Tong Wang, Thomas R. Hopper*, Navendu Mondal, Sihui Liu, Chengning Yao, Xijia Zheng, Felice Torrisi, Artem A. Bakulin*

ACS Nano, 2023, 17, 7, 6330–6340

Transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) have shown outstanding semiconducting properties which make them promising materials for next-generation optoelectronic and electronic devices. These properties are imparted by fundamental carrier–carrier and carrier–phonon interactions that are foundational to hot carrier cooling. Recent transient absorption studies have reported ultrafast time scales for carrier cooling in TMDs that can be slowed at high excitation densities via a hot-phonon bottleneck (HPB) and discussed these findings in the light of optoelectronic applications. However, quantitative descriptions of the HPB in TMDs, including details of the electron–lattice coupling and how cooling is affected by the redistribution of energy between carriers, are still lacking. Here, we use femtosecond pump–push–probe spectroscopy as a single approach to systematically characterize the scattering of hot carriers with optical phonons, cold carriers, and defects in a benchmark TMD monolayer of polycrystalline WS2. By controlling the interband pump and intraband push excitations, we observe, in real-time (i) an extremely rapid “intrinsic” cooling rate of ∼18 ± 2.7 eV/ps, which can be slowed with increasing hot carrier density, (ii) the deprecation of this HPB at elevated cold carrier densities, exposing a previously undisclosed role of the carrier–carrier interactions in mediating cooling, and (iii) the interception of high energy hot carriers on the subpicosecond time scale by lattice defects, which may account for the lower photoluminescence yield of TMDs when excited above band gap.

Ben Carwithen, Thomas R. Hopper, Ziyuan Ge, Navendu Mondal, Tong Wang, Rozana Mazlumian, Xijia Zheng, Franziska Krieg, Federico Montanarella, Georgian Nedelcu, Martin Kroll, Miguel A. Siguan, Jarvist M. Frost, Karl Leo, Yana Vaynzof, Maryna Bodnarchuk, Maksym Kovalenko, Artem A. Bakulin*

ACS Nano, 2023, 17, 7, 6638–6648

The relaxation of the above-gap (“hot”) carriers in lead halide perovskites (LHPs) is important for applications in photovoltaics and offers insights into carrier–carrier and carrier–phonon interactions. However, the role of quantum confinement in the hot carrier dynamics of nanosystems is still disputed. Here, we devise a single approach, ultrafast pump–push–probe spectroscopy, to study carrier cooling in six different size-controlled LHP nanomaterials. In cuboidal nanocrystals, we observe only a weak size effect on the cooling dynamics. In contrast, two-dimensional systems show suppression of the hot phonon bottleneck effect common in bulk perovskites. The proposed kinetic model describes the intrinsic and density-dependent cooling times accurately in all studied perovskite systems using only carrier–carrier, carrier–phonon, and excitonic coupling constants. This highlights the impact of exciton formation on carrier cooling and promotes dimensional confinement as a tool for engineering carrier–phonon and carrier–carrier interactions in LHP optoelectronic materials.

Xijia Zheng, Thomas R. Hopper†*, Andrei Gorodetsky, Marios Maimaris, Weidong Xu, Bradley A. A. Martin, Jarvist M. Frost, Artem A. Bakulin

The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters, 2021, 12, 36, 8732–8739

Hot carriers in metal-halide perovskites (MHPs) present a foundation for understanding carrier-phonon coupling in the materials as well as the prospective development of high-performance hot carrier photovoltaics. While the carrier population dynamics during cooling have been scrutinized, the evolution of the hot carrier properties, namely mobility, remains largely unexplored. Here we introduce novel ultrafast visible pump–infrared push–terahertz probe spectroscopy to monitor the real-time conductivity dynamics of cooling carriers in methylammonium lead iodide. We find a decrease in mobility upon optically re-exciting the carriers, as expected for band transport. Surprisingly, the conductivity recovery is incommensurate with the hot carrier population dynamics measured by infrared probe and exhibits a negligible dependence on the hot carrier density. Our results reveal the importance of localized lattice heating toward the hot carrier mobility. This collective polaron-lattice phenomenon may contribute to the unusual photophysics of MHPs and should be accounted for in hot carrier devices.

Ziming Chen, Zhenchao Li, Thomas R. Hopper†, Artem A. Bakulin, Hin-Lap Yip*

Reports on Progress in Physics, 2021, 84 046401

Here we provide a comprehensive review of a newly developed lighting technology based on metal halide perovskites (i.e. perovskite light-emitting diodes) encompassing the research endeavours into materials, photophysics and device engineering. At the outset we survey the basic perovskite structures and their various dimensions (namely three-, two- and zero-dimensional perovskites), and demonstrate how the compositional engineering of these structures affects the perovskite light-emitting properties. Next, we turn to the physics underpinning photo- and electroluminescence in these materials through their connection to the fundamental excited states, energy/charge transport processes and radiative and non-radiative decay mechanisms. In the remainder of the review, we focus on the engineering of perovskite light-emitting diodes, including the history of their development as well as an extensive analysis of contemporary strategies for boosting device performance. Key concepts include balancing the electron/hole injection, suppression of parasitic carrier losses, improvement of the photoluminescence quantum yield and enhancement of the light extraction. Overall, this review reflects the current paradigm for perovskite lighting, and is intended to serve as a foundation to materials and device scientists newly working in this field.

Thomas R. Hopper†, Ahhyun Jeong, Andrei Gorodetsky, Maryna I. Krieg, Franziska, Bodnarchuk, Xiaokun Huang, Robert Lovrincic, Maksym V. Kovalenko, Artem A. Bakulin*

Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2020, 22, 17605-17611

The relaxation of high-energy “hot” carriers in semiconductors is known to involve the redistribution of energy between hot and cold carriers, as well as the transfer of energy from hot carriers to phonons. Over the past few years, these two processes have been identified in lead-halide perovskites (LHPs) using ultrafast pump–probe experiments, but their interplay is not fully understood. Here we present a practical and intuitive kinetic model that accounts for the effects of both hot and cold carriers on carrier relaxation in LHPs. We apply this model to describe the dynamics of hot carriers in bulk and nanocrystalline CsPbBr3 as observed by multi-pulse “pump–push–probe” spectroscopy. The model captures the slowing of the relaxation dynamics in the materials as the number of hot carriers increases, which has previously been explained by a “hot-phonon bottleneck” mechanism. The model also correctly predicts an acceleration of the relaxation kinetics as the number of cold carriers in the samples is increased. Using a series of natural approximations, we reduce our model to a simple form containing terms for the carrier–carrier and carrier–phonon interactions. The model can be instrumental for evaluating the details of carrier relaxation and carrier–phonon couplings in LHPs and other soft optoelectronic materials.

Thomas R. Hopper†, Andrei Gorodetsky, Ahhyun Jeong, Franziska Krieg, Maryna I. Bodnarchuk, Marios Maimaris, Marine Chaplain, Thomas J. Macdonald, Xiaokun Huang, Robert Lovrincic, Maksym V. Kovalenko, Artem A. Bakulin*

Nano Letters, 2020, 20, 4, 2271–2278

Carrier cooling is of widespread interest in the field of semiconductor science. It is linked to carrier–carrier and carrier–phonon coupling and has profound implications for the photovoltaic performance of materials. Recent transient optical studies have shown that a high carrier density in lead-halide perovskites (LHPs) can reduce the cooling rate through a “phonon bottleneck”. However, the role of carrier–carrier interactions, and the material properties that control cooling in LHPs, is still disputed. To address these factors, we utilize ultrafast “pump–push–probe” spectroscopy on LHP nanocrystal (NC) films. We find that the addition of cold carriers to LHP NCs increases the cooling rate, competing with the phonon bottleneck. By comparing different NCs and bulk samples, we deduce that the cooling behavior is intrinsic to the LHP composition and independent of the NC size or surface. This can be contrasted with other colloidal nanomaterials, where confinement and trapping considerably influence the cooling dynamics.

Michelle S. Vezie, Mohammed Azzouzi, Andrew M. Telford, Thomas R. Hopper, Alexander B. Sieval, Jan C. Hummelen, Kealan Fallon, Hugo Bronstein, Thomas Kirchartz, Artem A. Bakulin, Tracey M. Clarke, and Jenny Nelson*

ACS Energy Letters, 2019, 4, 9, 2096–2103

The energetic offset between the initial photoexcited state and charge-transfer (CT) state in organic heterojunction solar cells influences both charge generation and open-circuit voltage (Voc). Here, we use time-resolved spectroscopy and voltage loss measurements to analyze the effect of the exciton–CT state offset on charge transfer, separation, and recombination processes in blends of a low-band-gap polymer (INDT-S) with fullerene derivatives of different electron affinity (PCBM and KL). For the lower exciton–CT state offset blend (INDT-S:PCBM), both photocurrent generation and nonradiative voltage losses are lower. The INDT-S:PCBM blend shows different excited-state dynamics depending on whether the donor or acceptor is photoexcited. Surprisingly, the charge recombination dynamics in INDT-S:PCBM are distinctly faster than those in INDT-S:KL upon excitation of the donor. We reconcile these observations using a kinetic model and by considering hybridization between the lowest excitonic and CT states. The modeling results show that this hybridization can significantly reduce Voc losses while still allowing reasonable charge generation efficiency.

Thomas R. Hopper†, Deping Qian, Liyan Yang, Xiaohui Wang, Ke Zhou, Rhea Kumar, Wei Ma, Chang He, Jianhui Hou, Feng Gao, Artem A. Bakulin*

Chemistry of Materials, 2019, 31, 17, 6860–6869

In contemporary organic solar cell (OSC) research, small A-D-A molecules comprising electron donor (D) and acceptor (A) units are increasingly used as a means to control the optoelectronic properties of photovoltaic blends. Slight structural variations to these A-D-A molecules can result in profound changes to the performance of the OSCs. Herein, we study two A-D-A molecules, BTCN-O and BTCN-M, which are identical in structure apart from a subtle difference in the position of alkyl chains, which force the molecules to adopt different equilibrium conformations. These steric effects cause the respective molecules to work better as an electron donor and acceptor when blended with benchmark acceptor and donor materials (PC71BM and PBDB-T). We study the photophysics of these “D:A” blends and devices using a combination of steady-state and time-resolved spectroscopic techniques. Time-resolved photoluminescence reveals the impact of the molecular conformation on the quenching of the A-D-A emission when BTCN-O and BTCN-M are blended with PBDB-T or PC71BM. Ultrafast broadband transient absorption spectroscopy demonstrates that the dynamics of charge separation are essentially identical when comparing BTCN-M and BTCN-O based blends, but the recombination dynamics are quite dissimilar. This suggests that the device performance is ultimately determined by the morphology of the blends imposed by the A-D-A conformation. This notion is supported by X-ray scattering measurements on the “D:A” films, electroluminescence data, and pump–push-photocurrent spectroscopy on the “D:A” devices. Our findings provide insight into the remarkable structure–function relationship in A-D-A molecules and emphasize the need for careful morphological and energetic considerations when designing high-performance OSCs.

Fritz Nübling, Thomas R. Hopper, Brooke Kuei, Hartmut Komber, Viktoriia Untilova, Simon B. Schmidt, Martin Brinkmann, Enrique D. Gomez, Artem A. Bakulin, Michael Sommer*

ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2019, 11, 1, 1143–1155

Junction-functionalized donor–acceptor (D–A) block copolymers (BCPs) enable spatial and electronic control over interfacial charge dynamics in excitonic devices such as solar cells. Here, we present the design, synthesis, morphology, and electronic characterization of block junction-functionalized, all-conjugated, all-crystalline D–A BCPs. Poly(3-hexylthiophene) (P3HT), a single thienylated diketopyrrolopyrrole (ThxDPPThx, x = 1 or 2) unit, and poly{[N,N′-bis(2-octyldodecyl)-naphthalene-1,4,5,8-bis(dicarboximide)-2,6-diyl]-alt-5,5′-(2,2′-bithiophene)} (PNDIT2) are used as donor, interfacial unit, and acceptor, respectively. Almost all C–C coupling steps are accomplished by virtue of C–H activation. Synthesis of the macroreagent H-P3HT-ThxDPPThx, with x determining its C–H reactivity, is key to the synthesis of various BCPs of type H-P3HT-ThxDPPThx-block-PNDIT2. Morphology is determined from a combination of calorimetry, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and thin-film scattering. Block copolymer crystallinity of P3HT and PNDIT2 is reduced, indicating frustrated crystallization. A long period lp is invisible from TEM, but shows up in resonant soft X-ray scattering experiments at a length scale of lp ∼ 60 nm. Photoluminescence of H-P3HT-ThxDPPThx indicates efficient transfer of the excitation energy to the DPP chain end, but is quenched in BCP films. Transient absorption and pump–push photocurrent spectroscopies reveal geminate recombination (GR) as the main loss channel in as-prepared BCP films independent of junction functionalization. Melt annealing increases GR as a result of the low degree of crystallinity and poorly defined interfaces and additionally changes backbone orientation of PNDIT2 from face-on to edge-on. These morphological effects dominate solar cell performance and cause an insensitivity to the presence of the block junction.

Jiangbin Zhang, Bin Kan, Andrew J Pearson, Andrew J Parnell, Joshaniel FK Cooper, Xiao-Ke Liu, Patrick J Conaghan, Thomas R. Hopper, Yutian Wu, Xiangjian Wan, Feng Gao, Neil C Greenham, Artem A Bakulin, Yongsheng Chen*, Richard H Friend*

Journal of Materials Chemistry A, 2018, 6, 18225-18233

Non-fullerene acceptors (NFAs) have recently outperformed their fullerene counterparts in binary bulk-heterojunction (BHJ) organic solar cells (OSCs). Further development of NFA OSCs may benefit other novel OSC device structures that alter or extend the standard BHJ concept. Here, we report such a new processing route that forms a BHJ-like morphology between sequentially processed polymer donor and NFA with high power conversion efficiencies in excess of 10%. Both devices show similar charge generation and recombination behaviours, supporting formation of similar BHJ active layers. We correlate the ∼30 meV smaller open-circuit voltage in sq-BHJ devices to more substantial non-radiative recombination by voltage loss analysis. We also determine the exciton diffusion length of benchmark polymer PBDB-T to be 10 ± 3 nm. Our results demonstrate high-efficiency OSC devices using sequential deposition method and provide new opportunities to further improve performance of state-of-the-art OSCs.

Thomas R. Hopper†, Andrei Gorodetsky, Jarvist M. Frost, Christian Müller, Robert Lovrincic, Artem A. Bakulin*

ACS Energy Letters, 2018, 3 (9), 2199–2205

The rapid relaxation of above-band-gap “hot” carriers (HCs) imposes the key efficiency limit in lead-halide perovskite (LHP) solar cells. Recent studies have indicated that HC cooling in these systems may be sensitive to materials composition, as well as the energy and density of excited states. However, the key parameters underpinning the cooling mechanism are currently under debate. Here we use a sequence of ultrafast optical pulses (visible pump–infrared push–infrared probe) to directly compare the intraband cooling dynamics in five common LHPs: FAPbI3, FAPbBr3, MAPbI3, MAPbBr3, and CsPbBr3. We observe ∼100–900 fs cooling times, with slower cooling at higher HC densities. This effect is strongest in the all-inorganic Cs-based system, compared to the hybrid analogues with organic cations. These observations, together with band structure calculations, allow us to quantify the origin of the “hot-phonon bottleneck” in LHPs and assert the thermodynamic contribution of a symmetry-breaking organic cation toward rapid HC cooling.

Deping Qian, Zilong Zheng, Huifeng Yao, Wolfgang Tress, Thomas R. Hopper, Shula Chen, Sunsun Li, Jing Liu, Shangshang Chen, Jiangbin Zhang, Xiao-Ke Liu, Bowei Gao, Liangqi Ouyang, Yingzhi Jin, Galia Pozina, Irina A. Buyanova, Weimin M Chen, Olle Inganäs, Veaceslav Coropceanu*, Jean-Luc Bredas, He Yan, Jianhui Hou, Fengling Zhang, Artem A. Bakulin*, Feng Gao*

Nature Materials 2018, 17, 703–709

The open-circuit voltage of organic solar cells is usually lower than the values achieved in inorganic or perovskite photovoltaic devices with comparable bandgaps. Energy losses during charge separation at the donor–acceptor interface and non-radiative recombination are among the main causes of such voltage losses. Here we combine spectroscopic and quantum-chemistry approaches to identify key rules for minimizing voltage losses: (1) a low energy offset between donor and acceptor molecular states and (2) high photoluminescence yield of the low-gap material in the blend. Following these rules, we present a range of existing and new donor–acceptor systems that combine efficient photocurrent generation with electroluminescence yield up to 0.03%, leading to non-radiative voltage losses as small as 0.21 V. This study provides a rationale to explain and further improve the performance of recently demonstrated high-open-circuit-voltage organic solar cells.

Andreas Weu, Thomas R. Hopper†, Vincent Lami, Joshua A. Kreß, Artem A. Bakulin*, and Yana Vaynzof

Chemistry of Materials, 2018, 30, 8, 2660–2667

Understanding the photophysics of charge generation in organic semiconductors is a critical step toward the further optimization of organic solar cells. The separation of electron–hole pairs in systems with large energy offsets is relatively well-understood; however, the photophysics in blends with low driving energy remains unclear. Herein, we use the material system PffBT4T-2OD:PC71BM as an example to show that the built-in electric field plays a critical role toward long-range charge separation in high-performance devices. By using steady-state and time-resolved spectroscopic techniques, we show that in neat films an energetic barrier impedes polymer exciton dissociation, preventing charge transfer to the fullerene acceptor. In complete devices, this barrier is diminished due to the built-in electric field provided by the interlayers/contacts and accompanying space-charge distribution. The observed behavior could also be relevant to other systems with low driving energy and emphasizes the importance of using complete devices, rather than solely films, for photophysical studies.