cook. The 100-piece pack is all disposable, so there's no reusable mat to wash and keep track of; you just toss the liner when you're done. Tonmom also lists it as suitable for air fryers, microwaves, ovens, steamers and cookers, for baking, roasting, frying and serving, which makes it a decent all-purpose liner to keep in a drawer.
The trade-off is size and disposability. At 6.3 x 6.3 inches, these are meaningfully smaller than the INFRAOVENS squares — great for compact and mid-size square baskets, less ideal if you're trying to cover a large one. And because there's no reusable component, every single cook consumes a liner. If you're running the air fryer twice a day, that 100-pack has a clock on it.
• Best for a large square basket (Ninja Air Fryer Pro XL 6.5 qt AF181) → INFRAOVENS. The 8.7 x 8.7 inch sheets are cut to fit it.
• Best for saucy, oily or marinated food → Tonmom. The 4.5 cm raised edge and foil layer hold liquid that flat paper can't.
• Best for no-fuss setup → Tonmom. Square bowl shape, ready to drop in — nothing to fold, cut or bend.
• Best for food with no metal taste → INFRAOVENS. Unbleached parchment instead of an aluminum foil surface.
• Best for a reusable option in the box → INFRAOVENS. The set includes a PFOA-free fiberglass grill mat that's dishwasher safe.
• Best for small to mid-size square baskets → Tonmom. The 6.3 inch footprint suits compact air fryers better than a large square sheet.
• Best for multi-appliance use → Tonmom. Tonmom lists air fryer, microwave, oven, steamer and cooker compatibility.
• Best for a single-purchase, disposable-only routine → Tonmom. No mat to wash, no sheets to store flat — just grab and toss.
• Best for baking and roasting dry-ish foods → INFRAOVENS. Cakes, cookies, brownies, pizza and vegetables are squarely in its lane.
In my opinion, the deciding question is what you actually cook. If you own a large square-basket air fryer and your meals are mostly roasted vegetables, wings, pizza and baked goods, I'd buy the INFRAOVENS Parchment Paper Sheets — the exact 8.7 x 8.7 inch fit is the thing you'll notice every single day, and the included reusable fiberglass mat covers you for the sticky exceptions. If your cooking leans saucy, marinated or greasy, I'd buy the Tonmom Air Fryer Liners instead: that raised 4.5 cm edge and foil-and-parchment build do a job flat paper simply can't, and the drop-in bowl shape removes every bit of fiddling. Neither is universally better — they solve different problems. Match the liner to your messiest recipe and you'll be happy with either.
Not better — different. Tonmom's foil-and-parchment bowl shape is oil and water resistant and holds liquid inside a 4.5 cm raised edge. INFRAOVENS parchment is a flat unbleached sheet with no metal taste and a reusable fiberglass mat included. Which wins depends on whether your food is wet or dry.
Will INFRAOVENS parchment paper sheets fit my air fryer?
They're 8.7 x 8.7 inches, square, and made for the Ninja Air Fryer Pro XL 6-in-1 6.5 qt AF181. If your basket is a similar large square, they'll sit flat. If your basket is small or round, the sheets will be oversized for it.
Both sets contain 100 liners. The Tonmom liners are disposable — foil-lined and designed to be tossed after use. The INFRAOVENS set is 100 disposable parchment sheets plus one reusable, dishwasher-safe fiberglass grill mat.
Both are built to keep grease and residue off the basket. Tonmom has the edge with wet or oily food because the foil layer is fully oil and water resistant and the raised edge traps drips. INFRAOVENS handles dry residue and crumbs well, but liquid will run off a flat sheet. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: katbite Air Fryer Liners vs uxcell Round Parchment Paper, air fryer sheets liners, SMARTAKE Parchment Paper Roll vs YJWYDM Air Fryer Disposable