How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
If I had to pick one for most Ninja Foodi grill owners, it's the Criditpid Non-Stick Grill Grate — it's the only pick here that pairs a reusable ceramic-coated grate with a stainless splatter shield and a hundred disposable liners, so it covers cooking and cleanup in one box.
• Criditpid Non-Stick Grill Grate — best for Ninja Foodi indoor grill owners who want reusable parts plus disposable liners; pick this if you cook steaks, fish or other meats and want a ceramic non-stick grate, a 304 stainless splatter shield and 100 square paper liners in a single kit.
• Generic Air Fryer Sheets — best for round-basket air fryers and everyday baking; pick this if you want 50 pre-shaped aluminum foil liners with a raised rim in a 23.5 cm size that also fits ovens, microwaves and toaster ovens.
• Cabilock 50sheets — best for large flat trays and oven-style cooking; pick this if you need generous 30 x 30 cm square foil sheets for chicken wings, chips, bread and snacks on a bigger cooking surface.
• GLOGLOW 5 — best for saucy, messy foods and batch cooking; pick this if you want five sturdy square foil pans with high edges that hold juices in and go straight from air fryer to oven or grill.
This is a kit rather than a single liner, and that's exactly why I rank it first. You get three things: a 10" x 10 1/8" non-stick grill grate with a ceramic coating, an 8 1/2" x 8 7/16" splatter shield in food-grade 304 stainless steel, and 100 square unbleached heavy-duty paper liners. The grate and shield are reusable; the paper liners are disposable.
The compatibility list is unusually specific, and that matters more than anything else here. Criditpid states this kit fits Ninja AG300, AG300C, AG301, AG301C, AG302, AG400, IG301A, IG302Q, IG350Q, LG450CCO and LG450CO Foodi Indoor Electric Grills. If you own one of those models, you're the target buyer. If you own a different air fryer, this isn't for you — and I'd rather say that plainly than let you order the wrong thing.
In daily use, the splatter shield is the underrated piece. Its ultra-fine mesh is designed to catch splashes, which keeps the heating element cleaner and helps stop the unit from smoking when you're grilling fatty cuts. Anyone who has watched grease hit a hot element knows why that matters. The ceramic-coated grate is there to release food without sticking, so steaks, fish and other meats lift off cleanly instead of tearing. Both parts are removable and dishwasher safe, which turns cleanup into a two-minute job rather than a soak-and-scrub session.
The 100 paper liners do the disposable work — line the basket or tray, cook, toss. Between the reusable grate and shield and a hundred liners, this is the pick for someone who wants a real accessory set, not just a stack of paper.
The trade-off is narrowness. This is a compatibility-specific replacement-parts kit, so its value collapses if your grill model isn't on that list. The dimensions also tell you it's built around a compact indoor grill footprint, not a big oven tray. And if all you actually want is cheap disposable liners, you're paying for hardware you don't need. In my opinion, it's the strongest choice for the right owner and the wrong choice for everyone else.
Generic Air Fryer Sheets
That shape is the whole point. A round liner with a raised edge catches grease and crumbs instead of letting them run underneath, and because the foil is molded rather than flat, it holds its form while you load food in. For meat, vegetables and baked goods, it means the basket stays largely clean and you skip the washing-up step entirely.
Versatility is where this one earns its place. The manufacturer lists air fryers, ovens, microwaves and toaster ovens, covering baking, roasting, grilling and reheating. I like it as a general-purpose liner for anyone who moves between appliances — reheat leftovers in the microwave on one, roast vegetables in the air fryer with another. It's also a sensible pick for batch cooking or entertaining, where you're cycling through trays fast and don't want a sink full of greasy cookware.
Two honest caveats. First, aluminum foil liners are disposable by design — this is a consumables purchase, not a buy-once item, so plan on reordering. Second, the manufacturer notes that lighting and display angles can cause color differences and that manual measurement can introduce small size errors. That's a mild caution about fit: measure your basket before committing, because a liner that's too large won't sit flat and one that's too small lets drips past the edge. Also note the size options run 18.5 cm, 21.5 cm and 23.5 cm, and this listing is the 23.5 cm version — if you have a small basket, check whether that's actually the right one for you.
The Cabilock set takes the opposite approach to the Generic round liners: these are square sheets, 30 x 30 cm, in silver aluminum foil. Fifty of them, in a flat format rather than a molded cup.
Square is a real advantage on square and rectangular cooking surfaces. Round liners in a square basket leave four uncovered corners where grease and crumbs collect; a 30 cm square sheet covers the whole footprint. The generous size also suits oven trays and larger air fryer baskets, which is why I'd point oven-style air fryer owners here.
The trade-off is the format itself. A flat sheet has no raised edge, so it won't contain a pool of liquid the way a molded liner or a high-sided pan will — runny marinades and juicy roasts can still escape toward the edges. It's also a single-item package of sheets, with no reusable hardware included, so there's nothing here that survives more than one use. In my opinion, this is the right choice for dry-ish foods and larger trays: wings, chips, breaded snacks, baked goods. For a saucy casserole, look at the GLOGLOW pans instead.
GLOGLOW 5
The GLOGLOW set is the only pick here with genuine structure: five square aluminum foil pans with high edges. If your main complaint is that juices end up everywhere, this is the design that answers it.
High edges are the headline feature, and they're not cosmetic. The manufacturer designed them specifically to stop food juices from spilling out and to keep the oven and air fryer clean, which cuts down post-meal cleanup. Think of the difference between roasting chicken thighs on a flat sheet and roasting them in a shallow tray — the tray holds the render. The square shape is also claimed to promote more even heat distribution, which the brand ties to consistent grilling and baking results.
Because they're made from heat-resistant aluminum foil, GLOGLOW lists them for home ovens, air fryers and grills. That combination — a container you can move between appliances — makes them appealing for batch cooking, parties and outdoor events, where the brand positions them for use-and-toss convenience. Five pans means you can prep several different foods at once: meats, vegetables and desserts side by side, which is genuinely useful when you're feeding a group and don't want to cook in waves.
The trade-off: they're still disposable foil, so they're consumable and won't last like a metal pan. Five units also go quickly if you cook large meals often. And the listed color field reads "#511," which is a supplier code rather than a useful color description — treat the appearance as unknown and judge it on the material and shape instead. If you want maximum mess protection for juicy, saucy food, I'd take these over flat sheets.
How We Picked
I compared the published specs and features on each listing: material, dimensions, included components, stated compatibility and intended uses. Nothing here is based on hands-on testing. The order reflects my independent editorial opinion about which design suits which cooking situation — narrow compatibility and reusable hardware count for a lot, but so does broad everyday convenience. No brand paid for placement, and no brand saw this guide before you did.
Yes, when they're designed for it. All four picks here are listed as aluminum foil liners intended for air fryers, ovens, microwaves or grills, and the GLOGLOW pans are described as heat-resistant and durable at high temperatures. Just don't use a liner that blocks airflow around the basket, and never preheat with an empty lightweight liner sitting loose in the basket.
Under. Every product here is a base layer: the round and square sheets line the basket or tray, and the GLOGLOW pans hold the food directly. The Criditpid splatter shield is the exception — it sits above the food to catch grease before it reaches the heating element.
Measure your basket or tray first. The Generic liners come in 18.5 cm, 21.5 cm and 23.5 cm versions, and this listing is the 23.5 cm one. Cabilock's sheets are 30 x 30 cm, so they suit larger trays and oven-style cooking. Criditpid's grate is 10" x 10 1/8" and only fits the Ninja models listed. Too large and the liner curls up; too small and drips get past it.
They help with grease, but the specific fix for smoke is the Criditpid splatter shield — its fine mesh is designed to catch splashes and keep the heating element clean, which is what prevents smoking in the first place. Disposable liners mainly protect the basket and cut cleanup time.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer sheets, air fryer liners round, air fryer liners reusable